User:Significa liberdade/EFA

Under construction

If you see mistakes, feel free to correct them. If you want to help fill the table out, chime in.

Candidate	Nom	Q1	Q2	Q3	Thoughts
Ahecht	Self nom: Copyediting NPP RCP AfC Creating templates Administrator without tools (April 2024) wbm1058: Technical move requests Clean block log No noticeboard drama	Move requests for fully protected pages G6 deletion	Templates User scripts	No specifics, good attitude	Good AfD record High trust perms: AP, NPP, PM, TE
AntiDionysius	Self nom: Rollback Pending changes reviewer Recent changes patrol Welcoming new editors	Block vandals (Europe time zone) Protect articles Speedy delete (removed G11)	Anti-vandalism	CTOP issue Oct. 2023 (no link)	Good AfD record Low content creation Doesn't always archive critical talk page comments
Bastun	Long-term editor (2005) Improve articles Revert vandalism NPP (January)	PROD CSD AIV (anti-vandalism)		ANI re:Troubles (Ireland)	Good AfD record Low content creation Doesn't always archive critical talk page comments Sometimes snappy edit summaries when deleting hate speech
DoubleGrazing	NPP --> AfD, SPI, vandalism		WIRED	No specifics, good attitude	Excellent AfD record High trust perms: AP, NPP, PM Nom offer from Ingenuity
Dr vulpes	NPP AfC AfD Error log Femke co-nom	CSD Page protection PERM		Described specific	High trust perms: NPP, PM
EggRoll97	EFH	View deleted revisions AIV		No specifics, short	Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything Edit count < 8,000 Low content creation High-trust perms: Edit filter manager, global edit filter helper, NPP, PM
FOARP		RM AfD RFC	Collaborative work	No specifics, good attitude	Excellent AfD record theleekycauldron offered to nom for RFA Ritchie encouraged running High-trust perms: PM
Frost	Recept change patrol Revert and report vandalism Identify and tag spam Report socks Username violation	Change patrol Block Delete Protect Revdel Histmerge Linkspam		Specifics	Almost all edits from this year, many automated ~8k edits Good AfD record High-trust perms: PM
Hawkeye7	Former admin	DYK WP:RPP WP:RM		Desysoped (no link): privileges removed 12 years ago via "knee-jerk admin actions" in Arbcom	Skirted around answering question about why they didn't mention two failed RFAs (2016, 2019) Iffy AfD record
Iwaqarhashmi	Anti-vandalism (AIV, UAA) Recent change patrol	WP:AIV WP:UAA WP:RFPP PERM	Sept. NPP drive	No specifics	Got offended by someone saying he might be a hatcollector based on evidence
Knightoftheswords281	WP:ITN	WP:ITN		Have engaged in conflict, no discussion of resolve	Good AfD record Edit count under 8,000 <1k edits past year Low content creation
Leonidlednev	Anti-vandalism	AIV UAA Close XfDs G3/G11			Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything No articles created
LindsayH	Alt accounts: Kahtar, Rhydypennau, and Rhubarb Bikini	"I do not have a 'need for the tools'" Unclear what they would do as an admin	Gnoming (citation template errors, c/e)	Specifics with link	Good AfD record Low content creation Innisfree987 encouraged to run High-trust perms: NPP
MarcGarver	Second account: User:QuiteUnusualPublic Failed RfA in 2012 (CLOP) AfC Spam Paid contributions Vandalism Steward 10 yrs (re-confirmation yearly)	Undisclosed paid editing Promotional content and spam Addressing CV at AfC and NPP		According to self, no recent conflict	Excellent AfD record Low content creation High-trust perms: Steward, Wikibooks sysop & checkuser, AP, NPP
Mdewman6	Redirects Naming convention DAB	RFD RM RM/TR		Specifics with (broken) link	Excellent AfD record Some content creation High-trust perms: NPP, PM
NoobThreePointOh
Pbritti	Content creator	Anti-vandalism Page protection Unblock requests AfD/PROD		Good with conflict per Bugghost Specifics with link	Excellent AfD record High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Peaceray	Welcome new editors Anti-vandalism	Anti-vandalism Page protection		No specifics, good attitude Good with conflict per Femke	Good AfD record Approval from Rosiestep and others High-trust perms: AP, MMS, PM, TE
Pharaoh of the Wizards	Editing since 2006	Shares history: UAA AIV AFD CSD	Contect creation UAA AIV AFD	According to self, no significant conflict	Bad AfD record, vote stacking Short responses to questions Doesn't always archive critical talk page messages High-trust perms: AP
Queen of Hearts	Anti-vandalism XfD Admin without tools (Feb) Alts: Diverging Diamond, Queen of AWB, ClydeFranklin	"Lesser" XfDs: CfD, RfD, MfD		No specifics, good attitude Link in follow-up conversation	Iffy AfD record, but no interest in AfD High trust perms: Formerly had pending changes but returned for lack of use Good at closing RM per Maddy from Celeste Nom offers from Josh and Femke Excellent closer at CfD per HouseBlaster
Robert McClenon	Former failed RFAs (2006, 2017) NPP "Maintenance and improvement of the encyclopedia"	Dispute resolution XfD: MfD, deletion review, CSD (G6, G11)	Dispute resolution noticeboard		Very bad AfD record (explicitly stating it's not up to participants to look for sources) Low content creation High-trust perms: AP, NPP, PM Logical communication style Lots of back and forth in the discussion
Rsjaffe	Uses AWB for mass work Check for undeclared paid editing, vandalism, SP	SPI Vandalism Undeclared paid editors		Specifics	Excellent AfD record High-trust perms: NPP All SPI reports led to blocks
Sable232	Vandalism Content creation and formatting Sockpuppets LTA	SPI RFPP AIV		No specifics, good attitude	Excellent AfD record Low content creation Potential issues with dispute resolution/being petty (1, 2, 3)
SD0001	Novem Linguae: Technical editor (maintains Twinkle) 2024 Tech Contributor of the Year Trusted MediaWiki developer 10 years tenure Josh: Bot Approvals Group member Operates SDZeroBot (won 2020 Coolest Tool Award) Editor of the Week	Edit protected page templates and modules Update gadgets Respond to edit requests Operate admin bots Histmerge		No specifics, good attitude	Good AfD record <1,000 edits in last year High-trust perms: BAG, NPP, PM, TE
SheriffIsInTown
SilverLocust	Extraordinary Writ: Requested moves Content creation "Good judgment, a calm and friendly disposition, and above all a real diligence in how he goes about making a difference on this site". HouseBlaster: Arbitration Committee clerk	Requested moves Technical move requests Page protection History merge Clerking arbitration		No specific conflicts, good attitude	Good AfD record High-trust perms: MMS, NPP, PM, TE
Sohom Datta	Novem Linguae: MediaWiki extensions 10 GAs NPP coordinator "Personable and pleasant to interact with" 7,583 edit count Clover: "Kind, knowledgable, and I trust him"	Maintain gadgets and userscripts RFPP Admin bots DYK		No specifics, good attitude	Good AfD record Edit count under 8,000
Spy-cicle	Content creation AfD Delegate for Featured topic candidates	RPP AIV AfD		No specifics, good attitude Discussion shared in questions from community	Good AfD record <1,000 edits in last year Concerning edits regarding LGBT issues and reliable sources (1, 2, 3, 4, 5)
Starship.paint	Content creation INVOLVED in GSEX, APOL, Abortion, AI	AN ANI AE ITN dabbling			Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything High-trust perms: AP
SWinxy	Content creation Press photography for Wikimedia Commons	(Un)protect pages (CTOP editor) View and restore deleted pages (deletion discussions) Edit fully-protected articles		No specifics, good attitude	Good AfD record High-trust perms: TE Rhododentrites encouraged to run
ThadeusOfNazereth	Vanamonde93: 3 GAs 2 FLs Some DYKs NPP AfD participation RCP Non-admin discussion closure Volunteer advisor with the Wikimedia Foundations Elections Committee	AIV RPP DYK RSN		Specifics	Excellent AfD record High-trust perms: AP, NPP
The Squirrel Conspiracy	Formerly Sven Manguard and Nezzadar Withdrawn RFA in 2012 (OUTING) FFD Likely won't be active Admin on Commons Cross-wiki spam and vandalism	Spam (del/revdel) Vandalism (del/revdel) View revdel for cross-wiki spam and vandalism		No specifics, decent atttitude	Good AfD record <1,000 edits in last year Doesn't always archive critical messages High-trust perms: Wikidata sysop, Commons sysop, AP, NPP
Valenciano	NPP AIV RFPP UAA CSD log 400 articles created 26 DYK 3 GAs	AIV UAA RFPP		No specifics, decent attitude Specifics added here and here	Good AfD record but stale Doesn't always archive critical messages High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Velella	Active 19 years Blocked early on	Support the overall admin effort Anti-vandalism SPI Undisclosed paid editing AfD ANI CSD		"Avoids drama"	Good AfD record Some incorrect draftications despite Page Curator warnings "This process for me has been very stressful." Many creations, but not all good (some uncited) High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Zippybonzo	NPP Anti-vandalism Copyright	Lack of content work CSD PROD AIV UAA		According to self, does not handle criticism well (lashing out, leaving wiki)	Bad AfD record Edit count under 8,000 <1,000 edits in last year

See all candidate subpages