Talk:Proverbs in The Lord of the Rings/GA1
GA Review
[edit]| GA toolbox |
|---|
| Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Pax85 (talk · contribs) 06:15, 30 August 2021 (UTC)
GA review – see WP:WIAGA for criteria
- Is it well written?
- A. The prose is clear and concise, and the spelling and grammar are correct:
- Could use a light copyedit. If there are no objections, I can do this as part of the review process.
- OK as long as it's British English copyediting.
- Definitely. I reworded a couple of areas for flow and clarity. -Pax Verbum 05:41, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- OK as long as it's British English copyediting.
- Could use a light copyedit. If there are no objections, I can do this as part of the review process.
- B. It complies with the manual of style guidelines for lead sections, layout, words to watch, fiction, and list incorporation:
- A. The prose is clear and concise, and the spelling and grammar are correct:
- Is it verifiable with no original research?
- A. It contains a list of all references (sources of information), presented in accordance with the layout style guideline:
- B. All in-line citations are from reliable sources, including those for direct quotations, statistics, published opinion, counter-intuitive or controversial statements that are challenged or likely to be challenged, and contentious material relating to living persons—science-based articles should follow the scientific citation guidelines:
- C. It contains no original research:
- D. It contains no copyright violations nor plagiarism:
- A. It contains a list of all references (sources of information), presented in accordance with the layout style guideline:
- Is it broad in its coverage?
- A. It addresses the main aspects of the topic:
- Is it possible to give more details on the source of some of the proverbs? With Tolkien's background as a philologist, I'm sure there could be some great information here. -Pax Verbum 05:44, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- Added a column for real-world equivalents where these exist, and cited them. As stated in the article, Tolkien made up many of the proverbs.
- Looks good! -Pax Verbum 21:26, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- Added a column for real-world equivalents where these exist, and cited them. As stated in the article, Tolkien made up many of the proverbs.
- Is it possible to give more details on the source of some of the proverbs? With Tolkien's background as a philologist, I'm sure there could be some great information here. -Pax Verbum 05:44, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- B. It stays focused on the topic without going into unnecessary detail (see summary style):
- In the section "Making the world real", the article starts by mentioning Hammond and Scull, but then focuses on Crabbe and Shippey without mentioning Hammond and Scull again. It comes off a bit awkward. Hammond and Scull is an important Tolkien resource, but is there a way to reword that so it stays on focus or makes the Hammond and Scull connection a bit more clear?-Pax Verbum 03:10, 3 September 2021 (UTC)
- Reworded.
- I think that makes it much more clear. -Pax Verbum 21:26, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- Reworded.
- In the section "Making the world real", the article starts by mentioning Hammond and Scull, but then focuses on Crabbe and Shippey without mentioning Hammond and Scull again. It comes off a bit awkward. Hammond and Scull is an important Tolkien resource, but is there a way to reword that so it stays on focus or makes the Hammond and Scull connection a bit more clear?-Pax Verbum 03:10, 3 September 2021 (UTC)
- A. It addresses the main aspects of the topic:
- Is it neutral?
- It represents viewpoints fairly and without editorial bias, giving due weight to each:
- It represents viewpoints fairly and without editorial bias, giving due weight to each:
- Is it stable?
- It does not change significantly from day to day because of an ongoing edit war or content dispute:
- It does not change significantly from day to day because of an ongoing edit war or content dispute:
- Is it illustrated, if possible, by images? - None present. See note below.
- A. Images are tagged with their copyright status, and valid fair use rationales are provided for non-free content:
- B. Images are relevant to the topic, and have suitable captions:
- While images aren't necessarily required, due to the topic, I think there may be some excellent opportunities to include one or two illustrations.
- I actually illustrate my articles quite heavily, but I'm hard put to it to find something definitely on-topic here. Happy to discuss suggestions.
- Indeed. What about something that can go with the conversation between Gimli and Elrond, or better yet and perhaps more applicable to the article itself, an illustration of Strider, especially as he is initially seen in Bree? -Pax Verbum 05:18, 31 August 2021 (UTC)
- Strider added, not a bad image here.
- I agree, that one turned out quite nice. -Pax Verbum 02:42, 3 September 2021 (UTC)
- Strider added, not a bad image here.
- Indeed. What about something that can go with the conversation between Gimli and Elrond, or better yet and perhaps more applicable to the article itself, an illustration of Strider, especially as he is initially seen in Bree? -Pax Verbum 05:18, 31 August 2021 (UTC)
- I actually illustrate my articles quite heavily, but I'm hard put to it to find something definitely on-topic here. Happy to discuss suggestions.
- While images aren't necessarily required, due to the topic, I think there may be some excellent opportunities to include one or two illustrations.
- A. Images are tagged with their copyright status, and valid fair use rationales are provided for non-free content:
- Overall:
- Pass or Fail: PASS
- Please see section three for items to address.
- Pax85: All done, I believe. Many thanks for the review. Chiswick Chap (talk) 09:23, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- Please see section three for items to address.
- Concluding comments: Overall this was a delightful foray into the world of Middle-earth with Tolkien's use of proverbs and other turns of phrase. For you and future editors, I would say that this good article has some opportunity for growth; I have an inkling that an even deeper exploration of the topic may yield some fascinating results. Overall, a wonderful piece of work so far. Thank you for the opportunity to review it! -Pax Verbum 21:31, 5 September 2021 (UTC)
- Pass or Fail: