User:Pbsouthwood/FA analysis 2
Resources:
- User:Mike Christie/Sandbox9
- Wikipedia:Featured articles: Revision history for updates
- Wikipedia:List of Wikipedians by featured article nominations for number of stars.
The columns are:
- Title of the nominated article
- How many times the article has been nominated at FAC
- Reason archived
- The month in which it was promoted or archived
- The date the article was nominated at FAC.
- The number of nominators
- The nominators' names.
- Number of FAs the nominator has had promoted as of the date of the nomination, and date of latest promotion.
- The name of the editors who reviewed the FAC.
- Mentor
| Article Title | Arch. no. |
Reason archived | Arch. Month |
Nom Date | Num. Noms |
Nominator/s | Stars Latest dated |
Reviewers | Mentor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 Bank of America 500 | 1 | No reviews | Aug 2016 | 18 Jul 2016 | 1 | User:MWright96 | 1 5 Jan 2017 |
None | |
| Community Transit | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Aug 2016 | 15 Jul 2016 | 1 | User:SounderBruce | 0 (1 since) |
Casliber | |
| Valley View (Romney, West Virginia) | 1 | Nominator unresponsive | Aug 2016 | 9 Jul 2016 | 1 | User:West Virginian | 6 9 Jul 2016 |
Checkingfax, Brianboulton, Noswall59 |
|
| 1999 Atlantic hurricane season | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Sep 2016 | 9 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:12george1 | 5 19 Jul 2014 |
Hurricanehink | |
| 2006 Bank of America 500 | 2 | No Reviews | Sep 2016 | 29 Aug 2016 | 1 | User:MWright96 | 1 5 Jan 2017 |
none | |
| Jessica Chastain | 1 | Abandoned by nominator | Sep 2016 | 8 Aug 2016 | 1 | User:Krimuk90 (indef) | 5 30 Jul 2016 |
Nick-D Nergaal Gerda Arendt Dank FrB.TG Victoriaearle John |
|
| Glen Canyon Dam | 1 | Not ready | Sep 2016 | 1 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:Shannon1 | 2 30 Jul 2013 |
Carbrera | |
| 2015 NBL Canada Finals brawl | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Sep 2016 | 3 Aug 2016 | 1 | User:TempleM | 2 25 Dec 2015 |
Mike Christie | |
| Chhinnamasta | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Oct 2016 | 2 Oct 2016 | 1 | User:Redtigerxyz | 5 | J Milburn | |
| Bicycle kick | 2 | Insufficient reviews | Oct 2016 | 23 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:MarshalN20 | 3 | Brianboulton Praemonitus |
|
| Viking metal | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Oct 2016 | 23 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:3family6 | 1 | Retrohead | |
| CMLL World Welterweight Championship | 1 | No reviews | Oct 2016 | 15 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:MPJ-DK | 4 | N/A | |
| Fallout 4: Far Harbor | 1 | Prose, insufficient reviews | Oct 2016 | 21 Aug 2016 | 1 | User:Anarchyte | 1 | David Fuchs J Milburn |
|
| Beta-Hydroxy beta-methylbutyric acid | 1 | Withdrawn after prolonged disputes | Oct 2016 | 12 Aug 2016 | 2 | User:Seppi333 User:Boghog |
1 14 Jan 2015 1 14 Jan 2015 |
Doc James Nergaal Jytdog Zefr Sizeofint WhatamIdoing John Axl |
|
| Thomas Bailey Marquis | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Nov 2016 | 16 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:SpinningSpark | 5 | Nikkimaria J Milburn |
|
| House of Music | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Dec 2016 | 4 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:Dan56 | 16 | Jennica Dank TheAmazingPeanuts |
|
| CMLL World Welterweight Championship | 2 | Insufficient reviews | Dec 2016 | 2 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:MPJ-DK | 4 | Dank | |
| Chhinnamasta | 2 | Insufficient reviews | Dec 2016 | 2 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:Redtigerxyz | 5 | Midnightblueowl | |
| Courtney Love | 4 | No consensus | Dec 2016 | 25 Sep 2016 | 1 | User:Drown Soda | 1 | Praemonitus Mark Miller Mike Christie Midnightblueowl Sagaciousphil |
|
| Battle of Prokhorovka | 1 | No consensus | Dec 2016 | 6 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:EyeTruth | 1 | AustralianRupert K.e.coffman Nikkimaria ÄDA - DÄP |
|
| H. H. Asquith | 1 | Insufficient support / no consensus | Dec 2016 | 21 Oct 2016 | 3 | User:Wehwalt User:Tim riley User:KJP1 |
158 ? ? |
Paulturtle Nikkimaria Dudley Miles |
|
| Beta-Hydroxy beta-methylbutyric acid | 2 | No consensus | Dec 2016 | 18 Oct 2016 | 2 | User:Seppi333 User:Boghog |
1 14 Jan 2015 1 14 Jan 2015 |
Mirokado Doc James John Graeme Bartlett CFCF |
|
| Coloman, King of Hungary | 1 | No consensus (outstanding oppose) | Jan 2017 | 22 Nov 2016 | 1 | User:Borsoka | 1 | Dank Nikkimaria Tintor2 Casliber Sarastro1 Ealdgyth |
|
| Joker (comics) | 2 | No consensus (ongoing dispute) | Jan 2017 | 2 Jan 2017 | 1 | User:Darkwarriorblake | 7 | Curly Turkey J Milburn Aoba47 |
|
| This England (album) | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Jan 2017 | 24 Dec 2016 | 1 | User:Another Believer | 4 | Smerus Brandt Luke Zorn Jonesey95 Grand'mere Eugene Nikkimaria Syek88 Lemongirl942 |
|
| Star of Bengal | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Jan 2017 | 8 Jan 2017 | 1 | User:凰兰时罗 | 1 | Laser brain Mymis Indopug Nikkimaria |
|
| Mikhail Petrovich Petrov (general) | 1 | No consensus | Jan 2017 | 12 Oct 2017 | 1 | User:Kges1901 | 1 | Krishna Chaitanya Velaga Dank AustralianRupert Tony1 Nikkimaria Ian Rose |
|
| Lead | 1 | Multiple issues, incl. prose. | Feb 2017 | 16 Feb 2016 | 2 | User:R8R Gtrs | 3 | Hawkeye7 Nergaal John |
|
| Fragment of a Crucifixion | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Feb 2017 | 26 Feb 2017 | 1 | User:Ceoil | 45 | Caeciliusinhorto | |
| Peter Prevc | 1 | Insufficient support | Feb 2017 | 28 Dec 2016 | 1 | User:Tone | 3 | Icebob99 Syek88 Victoriaearle |
|
| Beta-Hydroxy beta-methylbutyric acid | 3 | Withdrawn due to lack of reviews | Feb 2017 | 1 Jan 2017 | 2 | User:Seppi333 User:Boghog |
1 14 Jan 2015 1 14 Jan 2015 |
Doc James SlimVirgin |
|
| Henry Morgan | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Feb 2017 | 12/8/2016 | 1 | User:The Bounder | 2 | Nikkimaria Caeciliusinhorto HJ Mitchell Nick-D Nikkimaria Iridescent Wehwalt Ealdgyth Laser brain SlimVirgin |
|
| Nights: Journey of Dreams | 1 | Prose issues | Mar 2017 | 27 Feb 2017 | 1 | User:Jaguar | 5 | Aoba47 Tintor2 ProtoDrake Jo-Jo Eumerus Hawkeye7 Syek88 Casliber |
|
| D.Gray-man | 1 | Prose issues | Mar 2017 | 27 Feb 2017 | 1 | User:Tintor2 | 2 | Aoba47 Jaguar 1989 Narutolovehinata5 Lingzhi Jo-Jo Eumerus ProtoDrake JDC808 Mike Christie |
|
| Heathenry (new religious movement) | 1 | No consensus | Mar 2017 | 14 feb 2017 | 1 | User:Midnightblueowl | 17 | Johnbod FunkMonk 22mikpau |
|
| Oxford College of Emory University | 2 | No consensus, outstanding issues. | Mar 2017 | 2 Mar 2017 | 1 | User:Haha169 | 1 | Juliancolton Nikkimaria Syek88 |
|
| Steller's sea cow | 1 | No consensus | Mar 2017 | 22 Jan 2017 | 1 | User:Dunkleosteus77 | 2 | FunkMonk Vanamonde93 Mike Christie Jens Lallensack Ealdgyth Elmidae Dudley Miles |
|
| Louis Leblanc | 1 | No consensus, outstanding issues. | Mar 2017 | 13 Jan 2017 | 1 | User:Kaiser matias | 9 | Dank Mike Christie Sturmvogel 66 Moisejp Syek88 |
|
| William Pūnohu White | 1 | Insufficient reviews | Mar 2017 | 4 Feb 2017 | 1 | User:KAVEBEAR | 4 | Maile66 | |
| Bengal famine of 1943 | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator's request | Apr 2017 | 29 Apr 2017 | 1 | User:Lingzhi | 6 | Nick-D Fowler&fowler Graham Beards RegentsPark Ms Sarah Welch |
|
| William Pūnohu White | 2 | No consensus / insufficient reviews | Apr 2017 | 11 Mar 2017 | 1 | User:KAVEBEAR | 4 | Hawkeye7 Casliber Wehwalt Dank HJ Mitchell |
|
| Mary Kom (film) | 1 | No consensus | Apr 2017 | 22 feb 2017 | 1 | User:Krish! | 1 | Aoba47 Pavanjandhyala Kailash29792 Numerounovedant Giants2008 Ssven2 Syek88 Numerounovedant FrB.TG |
|
| Briarcliff Manor Public Library | 2 | Dispute | Apr 2017 | 20 Jan 2017 | 1 | User:Ɱ | 2 (27 June 2015) |
Fencer2013 Ajfeist Bluerasberrry PointsofNoReturn Woebegone Axl Ceoil Tony1 |
|
| The Seventh Victim | 1 | Insufficient support / reviews | May 2017 | 14 Apr 2017 | 1 | User:Drown Soda | 1 | Dank Ian Rose SlimVirgin |
|
| CMLL World Lightweight Championship | 1 | No consensus | May 2017 | 6 Mar 2017 | 1 | User:MPJ-DK | 4 | Dank Casliber Jo-Jo Eumerus Giants2008 Brianboulton Siuenti Tisquesusa SlimVirgin |
|
| Great white shark | 1 | Insufficient review, no consensus. | May 2017 | 22 May 2017 | 1 | User:Pvmoutside | 1 | Jimfbleak LittleJerry FunkMonk |
|
| Naruto | 2 | No consensus, outstanding issues | May 2017 | 9 Apr 2017 | 1 | User:1989 | 2 | Tintor2 Gen. Quon Aoba47 ISD Mike Christie Casliber |
|
| Yu Kanda | 1 | Withdrawn on nominator's request | May 2017 | 24 Apr 2017 | 1 | User:Tintor2 | 2 | ISD Aoba47 Jaguar Jo-Jo Eumerus Brianboulton Lois Lane vs Mary Jane |
|
| Appian Way Productions | 1 | Withdrawn by nominator | Jul 17 | 25 Jun 2017 | 1 | User:FrB.TG | 6 | Numerounovedant Dank Aoba47 Jo-Jo Eumerus Pavanjandhyala Sarastro1 |
|
| Loev (film) | 1 | Withdrawn on nominator's request | Jul 2017 | 18 Jun 2017 | 1 | User:Numerounovedant | 3 | Dank Aoba47 FrB.TG IndianBio Kailash29792 1989 Ceranthor |
|
| Crusades | 1 | No consensus, stalled with outstanding issues. | Jul 2017 | 29 May 2017 | 1 | User:Norfolkbigfish | 1 | Hchc2009 Smurrayinchester Johnbod Dank Display name 99 Seraphim System |
|
| Dan Bain | 2 | Insufficient reviews | Jul 2017 | 18 Jun 2017 | 1 | User:Kaiser matias | 9 | Dank Nikkimaria |
|
| Lazarus (comics) | 1 | No reviews | Jul 2017 | 9 Jun 2017 | 1 | User:Argento Surfer | 2 | none | |
| Astronomica (Manilius) | 1 | Withdrawn on nominator's request | Jul 2017 | 23 Jun 2017 | 1 | User:Gen. Quon | 10 | Edwininlondon Nikkimaria J Milburn Casliber Ceoil |
Analysis
[edit]Number of archived nominations: 54 Reason for archiving:
- Insufficient reviews: 19/54 = 35%
- Includes no reviews: 4/54 = 7%
- Withdrawn by nominator: 12/54 = 22%
- No consensus: 17/54 = 31%
- Abandoned by nominator without explanation: 1/54 = 2%
- Dispute: 1
- Prose issues: 4
Nominator with no FA
Successful 1st FAs
[edit]Date of promotion, Article, Nominator, Stars to date, Date of nomination
- 10 August 2017 The Getaway (1972 film) Bluesphere (1) 22 June 2017
- 9 August 2017 True Detective (season 1) DAP388 (1) User:Mike Christie (61) 11 June 2017
- 1 August 2017 Banksia serrata user:Gderrin (1) & Casliber (154) 20 July 2017
- 26 July 2017 6th Regiment Massachusetts Volunteer Militia Historical Perspective 2 (1) 30 June 2017
- 8 July 2017 Disneyland Railroad Jackdude101 (1) 20 June 2017
- 3 July 2017 History of the British penny (1901–1970) Wehwalt (156), Arwel Parry (1) 17 June 2017
- 24 June 2017 Boogeyman 2 PanagiotisZois (1) 9 May 2017
- 17 June 2017 Evita (1996 film) FrankRizzo2006 (1) 21 March 2017
- 8 June 2017 Fallout 4: Far Harbor Anarchyte (1) 18 April 2017
- 7 June 2017 Arlington, Washington SounderBruce (1) 7 May 2017
- 2 June 2017 Battle of Prokhorovka EyeTruth (1) 30 April 2017
- 29 May 2017 Dire wolf William Harris (1) 19 April 2017
- 30 April 2017 Van Diemen's Land v Port Phillip, 1851 Lourdes (1) and Sarastro1 (27) 12 April 2017
- 14 April 2017 Operation Grandslam Indy beetle (1) 13 March 2017
- 12 April 2017 INS Vikrant (R11) Krishna Chaitanya Velaga (1) 2017
- 4 April 2017 The Founding Ceremony of the Nation 如沐西风(RúMùXīFēng) (1) Wehwalt (150) 19 March 2017
- 1 April 2017 William T. Stearn Michael Goodyear (1) 24 February 2017
- 31 March 2017 Alan Shepard JustinTime55 (1) and Hawkeye7 (54) 16 February 2017
- 27 March 2017 Operation Mincemeat The Bounder (1) 1 March 2017
- 27 March 2017 North Ronaldsay sheep TheMagikCow (1) 13 February 2017
- 11 March 2017 Courtney Love Drown Soda (1) 5 February 2017
- 4 March 2017 Archie vs. Predator Argento Surfer (1) 29 December 2016
- 1 March 2017 Ben Crosby A Texas Historian (1) 18 December 2016
- 1 March 2017 Oran fatwa HaEr48 (1) 28 January 2017
- 21 February 2017 Piano Concerto No. 24 (Mozart) Syek88 (1) 23 December 2016
- 17 February 2017 Gabriel Pleydell Curlymanjaro (1) 4 December 2016
- 13 February 2017 Grey jay User:Ivanvector (1) & Casliber (140) 28 January 2017
- 13 February 2017 Virgin and Child Enthroned (van der Weyden) Ceoil (44), Ayesha23 (1) 15 January 2017
- 28 January 2017 Viking metal 3family6 (1) 31 October 2016
- 28 January 2017 Aitraaz Krish! (1) 10 December 2016
- 22 January 2017 Mangrove swallow RileyBugz (1) 27 December 2016
- 21 January 2017 The American Bible Challenge Bcschneider53 (1) 26 November 2016
- 17 January 2017 Jennifer Lawrence FrB.TG (6) SNUGGUMS (2) Krimuk2.0 (1) 9 December 2016
- 5 January 2017 2014 Japanese Grand Prix MWright96 (1) 25 November 2016
- 25 December 2016 Operation Infinite Reach GeneralizationsAreBad (1) 20 August 2016
- 24 December 2016 Belgium national football team Kareldorado (1) 27 September 2016
- 22 December 2016 Jochen Rindt Zwerg Nase (1) 25 October 2016
- 1 December 2016 The Pale Emperor Homeostasis07 (1) 6 September 2016
- 26 November 2016 Ike Altgens ATS (1) 30 September 2016
- 20 November 2016 Night of January 16th RL0919 (1) 5 September 2016, Mentored: User:Curly Turkey
- 19 November 2016 2015 Formula One season Tvx1 (1) 31 August 2016
- 1 November 2016 Sabrina Sidney Worm That Turned (2) & Staceydolxx (1) 8 August 2016
- 1 November 2016 Taylor Swift FrB.TG (4) and User:IndianBio (1) 19 September 2016
- 30 October 2016 Allen Walker Tintor2 (1) 6 September 2016
- 29 October 2016 Turboliner Mackensen (1) 1 September 2016
- 22 October 2016 Secretariat (horse) Montanabw (13) Jlvsclrk (1) 17 September 2016
- 22 October 2016 Heavy metal (chemical element) Sandbh (1) 7 August 2016
- 15 October 2016 Divisional Cavalry Regiment (New Zealand) Kges1901 (1) 8 August 2016
- 30 September 2016 Bud Dunn White Arabian Filly (1) 1 August 2016
- 30 September 2016 Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward Famous Hobo (1) 20 July 2016
- 15 September 2016 Lazarus Aaronson P. S. Burton (1) 28 July 2016
- 9 September 2016 The Left Hand of Darkness Vanamonde93 (1) 8 July 2016
- 3 September 2016 Bluebuck FunkMonk (29) Sainsf (5) & 7&6=thirteen (1) 26 July 2016