Wikipedia:WikiProject England/The West Country Challenge/Devon

The Devon Contest was won by Worm and Stacey. It has now closed and will move on to Dorset after a week's break on 24 August. Thanks to everybody who contributed!

The West Country Challenge
Day 7-9: Devon


$Ilfracombe$

Core articles

Cleanup highlights

See Cleanup list for the county

Stubs

Missing articles

Parishes

See Template:Devon parishes

East Devon

Mid Devon

North Devon

West Devon

South Hams

Teignbridge

Rivers

See List of rivers of England for context:

Atlantic Coast of Devon

Rivers discharging into the Atlantic Ocean between Morte Point in North Devon and the county border.

Taw catchment

- River Caen (R)
- Knowl Water (R)
- Bradiford Water (R)
  - Colam Stream (Rs)
  - Mill Leat?
- Langham Lake (L)
- Hawkridge Brook (R)
  - Colley Lake (L)
    - Nadrid Water
  - Little Silver Stream (L)
  - Crooked Oak (L)
  - River Yeo (Molland) (L)
- Mully Brook (L)
- Hollocombe Water (L)
  - Huntacott Water (R)
  - Adworthy Brook (R)
  - Sturcombe River (R)
  - River Dalch (R)
  - Ash Brook (R)
  - Gissage Lake (L)
- Bullow Brook (L) (m)

Torridge catchment

- River Yeo (L)
  - River Duntz (R)
    - Lydeland Water (L)
- River Mere (L)
  - - Black-a-ven Brook
    - Brim Brook
  - Waggaford Water (L)
  - Medland Brook (R)
  - Dunsland Brook (R)
    - Merryland Stream (R)
  - Pulworthy Brook
- River Waldon (R)

Minor coastal catchments

Abbey River (MS)

South Coast of Devon

All rivers discharging between the Cornwall and Dorset borders.

Tamar catchment

- - Withey Brook (R)
  - Rattle Brook (L)
  - Amicombe Brook (R)
    - Black Ridge Brook
    - Cut Combe Water
- Lowley Brook (R)
  - Doetor Brook (L)
- River Carey (L)
- River Claw (L)
- River Deer (L)

Plym catchment

- Tory Brook (L)
  - Hart Tor Brook (L)
  - Newleycombe Lake (L)
  - Narrator Brook (L)
  - Sheepstor Brook (L)
  - Lovaton Brook (L)

Yealm catchment

- Ranny Brook (L)
- Broadall Lake (R)
  - Ford Brook (R)
- Redaven Lake (L)
- Piall River (L)
- Mill Leat
- Cofflete Creek
- Shortaflete Creek
- Newton Creek (R)
  - Noss Creek

Erme & Avon catchments etc.

- Butter Brook (L)
- Piles Brook (L)
- Left Lake (L)
- Dry Lake (L)
- Bledge Brook (R)
- Hook Lake (L)
- Red Lake (L)
- Dry Lake (L)
- Blacklane Brook (L)
- Small Brook (L)
- Bala Brook (R)
  - Middle Brook (R)
  - Scad Brook (R)
  - East Glaze Brook (Ls)
  - West Glaze Brook (Rs)

Kingsbridge catchment

Dart catchment

- River Harbourne (R) (or Harbourne River)
  - River Wash (R)
- River Hems (L)
  - Gatcombe Brook (L)
  - Am Brook (L)
  - Dean Burn (R)
    - Moorshead Brook (R)
      - Addislade Water (L)
  - Holne Moor Leat (L) (Feeds Venford Reservoir and Holy Brook)
  - Holne Moor Leat (L) (Feeds Venford Reservoir)
  - Cut Hill Stream (L) (Hangman's Stream)
  - Cut Lane Stream (L)
  - Summer Brook (R)

Teign catchment

- - Reddaford Water
    - Bovey Pottery Leat
- Ugbrooke Stream (R)
  - Forde Leat (L) (Sometimes referred to as Ford Leat)
  - Beers Brook (L)

Exe catchment

- Staplake Brook (R)
- Alphin Brook (R)
- North Brook
- Duryard Stream
  - Small Brook
    - River Culvery (R)
      - River Ted (Ls)
      - Lilly Brook (Rs)
    - River Troney
  - Holly Water
  - River Weaver (L)
  - Spratford Stream (R) (known as River Lyner in upper reaches)
  - River Kenn (L)
  - River Madford (L) (or Madford River)
    - Bolham River (R)
- Burn River (L)
- River Dart (Bickleigh) (R)
- River Lowman (L)
  - Ben Brook (R)
- Iron Mill Stream (R)
- Brockeye River (or River Brockey) (R)
- River Quarme

Sid catchment

- Woolbrook (R)

Axe catchment

- River Coly (R)
  - Umborne Brook (L)
  - Offwell Brook?
- River Yarty (R)
  - Corrie Brook (R)*
- River Kit (R)
- Blackwater River (L)
- River Synderford (L)

Settlements

Women

Those marked with "(Gray )" are included in Todd Gray's Remarkable Women of Devon (2009) [1], so have at least one reliable source.

Rachel, Countess of Bath, of Tawstock, see Manor of Tawstock (Gray pp.9-12)
Teignmouth and Shaldon fisherwomen - title? "Amazonian Sirens" in (Gray pp.13-19)
Lucy Reynell (d.1652) of Forde, Newton Abbot, wife of Richard Reynell (died 1633) (Gray pp.20-22)
Mrs Partington of Sidmouth, source of political cartoons (not Mrs Partington) (Gray pp.72-6)
Louisa Trefusis, Lady Rolle (d.1885) (Gray pp.77-80)
Sarah Brydges Willyams (d. 1863 or 5), friend of Benjamin Disraeli (Gray pp.86-9)
The Misses Skinner, set up "Hotel of Rest for Women in Business" (1878-) in Babbacombe (Gray pp.91-8)
Dame Audrey Georgiana Buller (1884–1953), daughter of Redvers Buller (Gray pp.143-4)
Juanita Maxwell Phillips (b. c.1880), first woman mayor in West Country, in Honiton (Gray p.144)
Mabel L. Ramsay (d.1954), medical doctor, suffragette in Plymouth (Gray pp.123-6) done.-PR
Suffragism in Devon (Gray pp.107-123)

Architecture

Grade I listed buildings

See sub lists of Grade I listed buildings in Devon

Grade II* listed buildings

See sub lists of Grade II* listed buildings in Devon

Sport

Men's football

St Luke's College F.C. (played in the Western Football League 1966–1978)

Women's football

Devon Women's Football League

Missing photos

Leaderboard

Discussion moved to talk page:

Devon contest overall ranking

Worm and Stacey - 1990 points (Winner: + 500 points WINNER of Devon Contest.)
Cwmhiraeth - 1805 points (+200 (+300 compensation) points for finishing Devon contest in 2nd place
Rodw - 930 points (+100 points for finishing Devon contest in 3rd place)
Ritchie333 - 320 points
Hchc2009 - 150 points (+400 two GAs pending)
Strumvogel_66 - 80 points
Penny Richards - 20 points
Deb - 10 points
Gasheadsteve - 10 points

Day 7

Rodw - 725 points (Winner: + £10)
Cwmhiraeth - 590 points
Worm and Stacey - 300 points
Penny Richards - 15 points
Deb - 10 points

Day 8

Cwmhiraeth - 430 points (Winner: + £10)
Ritchie333 - 320 points
Rodw - 75 points
Gasheadsteve - 10 points
Penny Richards - 10 points

Day 9

Worm and Stacey - 1190 points (Winner: + £10)
Cwmhiraeth - 285 points
Sturmvogel_66 - 280 points
Hchc2009 - 150 points (+400 two GAs pending)
Ritchie333 - 65 points
Rodw - 30 points
Penny Richards - 10 points

Overall scoreboard

After nine days:

Worm and Stacey - 4530 points
Cwmhiraeth - 3780 points
Sturmvogel_66 - 2550 points
Ritchie333 - 1975 points
Rodw - 975 points
Gasheadsteve - 395 points
D Eaketts - 270 points
Penny Richards - 180 points
Deb - 60 points
Hchc2009 - 175 points (+400 two GAs pending)

Contestants

User:Cwmhiraeth

North Devon Council - core article destubbed = 75 points [2] Y
Brendon - destubbed + ghastly = 30 points [3] Y
Compton Castle - core article destubbed = 75 points [4] Y
Loughwood Meeting House - core article destubbed = 75 points [5] Y
Luscombe Castle - destubbed = 25 points [6] I conflicted with WTT on this one. Y
Maristow House - core article destubbed = 75 points [7] Y
Torridge - core article destubbed, no refs = 80 points [8] Y
West Devon - core article destubbed, no refs = 80 points [9] Y
Devon Wildlife Trust - core article destubbed = 75 points [10]Y
Tavy Bridge - core article destubbed = 75 points [11]Y
@Dr. Blofeld: I don't want to sound like sour grapes, but this article cites a Commons photograph for the entire "Structure" section, including opening dates and the information given is not in that source. I have dropped in a source verifying the 1889 opening date, but I really don't think 75 points should be accepted. (FWIW, even if the points were deducted, Cwmhiraeth would still have the highest score). Ritchie333 ^(talk) ^(cont) 10:06, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Well, ideally yes, the articles should have no sourcing issues, I didn't spot this commons source. I have been more lenient with this contest though, I've corrected/filled out refs on a few other contestants work. Should I really give no points for this though?♦ Dr. Blofeld 10:13, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

I didn't say no points, as some work was done on a core article so it is worth merit. Ritchie333 ^(talk)

I can deduct 25 points for sourcing issues, but the 50 for core I think should still stand.♦ Dr. Blofeld 10:28, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

I think 55 is fairer, it's a core article and there was some work. Ritchie333 ^(talk)

^(cont) 10:33, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

OK, I'll deduct 20.♦ Dr. Blofeld

One of my other sources covers most of the structure section so I should be able to deal with the tag you have added. Amazingly, only one end of the bridge is a listed building. Cwmhiraeth (talk) 10:57, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

@Dr. Blofeld and Ritchie333: I was incorrect there, both ends are separately listed, with a time difference of three years. I think I have addressed Ritchie333's concerns. Cwmhiraeth (talk) 12:37, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Yup, that looks okay now. Ritchie333 ^(talk) ^(cont) 12:56, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Bradley (house) - core article destubbed = 75 points [12]Y
South West Water - core article destubbed = 75 points [13]Y
Exeter Science Park - core article destubbed = 75 points [14]Y
Devon County Show - core article destubbed = 75 points [15]Y
Coombe Cellars - core article destubbed + ghastly = 80 points [16] Y
Hillsborough, Devon - destubbed = 25 points [17] Y
Combeinteignhead - destubbed = 25 points [18] Y
Plymouth Science Park - core article destubbed + ghastly + no refs = 80 points? I completely rewrote this but unfortunately, some editor has since been along and added another ghastly tag. [19]Y
Plymouth Arts Centre - core article destubbed = 75 points The same editor interfered with this one too![20] or [21]Y

User:Gasheadsteve

Devon Women's Football League new article – 10 points Y

User: Hchc2009

Dartmouth Castle expanded, put up for GA. -75 points Y (+200 GA) Y
Kingswear Castle expanded, put up for GA. -75 points Y (+200 GA)Y

User:Penny Richards

Mabel L. Ramsay new article +10. Y
Miriam Bannister cleanup, new content, new refs, and a photo uploaded, but still stubby, so +5.Y
Sarah Brydges Willyams new article +10.Y
Mary Rose Columba Adams new article +10.Y

Ritchie333

Oldway Mansion core article, cleaned up all unsourced content - 55 points Y
River Plym core article, destubbed, cleaned up references, removed {{refimprove}} tag - 80 points Y
Countess Wear destubbed, 25 points Y
The Milky Way (amusement park) core article, was completely unsourced with 161 bytes of prose and an {{advert}} tag. There's only one answer to that, and it's some WP:TNT - 80 points Y
River Meavy destubbed, 25 points Y
Exeter sourced and cleaned up the postwar rebuilding and some transport history, 5 points (can't really claim 50 as it's not a major cleanup) Y It was still a core (very core) article cleanup though, so you're entitled to the 50 for editing a core article.♦ Dr. Blofeld 09:05, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
A30 road core article, added some information on historic turnpike between Chard and Honiton (on topic!) and a bit about highwayman, trimmed out a bunch of unsourced WP:RECENTISM (as was) about Goss Moor which I think is largely off-topic .... anyway, most of the article is now reliably sourced. 55 points. Y
River Yarty, new article, only ~~5 points I think as it's still a stub, but I was genuinely surprised to find this was a redlink from several articles Y~~ now 10 points as I have just got it above 1.5K of prose
Marsh, Devon, new article, but again I have to wave a white flag and produce a stub. I'm not declaring any points, but rather I'm putting this out as maybe an easy 25 points for somebody else. Unfortunately, the name has brought up so many false positives I am struggling to even put the easy stuff on (older maps have a church at Marsh - what was it called and when was it build?) Can somebody else help? Y I'll give 5 for each but we're really trying to avoid stubs with this and reduce the number of stubs we have!♦ Dr. Blofeld 18:28, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

User:Rodw

Museum of British Surfing new article & new pic - 15 points Y
Pickwell, Devon new article & new pic - 15 points Y
Barnstaple Long Bridge core article destubbed - 75 points Y
Bickleigh Castle core article destubbed - 75 points Y
Hillersdon House core article destubbed (including removing large copyvio) - 75 points Y
Kelly House, Devon core article destubbed - 75 points Y
Bradwell, Devon new pic added - 15 points Y
Braunton Academy new pic added - 15 points Y
Trimstone new pic added - 15 points Y
Swanpool, Devon new pic added - 15 points Y
Slapton Ley destub & sort "refimprove" banner - 30 points Y
Fowlescombe Manor core article destubbed - 75 points Y
The Plough Arts Centre, Torrington core article destubbed - 75 points Y
Lee Abbey add coords - 5 points (can you try to flesh it out a tad?)- done.— Rod ^talk 13:22, 14 August 2016 (UTC)Y[reply]
~~Royal Castle Hotel fix CS1 error accessdate - 5 points<./s>~~

~~Lynmouth Flood fix CS1 error accessdate - 5 points~~

~~Saltrock fix CS1 error |first1= missing |last1= in Authors list - 5 points~~

To give you the 5 points on each of those you'd have to do some sort of content addition or multiple reference cleanup I think! The 5 points wasn't intended for very minor fixes, more a reasonable "half" cleanup/improvement job.♦ Dr. Blofeld 12:57, 14 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Dolphin Inn, Plymouth core article destubbed - 75 pointsY
Was about to pick this one up myself - I used to drink here every Christmas day (odd family tradition)... it's not quite over the line - 1469 charcters, you shouldn't have much trouble getting it there. Worm^TT(talk) 16:20, 14 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

The counter Dr Blofeld recomended says 1529.— Rod ^talk 16:53, 14 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
Fair enough. I think that counter includes the reference numbers (I get 1469 using the DYK counter), but if that's the one Dr B is recommending that's the best one to use. Worm^TT(talk) 17:03, 14 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

~~Kingswear Regatta core article destubbed (+ added references & deorphaned removing banner) - 75 points~~ -still has some unsourced claims in it... Strike this one while I sort out whether it needs to be merged with Port of Dartmouth Royal Regatta.— Rod ^talk 14:51, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

~~Kennaway House add refs etc to unreferenced core article but wasn't a stub so 5 points~~ @Rodw: Can you source the quote and last paragraph?♦ Dr. Blofeld 10:26, 15 August 2016 (UTC) Last para sourced - but I can't source the quote so strike this one.— Rod ^talk 15:30, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Sandridge Park core article destubbed - 75 points -2nd paragraph is unsourced. Now referenced.— Rod ^talk 15:59, 16 August 2016 (UTC)Y[reply]

Salcombe Castle destubbed - 25 pointsY

Axminster Museum expanded but still under 1500 so 5 points Y

User:Deb
[edit]

Rachel Bourchier, Countess of Bath. New article.Y

User:Worm That Turned (and User:Staceydolxx)
[edit]

Exeter Racecourse - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Plymouth Hospitals NHS Trust - core article destubbed (almost ashamed of the lack of work to destub that)- 75 points Y

Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital - core article destubbing (again with almost no work) - 75 points Y

Kirkham House - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Luscombe Castle core article expansion. 50+25 (well over 3k added!) Y Also nominated for GA (+200 if it gets there) Y

Escot House - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Sidbury Manor - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Pynes House - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Sherford - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Atlantic Array - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Bridge Inn, Topsham - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Stowford House - core article destubbed (no sources)- 80 points Y

Drewe Arms, Drewsteignton - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Shiphay Manor - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

Luppitt Inn - core article destubbed and detagged - 80 points (I really want to go there!)Y

Pennon Group - core article destubbed - 75 pointsY

BBC Radio Devon - core article destubbed (no sources) - 80 points Y

Derriford Hospital - core article destubbed - 75 points Y

User:Sturmvogel_66
[edit]

HMS Devonshire (39) Core article expanded plus nasty tag removed 80 points (+200 GAN) [22] Y

Finally promoted--Sturmvogel 66 (talk) 04:04, 31 August 2016 (UTC) Y[reply]

v
t
e
The West Country Challenge
Main pages

Main page outline (talk)

Prize winners

Subcontests

Bristol (Day 1–3) (Won by Worm and Stacey)

Cornwall and Scilly (Day 4–6) (Won by Cwmhiraeth)

Devon (Day 7–9) (Won by Worm and Stacey)

Dorset (Day 10–12) (Won by Cwmhiraeth)

Gloucestershire (Day 13–15) (Won by Cwmhiraeth)

Somerset (Day 16–18) (Won by Worm and Stacey)

Wiltshire (Day 19–21) (Won by Cwmhiraeth)

Article/photograph lists

Core articles

Missing article hotlist

Missing photograph hotlist