Wikipedia:WikiProject Middle-earth/Article alerts/Archive 1

Archives

This is an archive of previous Article Alert reports. This page is automatically updated by AAlertBot. Entries and content can be added/removed/changed manually, as long as {{anchor|archivebottom}} and the workflow anchors {{anchor|AfD}}/{{anchor|AfDbottom}}, {{anchor|GAN}}/{{anchor|GANbottom}}, etc. aren't removed.

GAN

19 Aug 2011 – Quenya GA nominated by De728631 was not promoted; discussion
10 Dec 2012 – Quenya GA nominated by De728631 was promoted; discussion
04 Dec 2014 – Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted; discussion
11 Feb 2016 – Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor GA nominated by AdrianGamer was promoted by Jaguar; discussion
08 Aug 2016 – Cirth GA nominated by Asþont was not promoted by Sagecandor; discussion
26 Jun 2017 – Elf GA nominated by Alarichall was promoted by Farang Rak Tham; discussion
16 Apr 2018 – Dragon GA nominated by Katolophyromai was not promoted by Squeamish Ossifrage; discussion
02 Feb 2020 – Harad GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by J Milburn; discussion
08 Feb 2020 – Rohan (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
24 Feb 2020 – Smaug GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – The Hobbit (2003 video game) GA nominated by Thylacinus cynocephalus was closed; discussion
14 Feb 2020 – The Scouring of the Shire GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Jack Upland; discussion
29 Feb 2020 – Lothlórien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
06 Mar 2020 – Isengard GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
15 Feb 2020 – Battle of Helm's Deep GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
09 Feb 2020 – Gondor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
20 Feb 2020 – Moria (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by JavaHurricane; discussion
25 Feb 2020 – Shire (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
11 Feb 2020 – The Tale of Aragorn and Arwen GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Guettarda; discussion
05 Apr 2020 – Gandalf GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
09 Apr 2020 – Tom Bombadil GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
14 Mar 2020 – Orc GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Valereee; discussion
05 Apr 2020 – Frodo Baggins GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Cerebellum; discussion
17 Apr 2020 – Númenor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
19 Apr 2020 – Gollum GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
17 Apr 2020 – Troll (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Dyveldi; discussion
26 Apr 2020 – Battle of the Pelennor Fields GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
29 Apr 2020 – Watcher in the Water GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
30 Apr 2020 – Gríma Wormtongue GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
30 Apr 2020 – Éowyn GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
27 Apr 2020 – Palantír GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
04 May 2020 – Mirkwood GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
10 May 2020 – Samwise Gamgee GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
05 May 2020 – Thorin Oakenshield GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Cavie78; discussion
28 Mar 2020 – Themes of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Juliette Han; discussion
18 May 2020 – Merry Brandybuck GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
09 May 2020 – Bilbo Baggins GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by JavaHurricane; discussion
19 May 2020 – Pippin Took GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
15 May 2020 – Poetry in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Yakikaki; discussion
23 May 2020 – Nazgûl GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
31 May 2020 – Legolas GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
04 Jun 2020 – Radagast GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
30 May 2020 – Galadriel GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
11 Jun 2020 – Impression of depth in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Aza24; discussion
11 Jun 2020 – Trees and forests in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Yakikaki; discussion
14 Jun 2020 – Sauron GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
03 Jul 2020 – Battle of the Morannon GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Whiteguru; discussion
17 Jul 2020 – Tolkien's artwork GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Aza24; discussion
02 Jul 2020 – Éomer GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Whiteguru; discussion
08 Jul 2020 – Named weapons in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
06 Jul 2020 – Mordor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
02 Jul 2020 – Elf (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Whiteguru; discussion
13 Apr 2020 – J. R. R. Tolkien's influences GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ffranc; discussion
03 Aug 2020 – The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ovinus Real; discussion
15 May 2020 – Aragorn GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
18 Aug 2020 – Rivendell GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
25 Aug 2020 – Warg GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
25 Aug 2020 – Ent GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
12 Jul 2020 – Wizards (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
21 Jul 2020 – Women in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
22 Jun 2020 – Hobbit GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by The Most Comfortable Chair; discussion
04 Jul 2020 – One Ring GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
15 May 2020 – Aragorn GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
22 Jun 2020 – Hobbit GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by The Most Comfortable Chair; discussion
04 Jul 2020 – One Ring GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
12 Jul 2020 – Wizards (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
21 Jul 2020 – Women in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
25 Aug 2020 – Warg GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
25 Aug 2020 – Ent GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
08 Dec 2020 – The Hobbit (2003 video game) GA nominated by Thylacinus cynocephalus was not promoted; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – Tolkien's maps GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
09 Oct 2020 – Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Willbb234; discussion
30 Dec 2020 – Dwarf (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Whiteguru; discussion
10 Mar 2021 – Christianity in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Vaticidalprophet; discussion
16 Feb 2021 – Balrog GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
07 Jan 2021 – Barrow-wight GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by RoySmith; discussion
24 Mar 2021 – Arwen GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Guettarda; discussion
26 Aug 2020 – The Lord of the Rings: film versus book GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was not promoted by David Fuchs; discussion
18 Aug 2020 – Rivendell GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ardenter; discussion
05 Apr 2021 – Rings of Power GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Guettarda; discussion
08 Apr 2021 – The Silmarillion GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TeenAngels1234; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – Errantry GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Tkbrett; discussion
25 Apr 2021 – Khraniteli GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Some Dude From North Carolina; discussion
30 May 2021 – Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Michael Martinez; discussion
24 Mar 2021 – Goldberry GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
17 Feb 2021 – Théoden GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
17 Feb 2021 – Denethor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Willbb234; discussion
21 May 2021 – Time travel in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
13 Mar 2021 – Man (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
12 Feb 2021 – Beowulf in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
19 Apr 2021 – Peter Jackson's interpretation of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Some Dude From North Carolina; discussion
03 Jul 2021 – Treebeard GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Harper J. Cole; discussion
01 May 2021 – England in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Haleth; discussion
15 Jul 2021 – Shelob GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
16 Jul 2021 – The Sea-Bell GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Some Dude From North Carolina; discussion
09 May 2021 – Tolkien's frame stories GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Haleth; discussion
03 Jul 2021 – Proverbs in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Pax85; discussion
03 Jul 2021 – Interlacing in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Iazyges; discussion
01 Aug 2021 – Tolkien and race GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Iazyges; discussion
02 Jul 2021 – Sexuality in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Iazyges; discussion
30 Sep 2021 – Character pairing in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by DMT Biscuit; discussion
22 Sep 2021 – Magic in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by The Most Comfortable Chair; discussion
20 Sep 2021 – Heroism in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by REDMAN 2019; discussion
19 Oct 2021 – Splintered Light GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Olivaw-Daneel; discussion
29 Sep 2021 – Paganism in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Skytheunicorn; discussion
28 Oct 2021 – Tolkien and the Great War GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by KeeperOfThePeace; discussion
24 Sep 2021 – Decline and fall in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Cerebellum; discussion
24 Sep 2021 – Tolkien's style GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Sennalen; discussion
20 Sep 2021 – Plants in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
20 Sep 2021 – Music of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Jens Lallensack; discussion
19 Oct 2021 – The Road to Middle-Earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
20 Sep 2021 – Addiction to power in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
19 Oct 2021 – Tolkien: A Cultural Phenomenon GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
19 Oct 2021 – A Companion to J. R. R. Tolkien GA nominated by Piotrus was promoted by Olivaw-Daneel; discussion
19 Oct 2021 – Tolkien: Maker of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Usernameunique; discussion
18 Nov 2021 – Beowulf: A Translation and Commentary GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
05 Jan 2022 – The Council of Elrond GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
05 Nov 2021 – Tolkien and the modernists GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
22 Oct 2021 – J. R. R. Tolkien: Author of the Century GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Olivaw-Daneel; discussion
31 Dec 2021 – Hobitit GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
30 Nov 2021 – Tom Shippey GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
10 Jan 2022 – Christopher Lee GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
27 Nov 2021 – Eärendil and Elwing GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by RockMagnetist; discussion
01 Jan 2022 – The Shadow of the Past GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
26 Oct 2021 – Reception of J. R. R. Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Asilvering; discussion
04 Jan 2022 – Bored of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
12 Jan 2022 – Song of Eärendil GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
15 Jan 2022 – History of Arda GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
15 Jan 2022 – Middle-earth in film GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
20 Oct 2021 – The Worlds of J. R. R. Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Usernameunique; discussion
18 Jan 2022 – Heraldry of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
19 Jan 2022 – Environmentalism in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
19 Jan 2022 – The Road Goes Ever On (song) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2022 – Tolkien and the medieval GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
03 Nov 2021 – The Great War and Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
28 Jan 2022 – Celebrimbor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
28 Jan 2022 – Tolkien's monsters GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
28 Jan 2022 – Elendil GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AirshipJungleman29; discussion
21 Feb 2022 – The Road Goes Ever On (song) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by No Great Shaker; discussion
20 Feb 2022 – Glorfindel GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
18 Aug 2020 – Rivendell GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ardenter; discussion
26 Aug 2020 – The Lord of the Rings: film versus book GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed by David Fuchs; discussion
09 Oct 2020 – Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Willbb234; discussion
30 Dec 2020 – Dwarf (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Whiteguru; discussion
07 Jan 2021 – Barrow-wight GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by RoySmith; discussion
12 Feb 2021 – Beowulf in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – Errantry GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Tkbrett; discussion
15 Feb 2021 – Tolkien's maps GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Hog Farm; discussion
16 Feb 2021 – Balrog GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
17 Feb 2021 – Théoden GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
17 Feb 2021 – Denethor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Willbb234; discussion
28 Feb 2022 – Half-elf GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Casliber; discussion
02 Mar 2022 – Sound and language in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
14 Mar 2022 – Elrond GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TeenAngels1234; discussion
21 May 2022 – Ent GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AirshipJungleman29; discussion
19 Feb 2022 – Fingolfin GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Figureskatingfan; discussion
17 Mar 2022 – Poems and Songs of Middle Earth GA nominated by Blz 2049 was promoted by Figureskatingfan; discussion
21 May 2022 – Bagme Bloma GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Artem.G; discussion
29 May 2022 – Tom Shippey GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
14 Jan 2022 – The Tolkien Ensemble GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by The Most Comfortable Chair; discussion
15 Jun 2022 – Gil-galad GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Alan Islas; discussion
16 Jun 2022 – Balin (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Amitchell125; discussion
21 May 2022 – Isildur GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
21 May 2022 – Warg GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
21 May 2022 – Tolkien's Middle-earth family trees GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
11 Jun 2022 – Sundering of the Elves GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
14 Jun 2022 – Tolkien's Art: 'A Mythology for England' GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
16 Jun 2022 – Gimli (Middle-earth) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
21 Jun 2022 – Ainulindalë GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Mike Christie; discussion
21 May 2022 – Christopher Lee GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Realmaxxver; discussion
27 Sep 2022 – Literary hostility to J. R. R. Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
01 Jul 2022 – Thranduil GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by ThadeusOfNazereth; discussion
10 Oct 2022 – Morgoth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Craffael.09; discussion
01 Nov 2022 – Black Speech GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by ArcticSeeress; discussion
30 Sep 2022 – Noldor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
04 Oct 2022 – Dragons in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
10 Oct 2022 – Silmarils GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BetterCallSaulKripke; discussion
21 Oct 2022 – A Elbereth Gilthoniel GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
08 Nov 2022 – Morgoth GA nominated by VickKiang was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
10 Oct 2022 – Fëanor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
18 Nov 2022 – Lúthien and Beren GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
10 Nov 2022 – The Atlas of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Unexpectedlydian; discussion
02 Oct 2022 – Tuor and Idril GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
30 Nov 2022 – Eagles in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
30 Sep 2022 – Red Book of Westmarch GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
08 Sep 2022 – The Road Goes Ever On GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
19 Nov 2022 – Túrin Turambar GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
21 Sep 2022 – Shakespeare's influence on Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
22 Jan 2023 – Namárië GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
16 Nov 2022 – Cosmology of Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
21 Oct 2022 – Valar in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
10 Nov 2022 – Geography of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
29 Jan 2023 – Tolkien and the medieval GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
01 Feb 2023 – Bree, Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
02 Feb 2023 – Thingol GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
09 Feb 2023 – Old Man Willow GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
13 Feb 2023 – Tolkien's sentience dilemma GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
21 Feb 2023 – Luck and fate in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by LunaEatsTuna; discussion
30 Aug 2022 – Architecture in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Benji man; discussion
16 Oct 2022 – Psychological journeys of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
08 Feb 2023 – Narrative structure of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
18 Feb 2023 – Legends (play-by-mail game) GA nominated by Airborne84 was promoted by Lee Vilenski; discussion
21 Feb 2023 – Northern courage in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
09 Dec 2022 – Music of The Lord of the Rings film series GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Jonathanischoice; discussion
06 Feb 2023 – Beleriand GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by MyCatIsAChonk; discussion
24 Feb 2023 – Ancestry as guide to character in Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
01 Mar 2023 – Quests in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
21 Mar 2023 – Psychological journeys of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
22 Mar 2023 – Narrative structure of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
05 Mar 2023 – Beorn GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by GimliDotNet; discussion
30 Mar 2023 – Tolkien and the Norse GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by GimliDotNet; discussion
24 Mar 2023 – Tolkien and the classical world GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
16 Apr 2023 – Middle-earth: Shadow of War GA nominated by OceanHok was promoted by Shooterwalker; discussion
30 Mar 2023 – The Last Ringbearer GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
02 Apr 2023 – Tolkien's modern sources GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
03 Jun 2023 – Narrative structure of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
16 Jan 2023 – The Keys of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Grnrchst; discussion
23 Mar 2023 – The Notion Club Papers GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
13 Feb 2023 – Picturing Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Grnrchst; discussion
17 Nov 2022 – Master of Middle-Earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
30 Mar 2023 – Northern courage in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
05 Jul 2023 – Ancestry as guide to character in Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
06 May 2023 – Quests in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
26 Mar 2023 – Tolkien and the Celtic GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
01 Jul 2023 – Death and immortality in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
24 Jun 2023 – Psychological journeys of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
04 Jul 2023 – Narrative structure of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
22 Mar 2023 – A Tolkien Compass GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
21 Jul 2023 – Tolkien and the Classical World (book) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
23 Jul 2023 – Two Trees of Valinor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
27 Jul 2023 – Melian in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
28 Jul 2023 – Gondolin GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
28 Jul 2023 – Leaf by Niggle GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by 1TWO3Writer; discussion
29 Jul 2023 – Elijah Wood GA nominated by Lord Theoden was not promoted by Pamzeis; discussion
30 Jul 2023 – Witch-king of Angmar GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
25 Jul 2023 – Unfinished Tales GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
27 Jul 2023 – Ancestry as guide to character in Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
31 Jul 2023 – Perilous Realms GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
31 Jul 2023 – Smith of Wootton Major GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Frzzl; discussion
01 Aug 2023 – Tolkien: A Look Behind The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Premeditated Chaos; discussion
30 Jul 2023 – Farmer Giles of Ham GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
17 Aug 2023 – Understanding The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by AryKun; discussion
15 Aug 2023 – Finnish influences on Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Golden; discussion
22 Aug 2023 – The Children of Húrin GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Vanamonde93; discussion
12 Oct 2023 – Mithril GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ldm1954; discussion
25 Oct 2023 – Ramble On GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Vaughan J.; discussion
16 Aug 2023 – Lonely Mountain GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
18 Aug 2023 – Forests in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
24 Aug 2023 – Húrin GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Frzzl; discussion
29 Oct 2023 – Languages constructed by J. R. R. Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Generalissima; discussion
16 Aug 2023 – Translation of The Lord of the Rings into Swedish GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ealdgyth; discussion
04 Jan 2024 – Tolkien's ambiguity GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
03 Nov 2023 – Mental illness in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
02 Nov 2023 – Minas Tirith GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Ligaturama; discussion
10 Aug 2023 – Tolkien's impact on fantasy GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Tea with toast; discussion
12 Jan 2024 – Forests in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Seltaeb Eht; discussion
16 Aug 2023 – Valinor GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
27 Jan 2024 – Ian Holm GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by BennyOnTheLoose; discussion
10 Aug 2023 – Corey Olsen GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Averageuntitleduser; discussion
27 Jan 2024 – Elijah Wood GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Cocobb8; discussion
20 Aug 2023 – Ancestry as guide to character in Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by ZombiUwU; discussion
18 Jul 2023 – Economy of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Reidgreg; discussion
13 Jan 2024 – Literary devices in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by CipherSleuth; discussion
05 Jan 2024 – Tolkien and antiquarianism GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Heavy Grasshopper; discussion
02 Sep 2023 – Philology and Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Averageuntitleduser; discussion
03 Nov 2023 – A Secret Vice GA nominated by Frzzl was promoted by UndercoverClassicist; discussion
22 Jan 2024 – Anachronism in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
08 Nov 2023 – Illustrating Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Cocobb8; discussion
22 Mar 2024 – Pauline Baynes GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Simongraham; discussion
25 Jan 2024 – J. R. R. Tolkien's ambiguity GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Rachel Helps (BYU); discussion
10 Feb 2024 – Music of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power GA nominated by Adamstom.97 was promoted by Heidi Pusey BYU; discussion
22 May 2024 – Translating The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
07 Jun 2024 – The Etymologies (Tolkien) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Remsense; discussion
09 Jun 2024 – Margaret Carroux GA nominated by Kusma was promoted by Chiswick Chap; discussion
11 May 2024 – Pseudotranslation in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Generalissima; discussion
05 Mar 2024 – Christian light in Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by SnowFire; discussion
22 Jun 2024 – The History of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Kusma; discussion
03 Jun 2024 – Christopher Tolkien GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by MSincccc; discussion
29 May 2024 – Round World Version of Tolkien's legendarium GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
20 May 2024 – A mythology for England GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by FishLoveHam; discussion
27 Jun 2024 – Phial of Galadriel GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by TompaDompa; discussion
26 Jan 2024 – Mental illness in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by Eewilson; discussion
18 Sep 2024 – Tolkien's round world dilemma GA nominated by Vacant0 was promoted by Closed Limelike Curves; discussion
20 Sep 2024 – Elvish languages of Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
15 Jul 2024 – Dreams and visions in Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
28 Sep 2024 – Company of the Ring GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
07 Jul 2024 – Storytelling in The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
25 Mar 2024 – Tolkien, Race and Cultural History GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
21 May 2024 – The Lord of the Rings (1955 radio series) GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
23 May 2024 – Editorial framing of The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
17 Jun 2024 – Lhammas GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
03 Jul 2024 – Westron GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
26 Jul 2024 – Constructing The Lord of the Rings GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
18 Aug 2024 – Hell and Middle-earth GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
03 Aug 2024 – The Fellowship of the Ring GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by DoctorWhoFan91; discussion

AfD

11 Nov 2011 – The Black Book of Arda AfDed by StAnselm was deleted; discussion
28 Dec 2011 – Red Arrow (Middle-earth) AfDed by Anthony Appleyard was closed as redirect by Arbitrarily0 on 05 Jan 2012; discussion
30 Dec 2011 – Laiquendi AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by Armbrust on 06 Jan 2012; discussion
27 Feb 2012 – Ainulindalë AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as keep by Tom Morris on 06 Mar 2012; discussion
05 Aug 2012 – Narsil AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by The Bushranger on 13 Aug 2012; discussion
11 Aug 2012 – Imrahil AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as redirect by Mark Arsten on 18 Aug 2012; discussion
17 Sep 2012 – Nedaphadrimeru AfDed by De728631 was deleted; discussion
24 Sep 2012 – The Hobbit (1985 film) AfDed by Go Phightins! was closed as keep by Drmies on 01 Oct 2012; discussion
18 Nov 2012 – Music of The Hobbit film series AfDed by Razr Nation was closed as merge by MBisanz on 26 Nov 2012; discussion
09 Dec 2012 – Gothmog (Third Age) AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as no consensus by Michig on 24 Dec 2012; discussion
01 May 2013 – Argon (Middle-earth) AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as delete by Black Kite on 09 May 2013; discussion
13 Sep 2013 – Thangorodrim AfDed by TTN was closed as keep by Mark Arsten on 06 Oct 2013; discussion
05 Dec 2013 – Lalaith AfDed by Crisco 1492 was closed as no consensus by Sandstein on 30 Dec 2013; discussion
14 Mar 2014 – The Scouring of the Shire AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as keep by Mojo Hand on 22 Mar 2014; discussion
07 Apr 2014 – Minas Morgul AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as no consensus by King of Hearts on 23 Apr 2014; discussion
01 Jun 2014 – A Walking Song AfDed by Ricky81682 was closed as no consensus by Northamerica1000 on 25 Jun 2014; discussion
22 Dec 2014 – Elanor Gardner AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by Courcelles on 16 Jan 2015; discussion
14 Mar 2015 – Hithlum AfDed by AadaamS was closed as no consensus by Nakon on 07 Apr 2015; discussion
14 Dec 2015 – Halfling AfDed by Ceosad was closed as keep by Davey2010 on 27 Dec 2015; discussion
25 Mar 2016 – Fingon AfDed by AadaamS was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 16 Apr 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Finrod Felagund AfDed by AadaamS was closed as keep by MBisanz on 09 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Curufin AfDed by AadaamS was closed as keep by David Fuchs on 11 May 2016; discussion
14 Dec 2015 – Halfling AfDed by Ceosad was closed as keep by Davey2010 on 27 Dec 2015; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Caranthir AfDed by AadaamS was closed as delete by Swarm on 14 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Caranthir AfDed by AadaamS was closed as delete by Swarm on 14 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Maglor AfDed by AadaamS was closed as no consensus by Sjakkalle on 14 May 2016; discussion
11 Jun 2016 – Halbarad AfDed by Quasihuman was closed as redirect by Northamerica1000 on 18 Jun 2016; discussion
06 Aug 2016 – The Two Towers (MUD) AfDed by Czar was closed as delete by Sandstein on 21 Aug 2016; discussion
12 Sep 2016 – Catherine Karina Chmiel AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 27 Sep 2016; discussion
06 Aug 2016 – The Two Towers (MUD) AfDed by Czar was closed as delete by Sandstein on 21 Aug 2016; discussion
07 Jan 2017 – Gift of Men AfDed by Joshualouie711 was closed as delete by King of Hearts on 14 Jan 2017; discussion
04 Apr 2017 – Farmer Maggot AfDed by Hijiri88 was closed as keep by Feminist on 20 Apr 2017; discussion
19 Apr 2017 – Minor battles in The Lord of the Rings AfDed by Izno was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Apr 2017; discussion
15 Jul 2017 – Fountain guards AfDed by Moduin was closed as delete by Ritchie333 on 30 Jul 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Húrin AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Bëor AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Finwë AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Telcontar AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – Hador AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
13 Mar 2018 – Ceorl (Middle-earth) AfDed by Mdwicker was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 21 Mar 2018; discussion
09 Apr 2018 – Eärnil II AfDed by Yellow Diamond was closed as redirect by RoySmith on 17 Apr 2018; discussion
10 Apr 2018 – Fíriel AfDed by Yellow Diamond was closed as delete by Spartaz on 18 Apr 2018; discussion
13 Aug 2018 – Adventures in Middle-earth AfDed by Chetsford was closed as keep by SoWhy on 22 Aug 2018; discussion
09 Oct 2018 – Fëa and hröa AfDed by Joshualouie711 was closed as delete by RoySmith on 17 Oct 2018; discussion
25 May 2019 – Fredegar Bolger AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by ST47 on 02 Jun 2019; discussion
09 Oct 2019 – Eönwë AfDed by TTN was closed as redirect by Tone on 24 Oct 2019; discussion
28 Oct 2019 – Thuringwethil AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by Tone on 12 Nov 2019; discussion
06 Nov 2019 – Anduin AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 13 Nov 2019; discussion
07 Nov 2019 – Paths of the Dead AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 14 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Dead Men of Dunharrow AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 19 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Forlong the Fat AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 19 Nov 2019; discussion
13 Nov 2019 – Fords of Isen AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Wizard (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Scottywong on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Radagast AfDed by Piotrus was closed as keep by Scottywong on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Daughters of Finwë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Blue Wizards AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Werewolf (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Thain (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Middle-earth roads AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – House of Elendil AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Bradv on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
15 Nov 2019 – Aulë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 22 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – The Scouring of the Shire AfDed by Piotrus was closed as keep by ST47 on 24 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – Barliman Butterbur AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 24 Nov 2019; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Mouth of Sauron AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Tone on 25 Nov 2019; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Sun and Moon (Middle-earth) AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Queen Berúthiel AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as merge by Tone on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
27 Nov 2019 – Battle of the Hornburg (initially Gamling) AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as keep by Tone on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Nandor (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Sgeureka on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Hithlum AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
21 Nov 2019 – Ælfwine of England AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as keep by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – Minor places in Middle-earth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Angband AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Bëor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Caradhras AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Edain AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Eriador AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Finduilas of Dol Amroth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Háma (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Huorn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Nargothrond AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Manwë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Warg (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – List of Middle-earth rivers AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Barkeep49 on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – List of Middle-earth animals AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Lord Roem on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – Middle-earth plants AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Lord Roem on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Ulmo AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by BD2412 on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – White Council AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – Half-elven AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – Round World version of the Silmarillion AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Easterlings (First Age) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 05 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Easterlings AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 05 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Melian AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Esgaroth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as no consensus by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Caras Galadhon AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Celeborn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Varda AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
29 Nov 2019 – Uinen AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
29 Nov 2019 – Glaurung AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Minor places in Beleriand AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Czar on 07 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Ecthelion of the Fountain AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 07 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Pelendur AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Malbeth the Seer AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Maeglin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Mardil Voronwë AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Vorondil AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – House of Haleth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Tone on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Turgon AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Aerin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Dorlas AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Manthor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by AustralianRupert on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Boldog AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Wise (Edain) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – List of Middle-earth Lego sets AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Men of Twilight AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Elfhelm AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
03 Dec 2019 – Tirion AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
03 Dec 2019 – Stewards of Gondor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
04 Dec 2019 – Avranc AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by AustralianRupert on 11 Dec 2019; discussion
04 Dec 2019 – Húrin the Tall AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 11 Dec 2019; discussion
08 Dec 2019 – Amrod AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 15 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Curufin AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Amras AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Erkenbrand AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
11 Dec 2019 – Tilion AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 18 Dec 2019; discussion
13 Dec 2019 – White Tree of Gondor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 20 Dec 2019; discussion
14 Dec 2019 – Gothmog (Third Age) AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Spartaz on 22 Dec 2019; discussion
15 Dec 2019 – Forodwaith AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Sandstein on 22 Dec 2019; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Middle-earth wars and battles AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 23 Dec 2019; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by RL0919 on 23 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Rhûn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 24 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Arvedui AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 24 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Battle of Dale AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Eagles247 on 25 Dec 2019; discussion
18 Dec 2019 – Dagor Dagorath AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 25 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Lindon (Middle-earth) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Ithilien AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by RL0919 on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Avari (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Rangers of Ithilien AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
22 Dec 2019 – Middle-earth armies and hosts AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by BD2412 on 29 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Dec 2019 – Eluréd and Elurín AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by RL0919 on 30 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Dec 2019 – Grimbold AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 31 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Dec 2019 – Dior Eluchíl AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 31 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Hareth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as keep by Hog Farm on 30 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Dec 2019 – Eldarion AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by Newslinger on 01 Jan 2020; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Voronwë AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 01 Jan 2020; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Aegnor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 01 Jan 2020; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Salmar AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 01 Jan 2020; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Ilmarë AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 02 Jan 2020; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Ossë AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 02 Jan 2020; discussion
26 Dec 2019 – Arien AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by Yunshui on 02 Jan 2020; discussion
26 Dec 2019 – Maglor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 03 Jan 2020; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Reunited Kingdom AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Yunshui on 03 Jan 2020; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Arnor AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Yunshui on 03 Jan 2020; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Fictional food and drink in Middle-earth AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Yunshui on 03 Jan 2020; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Ohtar AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 03 Jan 2020; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Middle-earth objects AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by RL0919 on 04 Jan 2020; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Eregion AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 04 Jan 2020; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Tol Eressëa AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Britishfinance on 05 Jan 2020; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – All that is gold does not glitter AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 05 Jan 2020; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Doriath AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 05 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Idril AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 06 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Elladan and Elrohir AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 06 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Lonely Mountain AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 06 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Carcharoth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Randykitty on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – High-Kings of Arnor and Gondor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Dark Years AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Théodred AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Witch-king of Angmar AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as redirect by Nosebagbear on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Angmar AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Premeditated Chaos on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Orodreth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 07 Jan 2020; discussion
02 Jan 2020 – Dúnhere AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Northamerica1000 on 09 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Tar-Aldarion AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 09 Jan 2020; discussion
02 Jan 2020 – List of hobbit families AfDed by TTN was closed as delete by RL0919 on 09 Jan 2020; discussion
02 Jan 2020 – List of hobbits AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by RL0919 on 09 Jan 2020; discussion
02 Jan 2020 – List of Middle-earth Elves AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by Sandstein on 10 Jan 2020; discussion
02 Jan 2020 – List of Númenóreans AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Jan 2020; discussion
03 Jan 2020 – Huor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Jan 2020; discussion
03 Jan 2020 – Beregond and Bergil AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Jan 2020; discussion
03 Jan 2020 – Éothéod AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Nosebagbear on 11 Jan 2020; discussion
10 Jan 2020 – Haldir AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Username Needed on 10 Jan 2020; discussion
05 Jan 2020 – Barrow-wight AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 12 Jan 2020; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Dol Amroth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Tone on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Fingolfin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Tone on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Nimloth AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Timeline of Arda AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Elder Days AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Baggins of Hobbiton AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Tone on 13 Jan 2020; discussion
07 Jan 2020 – Rhovanion AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 14 Jan 2020; discussion
08 Jan 2020 – Outline of Middle-earth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as keep by RL0919 on 15 Jan 2020; discussion
06 Jan 2020 – Ranger (Middle-earth) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as no consensus by Mazca on 15 Jan 2020; discussion
08 Jan 2020 – Finarfin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 15 Jan 2020; discussion
08 Jan 2020 – Barahir AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by Sandstein on 15 Jan 2020; discussion
10 Jan 2020 – Eärendur AfDed by Narky Blert was closed as delete by Sandstein on 17 Jan 2020; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Arathorn AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 18 Jan 2020; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Elendur AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 18 Jan 2020; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Gil-galad AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 19 Jan 2020; discussion
12 Jan 2020 – Middle-earth Orc characters AfDed by BenKuykendall was closed as delete by Sandstein on 19 Jan 2020; discussion
13 Jan 2020 – Morwen AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by RL0919 on 20 Jan 2020; discussion
13 Jan 2020 – Lalaith AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Nosebagbear on 20 Jan 2020; discussion
18 Jan 2020 – Tolkien family AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as keep by BD2412 on 21 Jan 2020; discussion
12 Jan 2020 – Middle-earth dwarf characters AfDed by BenKuykendall was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 22 Jan 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2020 – Door of Night AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Missvain on 23 Jan 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2020 – Ilkorin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Missvain on 23 Jan 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2020 – Entish AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as merge by Barkeep49 on 24 Jan 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2020 – Middle-earth calendar AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as merge by Missvain on 23 Jan 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2020 – Serpent Lord AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Missvain on 23 Jan 2020; discussion
24 Jan 2020 – Haleth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 31 Jan 2020; discussion
24 Jan 2020 – Oromëan AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Tone on 31 Jan 2020; discussion
27 Jan 2020 – The Two Towers AfDed by WanderingWanda was closed as keep by JBW on 04 Feb 2020; discussion
27 Jan 2020 – The Return of the King AfDed by WanderingWanda was closed as keep by JBW on 04 Feb 2020; discussion
27 Jan 2020 – The Fellowship of the Ring AfDed by WanderingWanda was closed as keep by JBW on 04 Feb 2020; discussion
29 Jan 2020 – First Age AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Premeditated Chaos on 05 Feb 2020; discussion
29 Jan 2020 – Northmen (Middle-earth) AfDed by BenKuykendall was closed as redirect by Northamerica1000 on 05 Feb 2020; discussion
31 Jan 2020 – Umbar AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Natg 19 on 07 Feb 2020; discussion
02 Feb 2020 – Strawheads AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 09 Feb 2020; discussion
02 Feb 2020 – The Tale of Aragorn and Arwen AfDed by BenKuykendall was closed as delete by Sandstein on 10 Feb 2020; discussion
07 Feb 2020 – Anárion AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 14 Feb 2020; discussion
10 Feb 2020 – Realms of Arda AfDed by BenKuykendall was closed as delete by Yunshui on 17 Feb 2020; discussion
12 Feb 2020 – Elendil AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by RL0919 on 20 Feb 2020; discussion
13 Feb 2020 – A Tolkien Miscellany AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by QEDK on 21 Feb 2020; discussion
13 Feb 2020 – The Tolkien Quizbook AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by QEDK on 21 Feb 2020; discussion
17 Feb 2020 – Ecthelion AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 24 Feb 2020; discussion
17 Feb 2020 – Lithe AfDed by Hog Farm was closed by Sandstein on 24 Feb 2020; discussion
02 Mar 2020 – Eöl AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Mar 2020; discussion
02 Mar 2020 – The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as no consensus by Ritchie333 on 10 Mar 2020; discussion
12 Mar 2020 – Silvan Elves AfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed as redirect by Buidhe on 19 Mar 2020; discussion
15 Mar 2020 – Aman (Tolkien) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Sandstein on 22 Mar 2020; discussion
10 Apr 2020 – Calaquendi AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Buidhe on 16 Apr 2020; discussion
10 Apr 2020 – Troll (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as keep by Buidhe on 17 Apr 2020; discussion
10 Apr 2020 – Middle Earth Housing AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as merge by Mz7 on 26 Apr 2020; discussion
19 Apr 2020 – Telerin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Sam-2727 on 26 Apr 2020; discussion
04 May 2020 – Memories of Middle Earth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Dps04 on 11 May 2020; discussion
03 May 2020 – The Lord of the Rings (pinball) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 11 May 2020; discussion
05 May 2020 – Hex Combat AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Girth Summit on 12 May 2020; discussion
20 Apr 2020 – The Rivers and Beacon-Hills of Gondor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Spartaz on 13 May 2020; discussion
28 Apr 2020 – Aníron AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 13 May 2020; discussion
03 May 2020 – Early American editions of The Hobbit AfDed by Lava Lamps was closed as merge by Barkeep49 on 18 May 2020; discussion
03 May 2020 – Risk: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy Edition AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Premeditated Chaos on 18 May 2020; discussion
03 May 2020 – TheOneRing.net AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as merge by Barkeep49 on 18 May 2020; discussion
10 May 2020 – Marquette University Special Collections and University Archives AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Premeditated Chaos on 18 May 2020; discussion
12 May 2020 – Gollum: How We Made Movie Magic AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 19 May 2020; discussion
03 May 2020 – Niënor Níniel AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Spartaz on 26 May 2020; discussion
25 May 2020 – Taliska AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Spartaz on 02 Jun 2020; discussion
17 Jun 2020 – Aeglos AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by JHunterJ on 24 Jun 2020; discussion
18 Jun 2020 – Complete Songs & Poems AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by Buidhe on 25 Jun 2020; discussion
29 Jun 2020 – War of Wrath AfDed by Shooterwalker was closed as redirect by King of Hearts on 07 Jul 2020; discussion
10 Jul 2020 – Tolkien's Ring AfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 17 Jul 2020; discussion
27 Oct 2021 – Round World version of the Silmarillion AfDed by King of Hearts was closed as keep by Jack Frost on 04 Nov 2021; discussion
23 Oct 2022 – The Individuated Hobbit AfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed as keep by Vanamonde93 on 30 Oct 2022; discussion
24 Apr 2024 – List of translations of The Lord of the Rings AfDed by Fram was closed as keep by CactusWriter on 16 May 2024; discussion
18 Jun 2024 – Labingi AfDed by OlifanofmrTennant was closed as delete by OwenX on 09 Jul 2024; discussion

CfD

20 Oct 2011 – Category:Works inspired by J. R. R. Tolkien CfDed by Mike Selinker was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2012 – Category:Middle-earth video games CfDed by The Bushranger was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2012 – Category:Middle-earth games CfDed by The Bushranger was closed; discussion
23 Jul 2013 – Category:Films in The Lord of the Rings (film series) CfDed by Armbrust was closed; discussion
13 Feb 2014 – Category:Characters in The Lord of the Rings CfDed by Liz was closed; discussion
19 Feb 2014 – Category:Original characters and objects in The Lord of the Rings (film series) CfDed by Safiel was closed; discussion
17 Sep 2015 – Category:Middle-earth food and drink CfDed by DexDor was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Works based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth parodies CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth music CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Radio programmes based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth theatre CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth films CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Board games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Miniatures games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Role-playing games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Video games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
11 Jul 2016 – Category:Middle-earth rivers CfDed by Od Mishehu AWB was closed; discussion
11 Jul 2016 – Category:Middle-earth rivers CfDed by Od Mishehu AWB was closed; discussion
09 Dec 2017 – Category:Middle-earth materials CfDed by 165.91.12.221 was closed; discussion
21 Dec 2017 – Category:Middle-earth regions CfDed by 108.210.216.40 was closed; discussion
22 Dec 2017 – Category:Rulers of Númenor CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
11 Apr 2018 – Category:Middle-earth theology CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
12 Sep 2018 – Category:Elves in film CfDed by Doniago was closed; discussion
03 Jun 2019 – Category:Miniatures games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2019 – Category:Middle-earth horses CfDed by Woodensuperman was closed; discussion
05 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth Dragons CfDed by TTN was closed; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth towers CfDed by Clarityfiend was closed; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth rivers CfDed by Clarityfiend was closed; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth astronomy CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth cities and towns CfDed by Mike Selinker was closed; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Category:Artificial mythology CfDed by Brandmeister was closed; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth swords CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
31 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth plants CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
03 Jan 2020 – Category:Kings of Rohan CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
04 Jan 2020 – Category:Kings of Dale CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
04 Jan 2020 – Category:Kings of Arnor CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Chieftains of the Dúnedain CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth hills CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth bodies of water CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
15 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth regions CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Chieftains of the Dúnedain CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth hills CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth bodies of water CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
17 Jan 2020 – Category:Ents CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
18 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth words CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Orcs CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth wizards CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Valar CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Maiar CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Orcs CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth wizards CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Valar CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth Maiar CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Category:Dúnedain of the North CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
10 Feb 2020 – Category:Middle-earth buildings CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
26 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth weapons CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
26 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth rings and jewels CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
26 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth weapons CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
26 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth rings and jewels CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
13 Feb 2020 – Category:Gondor CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Category:Middle-earth deities CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Feb 2020 – Category:Rulers of Gondor CfDed by Susmuffin was closed; discussion
20 Mar 2020 – Category:Lists of Middle-earth articles CfDed by WT79 The Engineer was closed; discussion
12 May 2020 – Category:Middle-earth mountains CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
13 May 2020 – Category:Númenóreans CfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
03 Jun 2020 – Category:Middle-earth eras CfDed by Shooterwalker was closed; discussion
11 Nov 2021 – Category:High Elves CfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
29 May 2022 – Category:Middle-earth films CfDed by StarTrekker was closed; discussion
23 Feb 2024 – Category:Tolkien studies CfDed by Woodensuperman was closed; discussion
23 Feb 2024 – Category:Works about Middle-earth CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
01 Mar 2024 – Category:Tolkien fandom CfDed by Woodensuperman was closed; discussion

PROD

27 Dec 2011 – House of Isildur PRODed by 80.2.95.0 was deproded by GimliDotNet on 29 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Quenta Silmarillion PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Akallabêth PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Ainulindalë PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Valaquenta PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
27 Dec 2011 – Warning beacons of Gondor PRODed by 80.2.95.0 was redirected to Gondor
09 Aug 2012 – Imrahil PRODed by GimliDotNet was deproded by Arentol Gellor on 11 Aug 2012
09 Aug 2012 – Bill Ferny PRODed by GimliDotNet was redirected to List of Middle-earth animals#Bill
09 Aug 2012 – Freca PRODed by GimliDotNet was redirected to Helm Hammerhand
16 Sep 2012 – Beyond Bree PRODed by De728631 was deleted
18 Dec 2014 – Elanor Gardner PRODed by GimliDotNet was deproded by 151.227.5.112 on 21 Dec 2014
15 Jan 2015 – Aredhel PRODed by AadaamS was deproded by Cryptic on 23 Jan 2015
25 Apr 2015 – Fountain guards PRODed by Neutrality was deproded by Andrew Davidson on 04 May 2015
09 Jul 2017 – Fountain guards PRODed by Moduin was deproded by Kvng on 13 Jul 2017
08 Jul 2017 – Music Inspired by The Lord of the Rings (Mostly Autumn album) PRODed by 68.151.25.115 was redirected to Mostly Autumn
31 May 2018 – Tower Guard of Gondor PRODed by Reyk was deleted
12 Nov 2019 – Blue Wizards PRODed by Jack Upland was deproded by Andrew Davidson on 12 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Werewolf (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by *Treker on 13 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Daughters of Finwë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Ausir on 13 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – House of Elendil PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Half-elven PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – White Council PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Maia (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Goldberry PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Aulë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Thain (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by 2601:444:380:8C00:29EF:3923:6CB9:42D9 on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Nandor (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 15 Nov 2019
15 Nov 2019 – Ulmo PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 15 Nov 2019
15 Nov 2019 – Manwë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 15 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Round World version of the Silmarillion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Spinningspark on 17 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Ornendil PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Siege of Angband PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Battle of Mirkwood PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Haldir (First Age) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Hallas (Steward) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Cirion PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Exiles (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
18 Nov 2019 – Dunharrow PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Háma (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Finduilas of Dol Amroth PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Warg (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Huorn PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Edain PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Bëor PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Nargothrond PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Angband PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Eriador PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Caradhras PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – White Mountains (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Easterlings (First Age) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 23 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Troll-man PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Troll (Middle-earth)
18 Nov 2019 – Took clan PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of hobbit families#T
18 Nov 2019 – Dorthonion PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Realms of Arda#Noldorin realms
18 Nov 2019 – Nan Elmoth PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Realms of Arda#Avarin and Nandorin realms
25 Nov 2019 – Melian PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Caras Galadhon PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Esgaroth PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Tirion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by DGG on 28 Nov 2019
22 Nov 2019 – Nienna PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Vala (Middle-earth)#Nienna
22 Nov 2019 – Yavanna PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Vala (Middle-earth)#Yavanna
29 Nov 2019 – Lonely Mountain PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Hog Farm on 29 Nov 2019
02 Dec 2019 – Elladan and Elrohir PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 04 Dec 2019
29 Nov 2019 – Iron Hills PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Middle-earth#The Second, Third and Fourth Ages
30 Nov 2019 – Sador PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#S
30 Nov 2019 – Hardang PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Húrin#Appearance and history
30 Nov 2019 – Rían PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#R
30 Nov 2019 – Gorlim PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Barahir
30 Nov 2019 – Elwing PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#E
01 Dec 2019 – Erendis PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Númenóreans#Erendis
01 Dec 2019 – Celegorm PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Fëanor
01 Dec 2019 – Angrod PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#A
05 Dec 2019 – Eldarion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Screechybird1 on 07 Dec 2019
02 Dec 2019 – Marach PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Man (Middle-earth)#Edain
02 Dec 2019 – Brandir PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#B
02 Dec 2019 – Brandybuck Clan PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of hobbit families
21 Dec 2019 – Ranger (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 22 Dec 2019
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor-nuin-Giliath PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor Aglareb PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor Bragollach PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – First Battle of Beleriand PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
21 Dec 2019 – Tol Eressëa PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Nemo bis on 27 Dec 2019
27 Dec 2019 – Dúnhere PRODed by Hog Farm was deproded by DGG on 01 Jan 2020
27 Dec 2019 – Halmir PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
28 Dec 2019 – Hiril PRODed by Fayenatic london was deleted
30 Dec 2019 – Amandil PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Elendil
05 Jan 2020 – Early American editions of The Hobbit PRODed by BenKuykendall was deproded by Usernamekiran on 06 Jan 2020
31 Dec 2019 – Beleg PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to The Silmarillion
31 Dec 2019 – Finarfin PRODed by Hog Farm was deproded by Ceyockey on 08 Jan 2020

PR

07 Jan 2012 – The Hobbit put up for PR by De728631 was closed; discussion
26 Aug 2019 – The Lord of the Rings (film series) put up for PR by Mazewaxie was closed; discussion
17 Nov 2020 – The Tolkien Reader put up for PR by Hofendorf was closed; discussion

FAC

04 Feb 2012 – The Hobbit FA nominated by De728631 was not promoted; discussion
04 Nov 2021 – Beowulf and Middle-earth FA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted; discussion

FLC

02 Mar 2012 – List of accolades received by The Lord of the Rings film trilogy FL nominated by Ruby2010 was closed; discussion

RfC

08 Jul 2012 – The Lord of the Rings film trilogy RfC by GimliDotNet was closed; discussion
16 Dec 2012 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey RfC by Tenebrae was closed; discussion
29 Dec 2013 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey RfC by Betty Logan was closed; discussion
09 Feb 2020 – The Lord of the Rings RfC by SMcCandlish was closed; discussion

FfD

04 Aug 2012 – File:JRR Tolkien signature - from Commons.svg FfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
05 Sep 2012 – File:TheHobbitFilm13Dwarves.jpg FfDed by Bulwersator was closed; discussion
06 May 2013 – File:"Crist", by Cynewulf, translated into Quenya, written in Tengwar.png FfDed by Jay8g was closed; discussion
04 Dec 2014 – File:Jrrt lotr cover design.jpg FfDed by Stefan2 was closed; discussion
08 Jan 2015 – File:TheHobbit.png FfDed by Safiel was closed; discussion
19 Feb 2020 – File:Sharku 2.jpg (on List of original characters in The Lord of the Rings film series) FfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion

RM

04 Aug 2012 – The Lord of the Rings film trilogy move request by Betty Logan was closed; discussion
04 Aug 2012 – The Hobbit film trilogy move request by Silvergoat was closed; discussion
04 Aug 2012 – The Hobbit (2012 film) move request by Silvergoat was closed; discussion
16 Oct 2012 – Rohan move request by Tamfang was closed; discussion
26 Feb 2013 – Middle-earth in film move request by Evanh2008 was closed; discussion
24 Mar 2013 – Mythopoeia (genre) move request by Florian Blaschke was closed; discussion
01 May 2013 – The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring move request by George Ho was closed; discussion
18 Jun 2013 – The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar move request by Augsburgbeliever was closed; discussion
25 Jul 2013 – Gimli (Middle-earth) move request by BDD was closed; discussion
04 Sep 2013 – The Lord of the Rings move request by George Ho was closed; discussion
20 Oct 2013 – Ainur (Middle-earth) move request to Ainu (Middle-earth) by Thu was closed; discussion
06 Jan 2014 – Eye of Sauron move request to Eye of Sauron (disambiguation) by BD2412 was closed; discussion
10 Apr 2014 – The Hobbit (film series) move request to The Hobbit: There and Back Again by AdamDeanHall was closed; discussion
15 Feb 2015 – Hobbiton film set move request to Hobbiton Movie Set by Ben MacDui was closed; discussion
25 Sep 2015 – Aman (disambiguation) move request by Zanhe was closed; discussion
19 Apr 2018 – Fall of Gondolin move request by Anthony Appleyard was closed; discussion
29 Apr 2018 – The Tale of Beren and Lúthien move request by Lawrence King was closed; discussion
22 Apr 2020 – Shire (Middle-earth) move request to The Shire by Lava Lamps was moved to The Shire by Jerm on 29 Apr 2020; discussion
15 May 2020 – Lúthien and Beren move request to Beren and Lúthien (Middle-earth) by Gonnym was not moved; discussion
15 May 2020 – Lúthien and Beren move request to Beren and Lúthien (Middle-earth) by Gonnym was not moved; discussion
15 Jun 2020 – The Return of the King (1980 film) move request to The Return of the King (1979 film) by Gonnym was not moved; discussion
27 Sep 2020 – Esgaroth move request to Lake-town (Middle-earth) by Devonian Wombat was not moved; discussion
09 Oct 2020 – Palantír move request to Palantir by Hog Farm was closed by Paine Ellsworth on 22 Oct 2020; discussion
10 Jan 2021 – Moria (video game) move request to Moria (roguelike) by Anthony Appleyard was closed; discussion
23 Feb 2021 – Melian (Middle-earth) move request to Melian by Haleth was closed; discussion
27 Feb 2021 – Tuor move request to Tuor and Idril by Haleth was closed; discussion
10 Mar 2021 – Finwë move request to Finwë and Míriel by Haleth was closed; discussion
01 Jul 2021 – Beowulf in Middle-earth move request to Beowulf and Middle-earth by Buidhe was moved to Beowulf and Middle-earth by Vpab15 on 01 Aug 2021; discussion
09 Sep 2021 – Weta Workshop move request to Wētā Workshop by Quilt Phase was moved to Wētā Workshop by Iffy on 16 Sep 2021; discussion
29 Dec 2021 – Tolkien's style move request to Tolkien's prose style by Buidhe was moved to Tolkien's prose style by Lennart97 on 05 Jan 2022; discussion
28 May 2022 – Music of The Hobbit films move request to Music of The Hobbit film series by StarTrekker was moved to Music of The Hobbit film series by Dekimasu on 12 Jun 2022; discussion
02 Oct 2022 – Battle of the Five Armies (board game) move request to Battle of the Five Armies by 109.78.128.140 was not moved; discussion
17 Aug 2023 – Tolkien's influences move request to Influences on J. R. R. Tolkien by Gjs238 was moved to Influences on J. R. R. Tolkien by MaterialWorks on 24 Aug 2023; discussion
08 Aug 2024 – A Shadow of the Past move request to A Shadow of the Past (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) by Adamstom.97 was not moved; discussion
08 Aug 2024 – Partings move request to Partings (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) by Adamstom.97 was closed; discussion
08 Aug 2024 – Udûn move request to Udûn (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) by Adamstom.97 was closed; discussion

TfD

21 Sep 2012 – Template:ME-disambiguation TfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
12 Nov 2012 – Template:LotR navbox TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
08 Feb 2013 – Template:Middle-earth Labelled Map TfDed by Gadget850 was closed; discussion
28 Feb 2013 – Template:ME-importance TfDed by Alan Liefting was closed; discussion
02 Feb 2014 – Template:Fellowship of the Ring TfDed by Matt Deres was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2014 – Template:Infobox LOTR place TfDed by Pigsonthewing was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2014 – Template:Infobox Middle-earth place TfDed by Pigsonthewing was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2015 – Template:Middle-earth weapons TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2015 – Template:Arda Rivers TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
14 Oct 2015 – Template:Kings of Rohan TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
29 Oct 2015 – Template:IsildurHeirs TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
29 Oct 2015 – Template:AnarionHeirs TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Isildur family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Tookclan family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Húrin family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:House of Eorl TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
25 Nov 2016 – Template:Tolkien-sectstub TfDed by KATMAKROFAN was closed; discussion
25 Nov 2016 – Template:ME-fact TfDed by KATMAKROFAN was closed; discussion
10 Jun 2017 – Template:Middle-earth dragons TfDed by TenPoundHammer was closed; discussion
09 Jul 2018 – Template:Anarion family tree TfDed by 2601:2C4:C480:946:FC71:F76:5CFA:4ECB was closed; discussion
07 Aug 2018 – Template:Anarion family tree TfDed by Hhkohh was closed; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Template:Campaignbox Wars of Beleriand TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
29 Jan 2020 – Template:Silmarillion TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
01 Feb 2020 – Template:Finarfin family tree TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
01 Feb 2020 – Template:Haleth family tree TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
01 Feb 2020 – Template:Fingolfin family tree TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
01 Feb 2020 – Template:Elwë family tree TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
03 Feb 2020 – Template:Arda Mountains TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
05 Feb 2020 – Template:History of Arda TfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
08 Mar 2020 – Template:Arda Realms Age1 TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
09 Mar 2020 – Template:Moria (Middle-earth) TfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
09 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth dwarves TfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
10 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth elves TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
10 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth peoples and animals TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
10 Mar 2020 – Template:Campaignbox War of the Ring TfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
08 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth races TfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
17 Mar 2020 – Template:Tolkien Gateway TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
18 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth (initially Template:Ainur) TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
18 Mar 2020 – Template:History of Middle-earth navbox TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
20 Apr 2020 – Template:LotR casts navbox TfDed by Gonnym was closed; discussion
18 Jun 2020 – Template:Elendil family tree TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
01 Nov 2021 – Template:After Tolkien navbox TfDed by Frietjes was closed; discussion
23 Dec 2021 – Template:ME-ref/FAIL TfDed by Q28 was closed; discussion
31 Dec 2021 – Template:MiddleEarth-char-stub TfDed by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion
15 Jul 2022 – Template:The Fellowship of the Ring/Plot summary TfDed by Mellohi! was closed; discussion
17 Jul 2022 – Template:The Two Towers/Plot summary TfDed by Pppery was closed; discussion
21 Feb 2024 – Template:Tolkien tourism TfDed by Woodensuperman was closed; discussion
27 Sep 2024 – Template:Lang-qya TfDed by Trappist the monk was closed; discussion
27 Sep 2024 – Template:Lang-sjn TfDed by Trappist the monk was closed; discussion

RfD

22 Nov 2012 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (film) RfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
03 Jul 2016 – Great Darkness →Treebeard RfDed by Patar knight was closed; discussion
08 Jan 2020 – Lond Daer Enedh →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
09 Jan 2020 – Adorn (Middle-earth) →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
10 Jan 2020 – Denethor I →Gondor#Government RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Wulf (Middle-earth) →Rohan (Middle-earth)#History RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Angamaitë →List of Middle-earth characters#A RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Angrod →List of Middle-earth characters#A RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Brandir →List of Middle-earth characters#B RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Rían →List of Middle-earth characters#R RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Sador →List of Middle-earth characters#S RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Tarondor →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Valandil →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Eldacar →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Haldir →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
11 Jan 2020 – Rómendacil →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
13 Jan 2020 – House of the Kings →Minas Tirith#House of the Kings RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
08 Jan 2020 – List of Middle-earth inns →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
18 Jan 2020 – Battle of Dale →The Lord of the Rings#Dale RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
19 Jan 2020 – Straight Road →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
19 Jan 2020 – Straight Road →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Gamil Zirak →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Fror →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Frór →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Fundin (Middle-earth) →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Gloin, son of Thorin →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Glóin, son of Thorin →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Gróin →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Grór →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Nain I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Nain II →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Nain, son of Gror →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Náin I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Náin II →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Náin, son of Grór →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thorin I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thorin III →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thorin III Stonehelm →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thrain I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thrain the Old →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thror →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thráin I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thráin the Old →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Thrór →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Farin →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Dis (Middle-earth) →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Dís (Middle-earth) →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Dain I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
25 Jan 2020 – Dáin I →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
27 Jan 2020 – Barahir (Steward) →Gondor#Government RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
29 Jan 2020 – Amon Anwar →Gondor#Amon Anwar RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
30 Jan 2020 – Elven-king →Thranduil RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
31 Jan 2020 – Ethring →Gondor#Ethring RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
31 Jan 2020 – Nár →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
31 Jan 2020 – Frerin →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by BenKuykendall was closed; discussion
01 Feb 2020 – Durin II →Dwarf (Middle-earth)#Durin RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
03 Feb 2020 – T2t →The Two Towers RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
27 Jan 2020 – Plague of 1636 →Gondor#Decline RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
07 Feb 2020 – Round World version of the Silmarillion →The Silmarillion RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2020 – Fuinur →Man (Middle-earth)#Adversaries RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
10 Feb 2020 – Two Watchers →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
18 Mar 2020 – Template:Dwarves →Template:Middle-earth dwarves RfDed by Gonnym was closed
18 Mar 2020 – Template:Middle-earth dwarves →Template:The Lord of the Rings RfDed by Gonnym was closed
10 Apr 2020 – Casarrondo →Moria (Middle-earth) RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
10 Apr 2020 – Hadhodrond →Moria (Middle-earth) RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
10 Apr 2020 – Phurunargian →Moria (Middle-earth) RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – The Which King →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – NAzGuL →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – Carn Dûm →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – Carn dum →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – Carn Dum →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
14 Apr 2020 – Dírhael →List of Middle-earth characters RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
12 Apr 2020 – Angmar →Nazgûl RfDed by 1234qwer1234qwer4 was closed; discussion
18 Apr 2020 – Amandil →Númenor RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
28 Apr 2020 – Rushdown (Middle-earth) →Geography of Middle-earth#Misty Mountains RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
30 Apr 2020 – Herumor →Man (Middle-earth)#Adversaries RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
28 May 2020 – Ciryon →Aragorn#Isildur RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
18 Jun 2020 – Template:Ainur →Template:Middle-earth RfDed by Hog Farm was closed
14 Aug 2020 – Aerandir →Eärendil and Elwing RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Aug 2020 – Aerlinn →A Elbereth Gilthoniel RfDed by GimliDotNet was closed; discussion
14 Aug 2020 – Gwathló →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
14 Aug 2020 – List of Middle-earth rivers →Geography of Middle-earth RfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
21 Oct 2020 – Palantir →Palantír RfDed by Rhododendrites was closed; discussion
14 Jan 2021 – Eärnil →Eärendil and Elwing RfDed by Hildeoc was closed; discussion
undated – Ñoldorin →Noldor RfDed was closed
undated – Noldorin →Noldor RfDed was closed
01 Mar 2021 – Thrall-Noldorin →Noldor RfDed by Uanfala was closed; discussion
07 May 2021 – Palantir →Palantír RfDed by 162 etc. was closed; discussion
undated – Thrall-Noldorin →Noldor RfDed was closed
undated – Ñoldorin →Noldor RfDed was closed
undated – Noldorin →Noldor RfDed was closed
13 Jul 2022 – Fellowship of the Ring (characters) →Template:The Fellowship of the Ring/Plot summary#Fellowship of the Ring RfDed by Lights and freedom was closed; discussion
26 Sep 2022 – JRR Tolkien/Sindarin →Sindarin RfDed by TNstingray was closed; discussion
18 Jun 2023 – Minhiriath →Middle-earth#Geography RfDed by Piotrus was closed; discussion

MfD

13 Apr 2016 – User:APclark/Frodo Simpsins MfDed by Ricky81682 was closed (deleted) by Xaosflux on 01 May 2016; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Portal:Middle-earth MfDed by Guilherme Burn was closed as delete by Scottywong on 19 Nov 2019; discussion
undated – Template:Tolkien grading scheme MfDed was closed; discussion

MRG

12 Jul 2018 – A Guide to Middle-earth proposed for merging to The Complete Guide to Middle-earth by Dyolf87 was closed; discussion
18 Aug 2019 – Blue Wizards proposed for merging to Wizard (Middle-earth) by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
15 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Middle-earth peoples by Goustien was closed; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Dáin II Ironfoot proposed for merging to Middle-earth dwarf characters by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
19 Nov 2019 – Eru Ilúvatar proposed for merging to Cosmology of Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Déagol proposed for merging to Gollum by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Old Man Willow proposed for merging to Old Forest by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – Farmer Maggot proposed for merging to List of hobbits by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Goldberry proposed for merging to Tom Bombadil by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
26 Nov 2019 – Gondolin proposed for merging to The Fall of Gondolin by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Ælfwine (Tolkien) proposed for merging to Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Ghân-buri-Ghân proposed for merging to Drúedain by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
15 Dec 2019 – Children of Ilúvatar proposed for merging to Cosmology of Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Rangers of Ithilien proposed for merging to Ithilien by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
06 Nov 2019 – Sting (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Middle-earth objects by Piotrus was closed; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – War of the Ring proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
22 Dec 2019 – Rohirric proposed for merging to Languages constructed by J. R. R. Tolkien by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Celebrían proposed for merging to Elrond by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
21 Nov 2019 – Dunharrow proposed for merging to Rohan (Middle-earth) by Goustien was closed; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Ælfwine (Tolkien) proposed for merging to Tolkien's legendarium by J Milburn was closed; discussion
12 Jan 2020 – Fathers of the Dwarves proposed for merging to Dwarf (Middle-earth) by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
21 Dec 2019 – History of Arda proposed for merging to Arda (Tolkien) by Piotrus was closed; discussion
27 Dec 2019 – Gladden Fields proposed for merging to Isildur by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
21 Dec 2019 – History of Arda proposed for merging to Arda (Tolkien) by Piotrus was closed; discussion
28 Dec 2019 – Umbar proposed for merging to Harad by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
18 Aug 2019 – Radagast proposed for merging to Wizard (Middle-earth) by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Battle of the Hornburg proposed for merging to Helm's Deep by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
20 Dec 2019 – The Scouring of the Shire proposed for merging to The Return of the King by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
22 Dec 2019 – Ranger (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Rangers of the North by Goustien was closed; discussion
24 Feb 2020 – Misty Mountains proposed for merging to Moria (Middle-earth) by Dmehus was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Fellowship of the Ring proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Two Towers proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Return of the King proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
27 Feb 2020 – White Mountains (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Gondor by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Fellowship of the Ring proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Two Towers proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
04 Feb 2020 – The Return of the King proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings by CaptainEek was closed; discussion
27 Feb 2020 – White Mountains (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Gondor by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
18 Mar 2020 – Radagast proposed for merging to Middle-earth peoples#Istari (Wizards) by Andy Dingley was closed; discussion
09 Mar 2020 – Three Rings proposed for merging to Rings of Power#The Three by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
28 Apr 2020 – The Lord of the Rings (TV series) proposed for merging to Middle-earth in film by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
13 May 2020 – Old Forest proposed for merging to Geography of Middle-earth by Hog Farm was closed; discussion
03 Sep 2020 – The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late proposed for merging to The Adventures of Tom Bombadil by Piotrus was closed; discussion
03 Sep 2020 – Errantry proposed for merging to The Adventures of Tom Bombadil by Piotrus was closed; discussion
03 Sep 2020 – Fastitocalon (poem) proposed for merging to The Adventures of Tom Bombadil by Piotrus was closed; discussion
03 Sep 2020 – The Sea-Bell proposed for merging to The Adventures of Tom Bombadil by Piotrus was closed; discussion
12 Nov 2021 – Addiction to power in The Lord of the Rings proposed for merging to One Ring by Eddie891 was closed; discussion
06 Jan 2023 – Naming of weapons in Middle-earth proposed for merging to Middle-earth weapons and armour by Piotrus was closed; discussion
17 May 2024 – The Hobbit (film series) proposed for merging to The Lord of the Rings (film series) by DisneyMetalhead was closed; discussion
02 Sep 2024 – Tolkien fan fiction proposed for merging to Tolkien fandom#Fan fiction by Zxcvbnm was closed; discussion

AFC

16 Aug 2020 – Draft:Multi-Users in Middle-earth submitted for AfC by Nschimme was declined by Cthomas3 on 07 Nov 2020
16 Aug 2020 – Draft:Multi-Users in Middle-earth submitted for AfC by Nschimme was declined by Cthomas3 on 07 Nov 2020
30 Dec 2020 – Draft:David Day (Canadian author) submitted for AfC by UnitedStatesian was accepted to David Day (Canadian author) by Robertsky on 08 Jul 2021
22 Aug 2022 – Draft:The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (soundtrack) submitted for AfC by 110.225.230.167 was accepted to The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (soundtrack) by Dan arndt on 23 Aug 2022
16 Feb 2023 – User:Icdxb/sandbox submitted for AfC by Icdxb was declined by Theroadislong on 16 Feb 2023
11 Apr 2023 – Draft:Middle East Images Agency submitted for AfC by Rosebreakly was declined by Hoary on 11 Apr 2023

FAR

20 Dec 2020 – The Lord of the Rings (1978 film) put up for FA by Femkemilene was closed; discussion

GAR

03 Jul 2021 – The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late nominated for GA reassessment by Colin M was closed; discussion
01 Jun 2021 – Women in The Lord of the Rings nominated for GA reassessment by Michael Martinez was closed; discussion

SPL

30 Apr 2023 – Orc proposed for splitting by Kiyoweap was closed; discussion
29 May 2023 – Orc proposed for splitting by Chiswick Chap was closed; discussion

AAlertBot is coded by Hellknowz and co-operated with Headbomb. Discuss? / Report bug? / Request feature?