Jump to content

Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Failed log/April 2008

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
edit2006
April 1 promoted 6 not promoted
October 0 promoted 1 not promoted
November 4 promoted 1 not promoted
December 1 promoted 2 not promoted 1 sup.
2007
January 2 promoted 7 not promoted
February 1 promoted 2 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
March 1 promoted 4 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
April 2 promoted 1 not promoted
May 2 promoted 4 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept
June 3 promoted 2 not promoted
July 0 promoted 0 not promoted
August 1 promoted 0 not promoted
September 4 promoted 6 not promoted 1 sup.
October 4 promoted 1 not promoted
November 2 promoted 0 not promoted 2 sup.
December 3 promoted 1 not promoted
2008
January 3 promoted 0 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
February 2 promoted 1 not promoted
March 4 promoted 2 not promoted 1 sup.
April 5 promoted 4 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept
May 5 promoted 1 not promoted 1 sup.
June 2 promoted 0 not promoted 1 sup. 2 demoted
July 3 promoted 4 not promoted 1 sup.
August 7 promoted 5 not promoted 2 sup.
September 10 FT, 7 GT 14 not promoted 3 sup.
October 2 FT, 7 GT 7 not promoted 3 sup. 1 kept
November 2 FT, 5 GT 3 not promoted 4 sup.
December 7 FT, 11 GT 5 not promoted 2 sup.
2009
January 2 FT, 4 GT 5 not promoted 2 sup.
February 7 FT, 6 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
March 2 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept
April 3 FT, 1 GT 3 not promoted 0 sup.
May 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
June 4 FT, 9 GT 2 not promoted 3 sup. 3 demoted
July 2 FT, 6 GT 5 not promoted 3 sup. 2 demoted
August 2 FT, 6 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup.
September 3 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 2 kept
October 3 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 2 kept, 6 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept
December 1 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup.
2010
January 1 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 3 sup. 2 kept, 2 demoted
March 5 FT, 4 GT 3 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 5 demoted
April 1 FT, 8 GT 3 not promoted 4 sup.
May 0 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup.
June 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
July 5 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup.
September 1 FT, 1 GT 4 not promoted 0 sup.
October 3 FT, 18 GT 4 not promoted 1 sup. 2 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 1 demoted
December 2 FT, 7 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
2011
January 2 FT, 5 GT 3 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 1 FT, 11 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
March 0 FT, 4 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 9 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 2 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 8 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
September 2 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 4 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 1 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2012
January 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 11 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 6 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 14 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 4 demoted
August 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 2 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2013
January 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 2 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 2 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 0 demoted
May 0 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
July 1 FT, 8 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 3 kept, 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
October 4 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2014
January 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 2 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
August 4 FT, 1 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
September 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2015
January 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
March 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 2 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
August 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 2 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2016
January 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
July 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
September 0 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 3 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 2 demoted
December 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2017
January 2 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 4 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
May 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2018
January 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2019
January 1 FT, 1 GT 4 not promoted 4 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
August 1 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2020
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 5 demoted
March 3 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
May 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 3 sup. 2 kept, 4 demoted
June 0 FT, 8 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
October 0 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2021
January 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 2 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
July 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
September 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
November 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 1 demoted
2022
January 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 2 kept, 3 demoted
February 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
April 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
September 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2023
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 4 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
July 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
August 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 3 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
September 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2024
January 2 FT, 6 GT 2 not promoted 7 sup. 0 kept, 5 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 3 FT, 5 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 5 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 2 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
September 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
Main page Articles
Manchester United F.C. List of Manchester United F.C. managers - List of Manchester United F.C. players - Manchester United F.C. seasons

I've not been involved with featured topic discussions before, but I've given a quick read over the featured topic criteria, and I'm glad to nominate those said articles for (collective) featured topic status. Rudget (review) 16:46, 15 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Hippos

[edit]
Main page Articles
Hungry Hungry Hippos Hippocrates - Hippopotamus - Pygmy Hippopotamus - Horned Asian Hippo - Horned Hairy Hippo - Hippogriff - Malagasy Hippopotamus - Augustine of Hippo - Hippocampus

This is my first Featured Topic nomination, so apologies if I got the formatting wrong. I think you could make the case that Hippopotamus should be the main page of this topic. I went with Hungry Hungry Hippos, because there are scholars (I am personally agnostic) who consider Hippocampus not to be a form of hippo. Please note that Hippodrome, which is not GA, is actually an unrelated type of building which is used primarily for horse racing and not hippo racing. Thank you for your consideration and I look forward to working to address any objections during the course of this FTC. --JayHenry (talk) 23:21, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

April Fools? :) What does hippo mean anyway? And why are all these hippo- articles so high-quality? Fascinating. Wrad (talk) 23:26, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
I like hippos. --JayHenry (talk) 23:30, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
I hope it passes. Wrad (talk) 23:36, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Thanks Wrad. I will quit in fury if it does not pass. I've been working on these articles for eight months. --JayHenry (talk) 23:37, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
So "hippos" is greek for "horse"? Wrad (talk) 23:38, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Well, the article doesn't go into this, but Hippopotamus is a construct of universal grammar: when people see the animal they automatically know to call it Hippopotamus. The Greeks started calling equines Hippos because Solon noted that horses were pathetic versions of hippopotami. --JayHenry (talk) 23:41, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose. They are not all related per the criteria. Maybe try a hippo (the animal) FT instead. 02blythed (talk) 09:18, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

April Fools is over, close this nomination! igordebraga 13:53, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

  • Closed as April Fools joke
You forgot about the Hiphopopotomus. --The Fat Man Who Never Came Back (talk) 14:13, 4 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Chicago Bears

[edit]
Main page Articles
Chicago Bears Chicago Bears Seasons - List of Chicago Bears head coaches

All articles are either featured articles or featured lists. They are all nicely written, sourced, and of course - they are accurate. The Main Page (Chicago Bears) nicely illustrates the topic. Note: List of Chicago Bears head coaches is not a FL yet. It is to be closed soon. Please see the nomination here for more info. - Milks F'avorite Cookie 22:06, 1 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

List of UEFA club tournament winning managers

[edit]
Main page Articles
List of UEFA club tournament winning managers List of European Cup and UEFA Champions League winning managers - List of UEFA Cup winning managers - List of UEFA Cup Winners' Cup winning managers - List of UEFA Super Cup winning managers

All articles in this proposed featured topic are featured lists. The main page for the topic is an accurate and well illustrated overview of the child lists. The statistics are double-checked by the use of decent secondary sources and all child lists are well referenced and also illustrated. Overall I think the consistent style across all five lists, along with the references and images makes this an ideal candidate for a featured topic. The Rambling Man (talk) 09:20, 26 March 2008 (UTC)[reply]

I also discussed this with TRM before this nom. As I don't believe any Intertoto winners receive an actual cup, if the topic name were amended to "...club cup..." instead of "...club tournament..." would that address the point? --Dweller (talk) 12:43, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Are you sure that's the case? This would appear to indicate otherwise. cheers, Struway2 (talk) 13:26, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Bastogne. OK, back to the drawing board. --Dweller (talk) 14:46, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Note to all, supporters and commentators - thanks for all your time and efforts so far here. I've concluded that Struway2 is right and the list would be incomplete without Intertoto Cup winning managers. Despite being in a relatively strong position of support I still feel it only right to withdraw this FTC and work on filling in the gaps. Thanks again to you all. The Rambling Man (talk) 15:35, 2 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]