User:Balloonman/CSD Survey/4.2
| Quicklinks |
|---|
| Other Excellent articles on CSD |
Original Article
[edit]pata nahi hai. jisko pata ho to bhej do
Nomination Criteria
[edit]A1
No context. Very short articles lacking sufficient context to identify the subject of the article. Example: "He is a funny man with a red car. He makes people laugh." Context is different from content, treated in A3, below.
Deletion Options
[edit]| rationale | Count | Percent |
|---|---|---|
| Agree with ratioinale to speedy delete. | 26 | 41.9 |
| Disagree with rationale, but deletable by other criteria. | 16 | 25.8 |
| Disagree with rationale, but this is a case where IAR applies. | 4 | 6.5 |
| Disagree with speedy deletion, it's in a foreign language, and being written in a foreign language is not a valid criteria for CSD, (should be PRODDED, sent to AFD, or kept.) | 16 | 25.8 |
Survey Comments
[edit]| Common rationale | Count |
|---|---|
| G1 | 6 |
- List for translation with a note that may be an A1 or otherwise speediable.
- I can't judge that one since I don't know the language. Could be that the admin who deleted it did.
- this I'd dleete under G1, unless something made me certain what language it was in - and then I'd check that language's wiki for the A2
- I don't think this is a real language. It is either Pakastani or Indian
- G1 (unless it really is in a foreign language, which I cannot determine)
- Just googling it shows hits to show it is a different language. There are other tags for this.
- Foreign language, but so short it probably doesn't establish context in that either. IAR.
- Possibly a speedy deletion candidate anyway, pending translation.
- G1 would also have applied, but I don't think A1 is blatantly wrong.
- It may happen that A2 would be legitimate (not to say A1 would not be), though a translation would be helpful either way... not sure how likely that would be as the language is Galician...
- Wouldn't argue with A1, but G1 and G2 also apply (for longer articles, tag with {{notenglish}} instead)
- Tag with notenglish, let someone who knows the language determine
- Now this is G1/nonsense, but check to see if the author speaks other languages or edits non-English-related articles. If so, soften the warning reminder to say non-English material should be in the proper Wikipedia, not this one.
- I'd run it through a language detection site to determine if it's a foreign language or nonsense. (note: you made me choose one of the above, and none fit exactly)
- To be honest I'd probably leave this for another admin, since I can't tell whether or not it's gibberish or a foreign language.
- send to relevant place for a check
Balloonman's analysis
[edit]This is a legitimate foreign language, and unless you speak the language you can't tell if it there is enough content/context. The proper steps would be:
- Check to see if the article exists on the appropriate foreign language wiki. If it does, then it is deletable under A2.
- If it doesn't exist, tag it for translation and place a PROD tag on it.