User:BilledMammal/ARBPIA claim review
This reviews the contributions of a small number of editors regarding their additions and removals of the word "claim", the use of which is discouraged by MOS:CLAIM. Editors who consistently add "claim" to content relating to one side's POV, and remove it from content relating to the others, are likely to be engaged in POV pushing.
- Example – Added "claim" to content related to an Israeli POV (Advances the Palestinian POV)
- Example – Removed "claim" from content related to an Israeli POV (Advances the Israeli POV)
- Example – Added "claim" to content related to a Palestinian POV (Advances the Israeli POV)
- Example – Removed "claim" from content related to a Palestinian POV (Advances the Palestinian POV)
- Example – Added or removed "claim" from content related to both an Israeli POV and a Palestinian POV
CarmenEsparzaAmoux
[edit]| Article | Diff | Edit summary | Previous text | New text |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses | 2024-05-01T00:43:42Z | /* Public and students */ ce, Sarsour | A doctorial student at UT claimed that Abbott used the protest and resulting police actions to further his political agenda on right wing ideals. | A doctoral student at UT stated that Abbott used the protest and resulting police actions to further his political agenda on right wing ideals. |
| Israel–Hamas war protests in the United States | 2024-01-30T03:02:11Z | /* Political */ Pelosi | Nancy Pelosi drew condemnation after claiming that anti-war protesters were being funded by Vladimir Putin and should be investigated by the FBI. | |
| Effect of the Israel–Hamas war on children in the Gaza Strip | 2024-02-11T20:01:45Z | /* Use of children by Hamas */ this appears to rely solely on IDF allegations | Use of children by Hamas | IDF claims regarding children and Hamas |
| Casualties of the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-22T20:35:54Z | /* Militants */ Salhut | Analyst Hamdah Salhut, however, stated Israel had provided no evidence to support the numbers it was claiming | |
| Casualties of the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-11T13:41:51Z | /* Health and aid workers */ UNRWA statement | On 11 November, UNRWA rejected Israel's claims that UN workers were undercover Hamas agents. | |
| Gaza Strip evacuations | 2023-10-15T12:36:24Z | /* Israeli humanitarian motives and accusations of war crime */ we can't ascribe motives, we know only what they are saying | Israeli humanitarian motives and accusations of war crime | Israeli humanitarian claims and accusations of war crime |
| Humanitarian aid during the Israel–Hamas war | 2024-03-29T03:27:59Z | /* Killing of aid seekers */ media office | The IDF claimed that in actuality IDF forces did not fire upon aid seekers but that "armed Palestinians" did. | The IDF denied IDF forces fired upon aid seekers and that "armed Palestinians" did. |
| Killing of journalists in the Israel–Hamas war | 2024-01-31T00:16:51Z | organize lead | Reporters Without Borders claimed that the Israeli army had deliberately targeted Palestinian and Lebanese journalists. | Reporters Without Borders has accused the Israeli army of intentionally targeting Palestinian and Lebanese journalists. |
| Gaza Strip famine | 2024-01-17T18:24:27Z | MOS:CLAIM | The Israeli NGO Btselem has claimed that the famine is a direct outcome of Israeli policy | The Israeli NGO Btselem has stated the famine is a direct outcome of Israeli policy |
| Israel–Hamas war protests | 2023-10-29T13:12:56Z | Mondoweiss claim | On 28 October, Mondoweiss claimed the protests against Israeli actions in Gaza were the largest anti-war protests in the United States since the Iraq War protests | |
| Media coverage of the Israel–Hamas war | 2024-03-06T21:31:47Z | /* Screams Without Words */ AJ | Summarizing the controversy, Al Jazeera stated that the claims in "Screams Without Words" "have since been revealed to be unsubstantiated, demonstrating the Times' pro-Israeli/anti-Palestinian bias and leaving the paper's newsroom riven by dissent." | |
| Misinformation in the Israel–Hamas war | 2024-10-08T04:00:44Z | /* Elsewhere */ add detail and source | Bash and Tapper were repeating claims first made by Nessel in a social media post criticizing a racist caricature suggesting Tlaib was a member of Hezbollah | |
| UNRWA and Israel | 2024-03-17T14:36:04Z | /* International community */ Van Hollen | In March 2024, U.S. Senator Chris Van Hollen stated Israel's claims about a connection between UNRWA and Hamas were "flat-out lies" and that "Netanyahu’s wanted to get rid of UNRWA because he has seen them as a means to continue the hopes of the Palestinian people for a homeland of their own". | |
| UNRWA and Israel | 2024-03-01T17:35:34Z | /* Response from UNRWA and the United Nations */ UN 29 feb statement | on 29 February, the United Nations announced it still had not received any evidence from Israel to support its claims | |
| UNRWA and Israel | 2024-02-21T01:13:39Z | /* top */ Lazzarini Haaretz | On 19 February, Lazzarini stated Israel had not provided any evidence to support its claim | |
| UNRWA and Israel | 2024-02-08T21:30:17Z | /* International community */ canada | On 8 February, the Canadian government stated it had still not seen any evidence to support Israel's claims | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-20T14:31:12Z | MOS:ALLEGED, MOS:AWW | Sources have claimed that Israel's actions resulted in a severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza. | Israel's actions resulted in a severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza. |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-08T19:47:15Z | /* Humanitarian situation */ creating subsection and adding additional information | Qatari government official Mohammed El Emadi condemned Israel's claims that Gazan hospitals were used for military purposes, stating they were made "without concrete evidence or an independent investigation" as a "blatant attempt to justify the occupation’s targeting of civilian facilities." | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-08T19:25:48Z | /* In Gaza */ adding Reuters note | the Gaza Ministry of Health claimed more than 4,000 children were killed in Gaza | the Gaza Ministry of Health recorded more than 4,000 children killed in Gaza |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-03T20:26:00Z | /* In Gaza */ editing for concision, moving info on communications blackout to timeline, moving info on stockpile to aid section, and removing MOS:ALLEGED statement from Hamas that fails WP:ECREE, WP:UNDUE | Eiland stressed that "this is not a program for revenge" The New York Times reported that Hamas had stockpiled fuel, food, water and medicine |
Eiland claimed this not "a program for revenge," The New York Times claimed Hamas had a stockpile of food, water, and medicine. |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-30T01:45:19Z | /* Humanitarian aid */ humanitarian zone in Khan Younis | On 29 October, a humanitarian zone was announced in the Khan Younis area, along with a claim that aid trucks would increase "significantly." | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-28T17:09:44Z | /* In Gaza */ cleanup and copyediting | The New York Times reported that Hamas had stockpiled fuel, food, water and medicine | The New York Times claimed Hamas had a stockpile of food, water, and medicine. |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-28T02:44:10Z | /* 27 October */ IDF and Lynk statements | The IDF claimed military operations were hidden beneath the Al-Shifa Hospital, leading Michael Lynk, a former UN rapporteur, to state the IDF was preparing "public opinion for the attacks to come." | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-26T18:20:12Z | /* Civilians */ Matthew Miller comments | Matthew Miller made a similar claim to Biden; however, the US Department of State cites the Gaza Health Ministry's death tolls in its own reports. | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-16T13:42:09Z | /* Water */ water update | On 16 October, Minister of Energy Israel Katz claimed water was available at Bnei Sahila, near southern Khan Younis, though Gaza Interior Ministry spokesman Eyad Al-Bozom said water was still unavailable. | |
| Attacks on health facilities during the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-12T23:39:06Z | /* Al-Shifa Hospital siege */ BBC and the Independent | Analysis from BBC and The Independent found Israel's claims of a Hamas base at al-Shifa to be "unconvincing." | |
| Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip | 2024-02-10T04:25:15Z | /* 8 February */ date and add 8 feb info | Israeli Prime Minister’s Office claimed that elimination of Hamas remains impossible without the destruction of the four Hamas battalions in Rafah which is the last major population center in Gaza not occupied by the IDF. | |
| Nasser Hospital siege | 2024-02-20T03:53:46Z | /* Reactions */ Tedros | Israel's claims were also directly contradicted by World Health Organization secretary-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus who stated, "The hospital is still experiencing an acute shortage of food, basic medical supplies, and oxygen. | |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2024-03-23T15:13:37Z | /* 18 March */ IDF statements into statements section, MOS:CLAIM, c/e | On Monday 18 March 2024, Israeli forces began an operation to clear Al-Shifa hospital of militants that they claimed were operating there Israel claimed to have made 600 arrests Israel claimed to have killed over 170 gunmen inside the hospital grounds |
On Monday 18 March 2024, Israeli forces began an operation in Al-Shifa Israel later stated they made 600 arrests Israel stated they killed over 170 gunmen inside the hospital grounds |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-17T00:26:07Z | /* Israeli claims regarding the hospital */ tunnel claim | Netanyahu claimed to have found a tunnel under al-Shifa, stating in an interview with CBS, "I think the less I say about it, the better." | |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-16T20:08:23Z | /* Reactions */ hellyer and salhut | Al Jazeera journalist Hamdah Salhut, stated Israel had not shown "solid proof, or evidence" to back up their claims | |
| Gaza humanitarian crisis (2023–present) | 2024-01-16T03:24:40Z | /* Palestinian */ reword | The Ministry stated Israel was justifying making Gaza uninhabitable as self-defense. | The Ministry stated Israel was claiming self-defense to justify making Gaza uninhabitable |
| Gaza humanitarian crisis (2023–present) | 2023-11-19T03:42:08Z | /* 9–16 November */ move link, add sources, fix typos | These claims were disputed. | |
| Gaza humanitarian crisis (2023–present) | 2023-11-17T22:59:56Z | /* Since 17 November */ incubators | The director of Al-Shifa stated Israel's claim to provide incubators to premature babies was false. | |
| Gaza humanitarian crisis (2023–present) | 2023-11-10T18:50:21Z | /* Humanitarian aid */ combing short paragraphs | On 29 October, a humanitarian zone was announced in the Khan Younis area, along with a claim that aid trucks would increase "significantly." | |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2024-02-09T04:41:14Z | /* Forced evacuation */ MOS:CLAIM | the Interior Ministry claiming Israel sought to "displace us once again from our land." | the Interior Ministry stating Israel sought to "displace us once again from our land." |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-12T01:32:22Z 2023-11-10T18:34:38Z |
Multiple | the IDF released videos showing Hamas fighters firing from the Sheikh Hamad Hospital | the IDF released videos claiming Hamas fighters fired from the Sheikh Hamad Hospital |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-06T12:15:26Z | /* Medical facilities */ Mohammed El Emadi statement | Qatari official Mohammed El Emadi condemned Israel's claim, stating it was made "without concrete evidence or an independent investigation" and was a "blatant attempt to justify the occupation’s targeting of civilian facilities." | |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-04T16:53:13Z | /* Medical facilities */ adding additional information | Abu Awash made this claim while handcuffed and undergoing IDF interrogation | |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-04T13:58:34Z | /* Medical facilities */ adding statements by doctors, citation needed note, and adjusting language to reflect these statements are all competing claims, shouldn't be in wiki-voice | However, Hamas has been documented to use hospitals and other medical facilities such as ambulances | The IDF claims Hamas uses hospitals and other medical facilities such as ambulances |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-26T01:18:58Z | /* Forced evacuation */ editing syntax, adding quote from gov. official, bundling citations, editing unrelated sentence | the Interior Ministry claiming Israel sought to "displace us once again from our land."[a] | |
| War crimes in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-25T20:03:26Z | /* International reactions */ adding quoted word from source | U.S. officials reported alarm at Israeli expectations of an acceptable death count in Gaza | U.S. officials reported alarm at Israeli claims of the "inevitability" of civilian deaths |
| Rafah offensive | 2024-05-14T21:26:27Z | /* Humanitarian impact */ MOS:CLAIM | the Palestine Red Crescent Society claimed that famine was imminent because of the closure of the Rafah crossing | the Palestine Red Crescent Society stated that famine was imminent because of the closure of the Rafah crossing |
| Killing of Hind Rajab | 2024-02-25T01:08:09Z | /* Investigation */ soldiers present | Israel claimed it did not have soldiers near the site of Rajab's death, leading Al Jazeera to state, "Israel has a history of swiftly clearing its troops of any wrongdoing in cases of abuse against Palestinians." | |
| Al-Tabaeen school attack | 2024-08-25T16:20:32Z | /* Attack */ WP:CLAIM, add source + detail | eyewitnesses claiming that roughly 250 people were inside the prayer hall at the time of the strikes | eyewitnesses stating that roughly 250 people were inside the prayer hall at the time of the strikes |
| Al-Tabaeen school attack | 2024-08-21T14:53:52Z | /* Investigation */ fact check | A fact check by Al Jazeera further cast doubt on Israel's claim that the individuals killed in the attack were "terrorists". | |
| Whitney Biennial | 2024-06-09T02:18:12Z | /* History */ WP:CLAIM, link | The United Nations released a report that claimed Israeli security forces may have committed war crimes | The United Nations released a report stating Israeli security forces may have committed war crimes |
| Sexual and gender-based violence in the 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel | 2024-06-17T01:01:05Z | /* Other investigations and reports */ The Times | The same month, The Times published a report stating that investigators believed that Israel's claims about formally sanctioned sexual assault did not stand up to scrutiny. | |
| Israeli–Palestinian prisoner exchange | 2023-12-15T03:11:11Z | /* Descriptions of prison conditions */ add word | Israel said that it was not aware of these claims, but that all basic rights accorded by the law had been applied | Israel said that it was not aware of these claims, but that all basic rights accorded by the law had been applied |
| Turkish-Palestinian Friendship Hospital | 2023-10-31T00:30:23Z | /* Operation */ matching verbs to sources | Dr. Subhi Skaik claimed that the third floor of the hospital was hit in an Israeli airstrike The Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs condemned the airstrike "in the strongest terms" on the same day, claiming it was a violation of international law. |
Dr. Subhi Skaik stated that the third floor of the hospital was hit in an Israeli airstrike The Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs condemned the airstrike "in the strongest terms" on the same day, stating it was a violation of international law. |
Iskandar323
[edit]| Article | Diff | Edit summary | Previous text | New text |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Al-Aqsa Foundation | 2024-08-24T07:29:00Z | Removing advocacy platform masquerading as source and clarifying | The al-Aqsa Foundation (originally named Al-Aqsa E.V.) is an entity established in 1991 claiming to be a not-for-profit or charity organisation while having links to Hamas. | The al-Aqsa Foundation (originally named Al-Aqsa E.V.) is an entity established in 1991 as a non-profit organisation that some Western governments have said is linked to Hamas. |
| Al-Sardi school attack | 2024-06-12T12:50:15Z | MOS:CLAIM | UNRWA claims approximately 6,000 people have been using it for shelter | UNRWA said approximately 6,000 people were using it for shelter |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2024-03-31T05:00:03Z | /* Alleged military use */Trimming excess and outdated material | The IDF released photos showing "Military uniforms, 11 guns, three military vests, one with a Hamas logo, nine grenades, two Qurans, a string of prayer beads, a box of dates." | The IDF released photos showing "Military uniforms, 11 guns, three military vests, one with a Hamas logo, nine grenades, two Qurans, a string of prayer beads, a box of dates" that they claimed to have found in the hospital. |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2024-03-25T00:25:40Z | /* 24 March */De-editorializing and removing unreliable source | Within hours of Al Jazeera's report the claim of rapes by Irsreali forces had been repeated by articles in Middle East Eye, | Accounts of rapes by Isreali forces were also reported by Middle East Eye[b] |
| UNRWA | 2024-03-09T02:35:35Z | /* Alleged staff participation in the Hamas-led attack on Israel */Ce | Israel provided a video footage of an UNRWA employee removing the dead body of an Israeli man who had been shot on the Be'eri massacre and driving off with it. | Israel provided video footage of what it claimed was an UNRWA employee removing the dead body of an Israeli man who had been shot on the Be'eri massacre and driving off with it. |
| 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel | 2023-12-18T17:55:17Z | /* Immolation */Rendering in encyclopedic, NPOV speech | On 20 October, the remains of victims from the Hamas attack and a team of Israeli and international forensic experts' analysis of the bodies were shown to the media at Israel's National Center of Forensic Medicine. These included charred hands with marks indicating the victims' hands were bound behind their backs with metal wire before being burned alive | On 20 October, a forensic analysis was presented to the media at Israel's National Center of Forensic Medicine that claimed to show evidence of victims burned alive with bound hands. |
| 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel | 2023-12-05T18:47:15Z | /* Criticism and counterclaims */Retitling section to reflect that most of the "denials" therein have subsequently been stood up as denying evident falsehoods - mixed in with various other speculations | Denial by others | Criticism and counterclaims |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-19T20:32:43Z | /* Alleged military use */ clarifying + tagging | On 19 November the IDF released footage down the tunnel shaft and into the Hamas tunnel network The entrance tunnel is five meters in length before making a turn to the right and continuing for another 50 meters before being stopped by a blast door containing a gunhole |
On 19 November the IDF released footage down the tunnel shaft of what it claimed to be a Hamas tunnel network. The entrance tunnel was five meters in length before making a turn to the right and continuing for another 50 meters before being stopped by a blast door containing a hole that the IDF claimed was a gunhole |
| Martyrdom in Palestinian society | 2023-12-05T07:55:21Z | Attributing image to its junk source | A martyr poster, showing Ashraf Sallah Alasmar, a suicide bomber affiliated with the Palestinian Islamic Jihad | An image claimed by the IDF to be a martyr poster found in Jenin |
| Use of human shields by Hamas | 2023-11-21T16:10:09Z | /* Israeli claims */ ce | IDF press release materials suggesting that rockets were hidden under a girl's bed in Gaza | IDF press release materials that it claimed showed rockets hidden under a girl's bed in Gaza |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-17T05:42:50Z | /* top */ ce | On November 16, the body of a hostage was found near the hospital. | On November 16, the IDF claimed to have recovered the body of a hostage from a structure nearby to the hospital. |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-17T05:01:55Z | /* top */ ce | Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has stated that there were "strong indications” that hostages were in al-Shifa. | Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had claimed prior to the siege that there were "strong indications” that hostages were in al-Shifa. |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2023-11-15T12:11:02Z | /* Siege and attacks */ adding sources attesting lack of evidence for claims | The Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) claimed that Israel had targeted Al-Shifa ambulances 7 times prior and had killed 4 of their personnel. | Neither the Washington Post nor the Human Rights Watch found anything to evidence the Israeli claims. The Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) stated that Israel had targeted Al-Shifa ambulances 7 times prior and had killed 4 of their personnel. |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-15T07:08:33Z | /* 17 October Israeli Airstrikes */ further trimming | The Gaza Health Ministry attributed it to an Israeli airstrike | Palestinian claims that it was an Israeli airstrike were denied by the IDF |
| 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel | 2023-11-10T02:07:07Z | /* Incursions into Southern Israel */ clarifying unconfirmed reports + trimming single-sourced extraordinary claims | According to documents recovered from the bodies of killed militants, militants were instructed to attack civilian populations | Israeli first responders claimed to have recovered documents from the bodies of killed militants, militants with instructions to attack civilian populations |
| Use of human shields by Hamas | 2023-11-21T16:09:26Z | /* top */ clarifying media attribution | A photo released by the IDF, which it says shows a weapon in a mosque during the Gaza War (2008–2009) | IDF press release materials that it claimed showed a weapon in a mosque during the Gaza War (2008–2009) |
| Use of human shields by Hamas | 2023-11-17T08:56:02Z | /* 2023 Israel–Hamas war */ putting recent addition of dubious merit and source quality into wikivoice | On November 16th it was published that from footage filmed by IDF soldiers in Gaza, Hamas rockets can be seen hidden inside a girl's bed in Gaza, and from a conversation published by the IDF between Hamas operatives, it can be heard that they transferred an anti-tank missile inside a baby carriage | On November 16th, the IDF soldiers released footage that it claimed showed Hamas rockets hidden inside a child's bed in Gaza, as well as an audio file that it claimed was a recording of a conversation between Hamas operatives discussing the transfer an anti-tank missiles in a baby carriage |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-26T19:56:36Z | /* top */ trimming excess detail and duplication to streamline now bloated fourth paragraph | settle the issue of whether the hospital had served as a command center | settle the issue of whether the hospital had served as a command center, as previously claimed by Israel |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-19T20:38:42Z | /* 2023 war */ clarifying - claims, not wikivoice | The IDF also released footage obtained from CCTV cameras of the Hospital which show Hamas forces arriving at the hospital in captured Israeli vehicles and hostages. | The IDF also released footage that it claimed were obtained from CCTV cameras of the Hospital and which show Hamas forces arriving at the hospital in captured Israeli vehicles and hostages |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-07T07:39:36Z 2023-11-07T07:28:22Z |
Multiple | Hospital administrators and personnel have consistently denied such claims. | |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-10-28T11:00:45Z | /* top */ expanding, balancing IDF claims | The claims have been denied been Hamas, while the UK-based resident doctor Ghassan Abu-Sittah calling the assertion an "outlandish excuse" to target hospitals. | |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-10-28T10:29:09Z | /* top */ ce | In 2023 once again it was revealed by the IDF that Hamas has a command center beneath the hospital. | In 2023, it was claimed by the IDF that Hamas has a command center beneath the hospital |
| Nova music festival massacre | 2023-10-08T18:00:33Z | /* top */ replacing made-up information with that from the actual sources | The number of deaths are unknown, but assumed to run in the hundreds | The casualties numbers are unknown, but a Ynet report claimed at least one death and other Israeli media reported dozens of wounded |
| March for Israel | 2023-11-18T17:42:43Z | Rv removal of reliable sources and distortion of the reporting - the estimate of the associated press is of infinite more value than the PR numbers put out by the organizer - and rounding up the estimated numbers to what the organizers claim isn't 'simplifying'; it's editorialization | Attendance was estimated at 200,000 people to as many as 290,000 people, according to William Daroff, CoP CEO. The event organizers estimated 200,000 people in attendance |
The media reported an attendance of "tens of thousands" and up to 100,000 people, while the event organizers claimed an attendance of 200,000 people. William Daroff, CoP CEO, was also quoted as claiming that 290,000 people attended. The event organizers claimed an attendance of 200,000 people |
| Pallywood | 2023-11-10T06:02:02Z | /* Other uses */ adding material | In November 2023, Israeli diplomat Ofir Gendelman circulated a clip from a Lebanese short film, claiming that it was proof that Palestinians were faking videos, and calling it an example of "Pallywood" | |
| Al-Shifa ambulance airstrike | 2023-11-11T07:56:13Z | /* top */ ce | The Israel Defense Forces acknowledged that it carried out the airstrike, and said that Hamas militants were killed in the attack | The Israel Defense Forces acknowledged that it carried out the airstrike, and claimed that Hamas militants were killed in the attack |
| Middle East Forum | 2023-11-08T17:45:42Z | /* Campus Watch */ ce | In 2002, the Middle East Forum initiated the Campus Watch program and identified what it finds to be the five major problems in the teaching of Middle Eastern studies at American universities | In 2002, the Middle East Forum launched an initiative called Campus Watch that it claimed would identify |
| Al-Shifa ambulance airstrike | 2023-11-08T16:56:21Z | /* Background */ ce | In the week prior to the attack, the IDF had claimed that al-Shifa was "the site of a significant Hamas command and control center | |
| Anti-Palestinianism during the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-10-23T02:32:35Z | /* France */ statement is already attributed: it doesn't need to be double-couched with a "claimed" - also per MOS:CLAIM | Alain Gresh, a French journalist, has claimed that Emmanuel Macron's Renaissance party has a "very strong anti-Palestinian position". | Alain Gresh, a French journalist, has said that Emmanuel Macron's Renaissance party has a "very strong anti-Palestinian position". |
| Gaza Strip | 2023-10-09T15:27:13Z | /* History */ clarifying description + removing statement that failed verification | has led to Gaza's description as ″the world's largest open-air prison", although the claim is contested. | has led to Gaza's description as ″the world's largest open-air prison". |
| Samerina | 2023-08-15T08:46:41Z | /* History */ ce | Following the Assyrian conquest, Sargon II deported 27,280 people (according to Assyrian records) | Sargon II claimed in Assyrian records to have deported 27,280 people to various places throughout the empire |
| July 2023 Jenin incursion | 2023-07-04T04:24:14Z | /* top */ clarifying | On 3 July 2023, the Israeli military attacked a camp in the West Bank city of Jenin in what the Israeli government claims is an operation to target militants within the camp | On 3 July 2023, the Israeli military conducted a major assault on a camp in the West Bank city of Jenin in what the Israeli government stated was an operation, named "Operation Home and Garden", to target militants within the camp. |
| Israeli disengagement from the Gaza Strip | 2023-06-15T06:25:13Z | /* Greenhouses */ duplicating the most relevant factual reporting on the subject by the New York Times further up + clarifying | A widespread opinion has it that Israel left Gazans with a generous endowment consisting of a rich infrastructure of greenhouses to assist their economic regrowth, and that this was immediately destroyed by the Palestinians | When Israel left Gaza, competing claims emerged about the fate of greenhouses left behind by settlers. Some sources claimed that large numbers of greenhouses had been handed over to assist economic regrowth, but were destroyed by the Palestinians. A New York Times investigation revealed that at least half of the greenhouses had actually been destroyed by Israeli settlers before they left. |
| Jewish Agency for Israel | 2023-05-08T07:42:02Z | Tagging for self-published sources, and trimming excess self-published content in lead | Since 1948, the Jewish Agency has brought 3 million immigrants to Israel | Since 1948, the Jewish Agency claims to have brought 3 million immigrants to Israel |
Nableezy
[edit]| Article | Diff | Edit summary | Previous text | New text |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Al-Ahli Arab Hospital explosion | 2024-07-07T17:17:55Z | wp:claim | claiming that "what happened at al-Ahli remains inconclusive" | saying that "what happened at al-Ahli remains inconclusive" |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-12T19:55:21Z | /* Resumption of hostilities (1 December–present) */ ce | Haaretz reported that Israeli security officials believed that approximately 10-15% of the people shown in the video were actually affiliated with Hamas, and that despite the public claims by Israel that this was not a "massive surrender" by Hamas units. | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-12T15:11:57Z | npov | Hamas has repeatedly denied the claims of sexual abuse | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-10T17:34:12Z | de-propagandize | The New York Times reported that the claim of Hamas fighters surrendering was made after video and photographs of "men stripped to their underwear, sitting or kneeling on the ground, with some bound and blindfolded" were seen on social media | |
| Israel–Hamas war | 2023-11-28T21:31:13Z | /* 28 November */ less partisan telliong | The IDF reported that several soldiers sustained minor injuries following an attack by Hamas in the northern Gaza Strip, marking a notable breach of the ceasefire after it claimed three explosive devices were detonated near its forces at two different locations, with gunfire being directed at them in one instance, prompting them to return fire. | The IDF reported that several soldiers sustained minor injuries following an attack by Hamas in the northern Gaza Strip by three explosive devices that it said were detonated near its forces at two different locations, while Hamas said it had engaged Israel in a "field clash" that it said was instigated by Israel. |
| Gaza Strip | 2024-03-20T16:05:30Z | that isnt what they concluded | The court added in the context of current claims of occupation | The court added in the context of current occupation |
| Gaza Strip | 2023-11-28T19:36:21Z | it is not just the blockade that makes them say it is occupied, please stop repeatedly inserting this edit without discussion, restore open-air prison removed silently as well | Israel has claimed that the blockade is necessary to protect itself from Palestinian political violence | |
| Al-Sardi school attack | 2024-06-11T14:58:51Z | remove irrelevant material, well poisoning, we have a wikilink, wp:claim, what the source says is gazan government not hamas-run | The Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry claimed that at least 33 Palestinians were killed, including 3 women, 9 children and 21 men. The IDF claimed that they carried out a "precise strike on a Hamas compound" |
The Gaza Health Ministry reported that at least 33 Palestinians were killed, including 3 women, 9 children and 21 men. The IDF said that they carried out a "precise strike on a Hamas compound" |
| 2024 Nuseirat rescue operation | 2024-06-10T18:57:09Z | wikilink says what government this is a part of, wp:claim | the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry claimed on the same day that at least 274 Palestinians died in the camp | the Gaza Health Ministry reported on the same day that at least 274 Palestinians died in the camp[c] |
| Nuseirat refugee camp massacre | 2024-06-10T19:12:05Z | /* Casualties */ wp:claim | Gaza Health Ministry claims that at least 274 Palestinians were killed and 400 were wounded due to the Israeli rescue operation | Gaza Health Ministry reported that at least 274 Palestinians were killed and 400 were wounded due to the Israeli rescue operation |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-24T20:27:38Z | Attribute to israel | It is also the site of underground tunnels which have been used by the militant group Hamas | Israel has claimed that it is also the site of underground tunnels which have been used by the militant group Hamas |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-23T14:37:03Z | US intelligence isnt a reliable source to claim something is confirmed, and represent what abc actually says | US intelligence also confirmed the hospital was used as a military base | with the United States supporting the claim despite a lack of public evidence |
| Al-Shifa Hospital | 2023-11-02T02:01:35Z | rv distortion of cited sources, undue weight on single sentence from 9 years ago in lead, and unsubstantiated tag, along with material repeated in section on misuse | it has been claimed by Palestinian sources that al-Shifa Hospital was overwhelmed with wounded and dying people | hospital administrators at al-Shifa said the hospital was overwhelmed with wounded and dying people |
| Mohammed el-Kurd | 2024-02-18T01:25:27Z | /* Investigation */ | El-Kurd later claimed on social media that the police had interviewed him and then dropped the case | El-Kurd later said on social media that the police had interviewed him and then dropped the case |
| Be'eri massacre | 2024-03-19T14:06:41Z | /* Timeline */ + | though later evicdence has cast doubt on the claims of the first responder who reported this | |
| Al-Shifa Hospital siege | 2024-03-22T22:36:49Z | /* March 2024 raid */ restore mondoweiss, the last RFC was pretty clearly "option 2", but attribute | Mondoweiss said that the IDF claim that their assault targeted a 'top Hamas operative' referred to Mabhouh | |
| 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel | 2024-03-21T16:15:38Z | /* Unsubstantiated reports of beheaded children */ + | Al-Jazeera reported that the claims of babies being beheaded and were killed en masse were false. | |
| Women in the Israel–Hamas war | 2023-12-09T15:30:44Z | /* Violence against women */ +cnn saying no firsthand | CNN reported that the claims are made by witnesses and that "investigators do not have firsthand testimony, and it is not clear whether any rape victims survived." | |
| Ahed Tamimi | 2023-12-01T11:29:27Z | /* 2023 arrest */ restore much of what was removed that is about tamimi, including the illegal transfer | Her lawyer claimed that she was beaten during her arrest | her lawyer said she was beaten during her arrest |
| List of Palestinian civilian casualties in the Second Intifada | 2023-11-04T23:23:48Z | wp:claim | B'tselem claims that 2,038 were civilians | According to the Israeli human rights organization B'tselem, 2,038 were civilians |
| 31 October 2023 Jabalia refugee camp airstrike | 2023-11-01T03:14:42Z | /* Attack */ what the source actually says | Gaza's Interior Ministry (controlled by Hamas) claimed that Israel dropped six US-made bombs in the area. | The director for civil defense in Gaza said that Israel dropped six US-made bombs in the area |
| Israeli apartheid | 2023-07-21T11:51:26Z | move un bit out of lead, rephrase opening para | In April 2021, Human Rights Watch became the first major international human rights body to claim Israel had crossed the threshold | In April 2021, Human Rights Watch became the first major international human rights body to say Israel had crossed the threshold |
Notes and limitations
[edit]- This review only considers the use of "claim" when the meaning is aligned with MOS:CLAIM. Use in contexts such as claiming land, legal claims, etc are not included.
- This review does not consider uses of "claim" within the context of a direct quote
- This review does not consider edits that incidentally remove "claim". For example, when an entire paragraph is removed, which included "claim" within it.
- This review does not consider edits that were voluntarily self-reverted
- This review does not consider reverts, unless the relevant content was manually adjusted as part of the revert
- This review does not consider every edit, but instead an effectively random subset
- This review is heavily dependent on manual efforts, and some errors may have occurred. These should not be frequent enough to affect the overall analysis, but if identified please raise on the talk page and I will correct them
Cite error: There are <ref group=lower-alpha> tags or {{efn}} templates on this page, but the references will not show without a {{reflist|group=lower-alpha}} template or {{notelist}} template (see the help page).