Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/310s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
311 1 block
2 topic-bans
2 warnings
2 non-enforcement actions
1 successful appeal
1 page-level sanction
1 procedural error
2 inconclusive
(2 unlisted threads not counted as duplicates)
Daveout AP2 Oct. 03, 2022 -nil- STL N/A
Muhafiz-e-Pakistan GS/UYGHUR Oct. 07, 2022 Muhafiz-e-Pakistan: Ban from GS/UYGHUR area (indef) TBan N/A
Clean Copy PS Oct. 08, 2022 Clean Copy: Block (1mo) Blk N/A
Request for 1RR at Crisis pregnancy center AB Oct. 11, 2022 Crisis pregnancy center: 1RR/72h on all editors writ large PLS The sanctioning admin stated that a BRD restriction may be added to the page without further discussion, either as an addendum to or replacement for the 1RR.
Grandmaster AA2 Oct. 14, 2022 Grandmaster: Ban from AA area lifted Acpt N/A
Kheo17 AA2 Oct. 15, 2022 Kheo17: Warned to use WP:RS/N rather than edit-war
Dallavid (filer): Warned to use RS/N rather than edit-war
Warn x2 N/A
Aman.kumar.goel IP Oct. 17, 2022 -nil- PE Thread was filed by a IP sockpuppet.
Bookku IP Oct. 08, 2022 Bookku: Ban from feminism as it relates to Pakistan topic area (indef) TBan N/A
Dallavid AA2 Oct. 22, 2022 -nil- STL No administrator commented on the thread.
Hari147 IP Nov. 01, 2022 Hari147: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Block was levied due to subject's overt disregard of their topic ban
TheCurrencyGuy TRB Nov. 04, 2022 TheCurrencyGuy: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Blocking admin suggested a TRB topic ban should be a condition of any unblock
312 3 topic-bans
1 non-enforcement action
1 moot/not a violation
1 inconclusive
2 withdrawn
USaamo IP Nov. 04, 2022 USaamo: Existing ban expanded to the whole IP area TBan N/A
Toa Nidhiki05 AP2 Nov. 05, 2022 Toa Nidhiki05: Ban from AP2 area (indef) TBan N/A
Saucysalsa30 KURD Nov. 09, 2022 Saucysalsa30: Ban from KURD area (6mo) TBan N/A
InverseZebra GS Nov. 13, 2022 -nil- NV Subject blocked independent of the thread.
The Tranarchist GS Nov. 17, 2022 -nil- WD Both of these threads were filed by the same user and withdrawn for the same reason. Even if the threads weren't withdrawn they would have been dismissed as content disputes.
Newimpartial GS Nov. 17, 2022 -nil- WD
Colnago2253 PS Nov. 17, 2022 Colnago2253: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Tys90 HORN Nov. 23, 2022 -nil- STL Subject had been blocked for 31h before the thread was filed and has not since returned from their block.
313 2 topic-bans
3 warnings
1 non-enforcement action
1 successful appeal
2 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 withdrawn
SPECIFICO AP2 Nov. 28, 2022 -nil- PE The article in question wasn't under a 1RR restriction.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Saucysalsa30 KURD Dec. 13, 2022 Saucysalsa30: Topic ban from KURD area remains in place due to appeal being withdrawn WD N/A
Olympian AA2 Dec. 17, 2022 Olympian: Formally warned against using genocide-denialist sources in AA2 area Warn N/A
Eyagi GS (?) Dec. 18, 2022 -nil- PE Whether or not the edits being complained about fell under the GS regime was unclear. The thread would ultimately be closed in favour of a discussion at WP:AN/I covering the same matter.
This is the first thread that closed after the change from DS to CT.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Yae4 CC Dec. 19, 2022 Yae4: Ban from CC area lifted Acpt N/A
(IPv4 address starting 192.) IRP Dec. 19, 2022 -nil- NV The IP in question hadn't edited in a week at the time of the thread's close, and even a warning was deemed to be impractical.
Archwayh PIA4 Dec. 23, 2022 Archwayh: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Vladdy Daddy Silly EE Dec. 27, 2022 Vladdy Daddy Silly: Formally warned of EE sanctions Warn N/A
Scientelensia GS Dec. 29, 2022 Scientelensia: Ban from GS area (1yr) TBan N/A
Dev0745 IP Dec. 31, 2022 Dev0745: Formally warned to stop engaging in original research Warn Filer was also given an informal warning for civility.
Paddykumar GS Jan. 01, 2023 Paddykumar: Ban from GS area (1yr) TBan N/A
314 2 topic-bans
3 warnings
2 non-enforcement actions
1 miscellaneous
1 procedural error
1 withdrawn
2 not acted on for other reasons
PreserveOurHistory IP Jan. 02, 2023 PreserveOurHistory: Ban from IP area (indef) TBan Consensus achieved for indefinite sanction (3 admins participating)
Ronar~enwiki GS, PS Jan. 04, 2023 Ronar~enwiki: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA User was judged to be pushing a conservative Christian POV and was blocked indefinitely as uninterested in building an encyclopaedia.
Maitrey M. Telang IP Jan. 05, 2023 Maitrey M. Telang: Formally warned to source their edits Warn N/A
ZaniGiovanni AA2 Jan. 05, 2023 -nil- NOR Consensus was to refer to ArbCom, leading to AA3.
Eta Carinae -- Jan. 06, 2023 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for actions taken on a different Wikipedia project altogether.
Michael60634 EE Jan. 15, 2023 Michael60634: Ban from Crimea topic area (6mo), formally warned against edit warring
Volunteer Marek (filer): Civility restriction in EE area (indef)
TBan, Warn, Misc. "Regarding the wording of [Volunteer Marek's] sanction... I was thinking the first two paragraphs but applying to everywhere the EE DS apply not just article talk pages. I'm not keen on the third paragraph around the use of "must" but I think the intention of it is good so could be included as a suggestion rather than a direction."[Link in original] --Callanecc, explaining the scope of Volunteer Marek's civility restriction
Dallavid AA2 Jan. 15, 2023 Dallavid: Formally warned against edit-warring Warn N/A
Spotted in Warsaw AA2 Jan. 16, 2023 Spotted in Warsaw: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Subject was later found to be a sockpuppet.
Decodingw GS Jan. 18, 2023 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions deemed disproportionate as the user was both newish and the only article they had been editing in the topic area was one that was seeing a lot of attention from newer editors overall.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by GoodDay GS Jan. 18, 2023 GoodDay: Ban from GS area remains in place as appeal is withdrawn WD N/A
315 1 block
2 topic-bans
1 miscellaneous
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
2 not acted on for other reasons
Minaro123 IP Jan. 28, 2023 Minaro123: 1RR in IP area (indef), requirement to draft new articles going forward (indef) TBan, Misc. Consensus achieved for indefinite sanctions (3 admins participating)
SashiRolls GMO Jan. 30, 2023 -nil- NOR Complaint was about SashiRolls breaching their interaction ban by thanking a user they were banned from. They claimed that they were not given a confirmation to do so, which was confirmed to be possible when viewing diffs on the mobile web interface by multiple parties. In addition, they had been participating in the discussion that sparked this in good faith and otherwise following their interaction ban.
CanterburyUK GS, BLP Jan. 31, 2023 CanterburyUK: Partial-block from Jordan Peterson and Talk:Jordan Peterson (indef) Blk Consensus achieved for indefinite sanctions post-block (3 admins participating)
Dan Palraz PIA4 Feb. 04, 2023 Dan Palraz: Ban from PIA area (6mo) TBan N/A
Jim Michael 2 BLP Feb. 05, 2023 -nil- NOR Thread closed in favour of a related AN/I discussion that was seeking stiffer sanctions than allowed by CT.
Super Dromaeosaurus, Mzajac, and Jeppiz EE Feb. 05, 2023 -nil- PE Almost all of the actionable complaints in the thread centred around Mzajac's use of administrator tools, for which the filer was told to request Arbitration. Claims against Jeppiz and Super Dromaeosaurus were dismissed as a content dispute, with the claims of conspiracy between the three considered unsupported.
Softlemonades AP2 Feb. 12, 2023 -nil- STL It should be noted that admins were seriously considering sanctioning or indefinitely blocking the filer before the thread petered out.
316 1 topic-ban
3 warnings
3 non-enforcement actions
1 successful appeal
1 moot/not a violation
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
GoodDay requesting amendment to topic ban GS Feb. 17, 2023 GoodDay: Ban given carveout for uncontroversial article edits in the topic area Acpt Consensus achieved for carveout (4 admins participating)
Truth&Wisdom365 PS Feb. 28, 2023 Truth&Wisdom365: Formal warning about PS sanctions Warn N/A
TheTranarchist GS Mar. 05, 2023 -nil- STL Responding administrators couldn't agree on whether the edits at issue breached the subject's topic-ban or (if they did) whether AE was the appropriate venue as the topic-ban wasn't related to any Arbitration ruling.
TrangaBellam EE Mar. 07, 2023 TrangaBellam: Formally warned of EE sanctions
Marcelus (filer): 0RR in EE area (indef)
GizzyCatBella: Last warning to behave in EE area
TBan, Warn x2 Topic-bans were considered for TrangaBellam and GizzyCatBella, but deferred once the Arbitration Committee indicated they would be looking into the situation.
Flibirigit -- Mar. 10, 2023 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for edits not covered by any Arbitration remedy.
BleedingKansas COVID Mar. 15, 2023 BleedingKansas: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Consensus was also achieved for an indefinite COVID area topic-ban (5 administrators participating) due to the subject "defending" themselves with blatant nationalistic threats, with agreement that the topic-ban would be a hard requirement for any unblock.
Michael Pocalyko GS Mar. 15, 2023 Michael Pocalyko: Extended-confirmed protection (4w, non-enforcement)
The Navigator (Pocalyko novel): Extended-confirmed protection (2w, non-enforcement)
NEA x2 I filed this thread.
Springee BLP Mar. 18, 2023 -nil- NV Dismissed as a content dispute.
317 2 blocks
2 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
2 withdrawn
CozyandDozy AP2 Mar. 20, 2023 CozyandDozy: Ban from AP2 area (indef), ban from BLP area (6mo) TBan x2 Consensus achieved for indefinite sanction (4 participants)
UnpetitproleX IP Mar. 26, 2023 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted the edits in controversy.
Harassed and intimidated by another -- Mar. 26, 2023 -nil- PE Thread not about edits or actions covered under any sort of Arbitration sanction. Filer was told to instead take it to WP:AN/I.
Valjean GS Mar. 27, 2023 -nil- NV Issue would be amiably resolved in the thread, making sanctions unnecessary.
Soibangla AP2 Mar. 29, 2023 -nil- WD The issue was primarily a massive misunderstanding, and was withdrawn once that became obvious.
Ferahgo the Assassin R&I Mar. 31, 2023 -nil- NV Thread deemed frivolous, with most diffs used being stale.
Marcelus EE Apr. 09, 2023 Pofka (filer): One-way interaction ban from Marcelus (indef), warned that next sanction will lead to harsh sanctions Misc, Warn Foot-shot, with a consensus for indefinite one-way interaction ban being reached (6 participants). Thread deemed frivolous with respect to Marcelus.
InedibleHulk GS Apr. 13, 2023 InedibleHulk: Siteban (1yr) Blk It was noted that InedibleHulk had a history of disregarding topic-bans.
JCJC777 PS Apr. 14, 2023 User:JCJC777: Block (1yr + indef) Blk Subject attempted to derail the thread by "retiring"; none of the responding administrators thought that it was genuine.
(N.B.: "1yr + indef" means the sanctioned user is indefinitely blocked, with the first year as Arbitration enforcement.)
NeuroZachary GS, AP2 Apr. 20, 2023 NeuroZachary: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA The request also included a Checkuser request, which the responding admins noted would in all likelihood be declined as a fishing expedition.
Request to lift topic ban PIA Apr. 23, 2023 -nil- WD Request was also malformed.
318 1 blocks
4 topic-bans
1 warning
1 non-enforcement action
1 successful appeal
1 page-level sanction
1 miscellaneous
3 moot/not violations
2 procedural errors
Oriental Aristocrat IP May 01, 2023 Oriental Aristocrat: Block (1yr + indef) Blk N/A
PalauanLibertarian AB May 02, 2023 PalauanLibertarian[i]: Ban from AB area (indef), revocation of rollback userright TBan, Misc. N/A
Interfase AA2 May 02, 2023 Interfase: Ban from AA area (1yr + indef) TBan Not enough admin input for hard-indefinite topic ban (1 participant)
(N.B.: "1yr + indef" for a topic-ban or other non-block sanction means that after the first year it may be appealed at any appropriate venue, not just AE or WP:ARCA.)
Zaathras AP2 May 05, 2023 Zaathras: Warned against edit-warring, especially over material that implicates WP:BLP.
Marjorie Taylor Greene: Consensus-required restriction (indef)
Warn, PLS N/A
Rayner111 R&I May 08, 2023 Rayner111: Partial-block from J.E.R. Staddon and Charles Murray (political scientist) (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Rayner111 claimed to be Staddon himself.
Emilimo PS May 09, 2023 Emilimo: Ban from PS area (indef) TBan Consensus achieved for indefinite sanction (3 participants)
Review of topic-ban (Dev0745) IP May 11, 2023 -nil- PE Request is malformed (and the closing administrator viewed the sanction being appealed as justified).
Iskandar323 PIA4 May 11, 2023 -nil- PE Request is malformed and dismissed as a content dispute.
Salandarianflag PIA4 May 12, 2023 Salandarianflag: Ban from PIA area (indef) TBan Consensus achieved for indefinite sanction (4 participants)
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Davidbena PIA4 May 16, 2023 Davidbena: Ban from PIA area lifted in favour of a mentorship by Nableezy (1yr) Acpt This did not affect Davidbena's community topic-ban from post-1948 Israeli politics.
Ghazaalch IRP May 22, 2023 -nil- NV Thread deemed frivolous.
Cioppino123 LCR May 27, 2023 -nil- NV Subject indefinitely blocked independent of the thread as a sockpuppet.
Buidhe HJP May 27, 2023 -nil- NV Thread dismissed as "unnecessary escalation" of a content dispute, with another administrator noting the talk page had hardly been used.
319 2 blocks
1 topic-ban
1 warning
6 non-enforcement actions
3 successful appeals
3 declined appeals
1 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Interstellarity AP2 May 27, 2023 Watergate scandal: AP2-related sanctions rescinded Acpt The appeal was against the AP2 sanctions on the page, as it falls outside the case's now-narrowed scope.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by FormalDude AP2 May 28, 2023 Ron DeSantis 2024 presidential campaign: AP2-related sanctions notice that was improperly placed replaced with a general notification Acpt N/A
Ruach Chayim EE May 30, 2023 Ruach Chayim: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Toa Nodhiki05 AP2 June 02, 2023 Toa Nidhiki05: Topic-ban from AP2 area remains in place Decl Appeal declined in part because filer was attempting to "wait out" the indefinite sanction.
Homme GS June 09, 2023 Homme: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Amaaretz PIA4 June 18, 2023 Amaaretz: Formally warned of PIA sanctions, particularly 500/30 Warn N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by DarrellWinkler COVID June 24, 2023 DarrellWinkler: Topic-ban from COVID area remains in place. Decl N/A
My very best wishes HJP June 27, 2023 My very best wishes: Block (2w), topic-ban from history of Jews in Eastern Europe and history of WWII topic-areas (indef) Blk, TBan Consensus achieved for indefinite sanctions (7 participants).
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Lima Bean Farmer AP2 July 05, 2023 Lima Bean Farmer: Topic-ban modified to be brought up to the modern AP2 topic-area (i.e. post-1992 instead of post-1932). Decl Filer was seeking a wholesale lift of the topic-ban. While this was declined due to his relative lack of edits in the interim there was a consensus to change it to match the present topic-area for AP2.
Prathamers PIA4 July 08, 2023 Prathamers (sockpuppet of יניב הורון)[ii]: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
ජපස[iii] COVID July 11, 2023 Adoring nanny (filer): Block (1yr + indef) Blk Foot-shot; thread deemed frivolous with respect to ජපස. Block was for their all-CTOPs% disruption (i.e. causing issues in multiple CTOPs at once; in this case COVID, PS, AP2) but there was no quorum for the indefinite block (2 participants).
Theheezy COVID July 12, 2023 Theheezy: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Block was for all-CTOPs% disruption (COVID, EE, AP2).
Raj208 AP2 July 12, 2023 Raj208: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Justito PS July 12, 2023 Justito: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Block was for all-CTOPs% disruption (PS, GS, COVID).
WikiEditor1234567123 EE July 12, 2023 -nil- NOR While there were concerns (likely caused by inexperience) with subject citing folkloric sources for claims (for which they would get an informal warning), the situation writ large was dismissed as a content dispute.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by InedibleHulk GS July 13, 2023 InedibleHulk: Siteban lifted and replaced with indefinite GS and AP2 topic-bans Acpt Consensus achieved for the indefinite sanctions (6 participants)
320 1 block
1 topic-ban
4 declined appeals
1 successful appeal
1 moot/not a violation
1 withdrawn
2 not acted on for other reasons
Tombah PIA4 July 16, 2023 Tombah: Ban from PIA area, 1yr + indef TBan No consensus for indefinite sanction (3 participants). Tombah would later be indefinitely blocked by a Checkuser.
NMW03 AA2 July 16, 2023 -nil- NOR Informal warning given. Filer would end up directly blocked/sitebanned by ArbCom directly.
SMcCandlish ATC July 22, 2023 -nil- WD Withdrawn as out of scope for AE.
Appeal request by Товболатов[iv] EE July 25, 2023 Товболатов: Ban from ethnic minorities in the former USSR topic area remains in place. Decl N/A
Fowler&fowler IP July 29, 2023 -nil- NOR Informal warning/advice given.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by BobNesh EE July 29, 2023 BobNesh: Indefinite block remains in place (becomes standard block on July 14, 2024). Decl N/A
Appeal request by GoodDay GS July 31, 2023 GoodDay: Topic-ban from GS area remains in place. Decl N/A
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Oktayey GS Aug. 04, 2023 Oktayey: Topic-ban from GS area remains in place. Decl Oktayey was told that the indefinite topic-ban was remarkably lenient, and that most other administrators would have just flat-out indefinitely blocked them. They were told in no uncertain terms that any further disruption would almost certainly lead to a block.
Appeal Request by 3Kingdoms PIA4 Aug. 04, 2023 3Kingdoms: PIA topic ban replaced with 0RR in PIA area Acpt N/A
Regarding Wikieditor1234567123 EE Aug. 15, 2023 -nil- NV Edits being complained about predated the subject's CTOP warning.
Miner Editor AP2 Aug. 17, 2023 Miner Editor: Block (1yr+ + indef) Blk "I indefed [Miner Editor] due to the beyond the pale conduct. If they appeal to arbcom, I will recuse[.]" - Sitting arbitrator Guerillero

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ The thread makes reference to a "PalauanReich"; this is the same user. They were renamed after it was pointed out "Reich" has unpleasant connotations.
  2. ^ he: Yaniv Horon
  3. ^ si: JPS
  4. ^ ru: Tovbolatov