Talk:Wilson Cleveland/Archive 1
This is an archive of past discussions about Wilson Cleveland. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
Archive 1 |
Some proposed changes
Part of an edit requested by an editor with a conflict of interest has been implemented. Please see below for additional information. |
Hi, Editors.
I wanted to propose removing the second sentence in the current opening sentence and replacing it per the below suggestion:
Current opening sentence: Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known for his roles as Derek Morrison in the web series Leap Year and the short film Kept Man.
Suggested changes with additional cited information italicized only for your reference:
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. Cleveland is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year [1], Suite 7 [2] and The Temp Life. [3] [4]
If possible, I'd also like to update the Filmography section with additional credits and small corrections reflected in the suggested changes below.
Extended content
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
References
|
- Comments: the sentence you want included in lead about what you are "currently" doing is problematic for multiple reasons. We don't include things here that have not yet been done - see WP:CRYSTAL; the source is two years old so not 'current'; and the source doesn't say anything about a web series so does not verify the content you want included. Also note that IMDb is not a reliable source here because it is WP:UGC. Thank you, Melcous (talk) 22:39, 12 May 2018 (UTC)
- talk Understood. Thanks so much. Wilsoncleveland (talk) 21:06, 13 May 2018 (UTC)
Reply quote box with inserted reviewer decisions and feedback 13-MAY-2018
Below you will see where text from your request has been quoted with individual advisory messages placed underneath, either accepting, declining or otherwise commenting upon your proposal(s). Please see the enclosed notes for additional information about each request. Also note areas where additional clarification was required. When this is ready to be provided to the reviewer, please change the edit request template to read from ans=yes to ans=no. Thank you! .spintendo⋅⋅) 07:00, 13 May 2018 (UTC)
Extended content
|
---|
|
2nd reply
Further clarification needed.
- The Film table's default settings are different from the TV and Web tables' in that the former moves chronologically from bottom to top, while the latter 2 move chronologically in the opposite direction, from top to bottom (again, in the default settings). This odd mix of chronologically ascending and descending tables is also how the tables in the standing version of the article are configured in their default view settings.
- Thank you. Clerical error. Edited in original post. Wilsoncleveland (talk) 17:49, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
- The number of Suite 7 episodes increases from the standing version to the proposed version by 5, from 3 to 8.
- As an actor, my character appears in 3 episodes of 8. I am also the series creator/executive producer of the 8-episode series. But to your point, I've included this as an acting credit, so the 3 episodes should remain. I've made that edit above as well. Wilsoncleveland (talk) 17:49, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
- The Web Adventures likewise increases in number from 1 to 5. As of 2018, is this a current continuing series? (See No. #4 below)
- The standing article credited my cameo appearance as an actor in 1 episode. However, I was a producer on this 5-episode series and I think that is a more relevant way of presenting the credit. The references I added specifically cite both my role as the series producer and the number of episodes (5). Wilsoncleveland (talk) 17:49, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
- The date column specifies series which are no longer running placed in before and after dates (e.g., 2011–2013). But this is not universally applied in the tables. For example, it appears that by showing only one date, Days of Our Lives is continuing its run (which it is). However, the column for Another World has that show also continuing its run (which it isn't). As the shows in notes 2 and 3 don't specify end dates, that would make their increase in numbers understandable, if the shows were still running. Is it the case that those shows are still running? Please advise.
- Sure. All of the dates in the date column refer to the dates I appeared on or otherwise worked on the show regardless of whether the series are still running. For example, I appeared on Days of Our Lives in 1995 but the show is still running. I appeared on Another World in 1996, but that show has ended. In the TV section, Bay State, Days of Our Lives and The Annoying Orange are still running. Does that help? Wilsoncleveland (talk) 17:49, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
3rd reply
Partially implemented.
It's usually at this point that editors start asking for the maintenance templates to be removed. If that's the direction you're going, those questions need to be put to the editor who initially assigned them.
Regards, .spintendo⋅⋅) 18:43, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
- Thank you. Were my proposed edits to the first sentence acceptable as well? Wilsoncleveland (talk) 21:20, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
Proposed changes
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
Hi, Editors.
I wanted to propose the following revision of the current intro paragraph:
Current: Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known for his roles as Derek Morrison in the web series Leap Year and the short film Kept Man. I would also like to add more content sections to the article in order to better meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for biographies so I can get that warning removed. I propose adding the headings, sub-headings, copy and citations below to the article (the Filmography section was previously approved by an editor and is fine as is). Happy to provide additional sources or clarification as needed. Looking forward to your feedback!
Proposed changes
|
---|
Proposed intro paragraph revision with citations: Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012), [1] Suite 7 (2010-2011) [2] and The Temp Life (2006-2011). [3] [4] He has also written and acted in the short films Kept Man (2014), [5] SPiN (2015) [6] and Intricate Vengeance (2016), which he produced for New Form, the digital studio co-founded by Ron Howard, Brian Grazer and Discovery, Inc. [7] [8] Career Early career Wilson Cleveland grew up in Darien, Connecticut and attended Darien High School where he acted in various school productions with classmates Chloe Sevigny and Topher Grace. [9] He attended Boston University and graduated with a Bachelor's degree in Film from Boston University College of Communication. As a Freshman, Cleveland was cast on Butv10's weekly television soap opera, Bay State, which led to small roles in Days of Our Lives and The Devil's Own. [10] The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Leap Year has won multiple awards and distinctions including several Telly Awards, a Webby Awards for Best Branded Entertainment (Scripted), [23] a Streamy Award for Best Branded Series [24], Best Branded Entertainment at the Banff World Media Festival [25] and the IAWTV Award for Best Dramatic Series. [26] USA Network acquired the Leap Year rights in 2013 [27] Other work In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV [33] [34] for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama. [35] Also in 2014, Cleveland wrote and starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man and SPiN. [36] [37] In 2015, Cleveland appeared in three episodes of The Annoying Orange and created/executive produced the documentary series Courageous Leaders. [38] [39] In 2016, Cleveland created and starred in the revenge drama Intricate Vengeance for New Form Digital. [40] References
|
Wilsoncleveland (talk) 05:23, 15 June 2018 (UTC)
Initial reply
It would be preferable if you could make edit requests one at a time so that they can be carefully reviewed and implemented if appropriate. There are a number of problems with your suggestions -just for one example: "Famous birthdays" is not a reliable source (see WP:UGC - same goes for IMDb) and the inclusion of names of famous classmates is basically name-dropping and "puffery". Cheers, Melcous (talk) 06:05, 15 June 2018 (UTC)
Draft suggestion
- All references in your proposal which were deemed to be non WP:RS (approximately half of the total number) were omitted. As a consequence, any text which was referenced by these sources was also omitted. The text which remains is what you see in the draft.
- Items placed in
strikeout fontneed to be removed and replaced with whichever suggestions are made next to it in red font. - All headings were replaced with non-level-defined substitute titles because the level-defined headings interfere with the headings already displayed in the talk page, rendering the talk page's table of contents as unwieldy.
- Please note that punctuation precedes all instances of the <ref> parameter, and that no spaces should exist between reference templates, nor should any extra spaces exist between the period at the end of one sentence and the first letter of the subsequent sentence. That area should contain only one space.
Draft Suggestion No. #1
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),[1] Suite 7 (2010-2011),[2] and The Temp Life (2006-2011). He has also written and acted in the short films Kept Man (2014),[3] SPiN (2015),[4] and Intricate Vengeance (2016), which he produced for New Form, the digital studio co-founded by Ron Howard, Brian Grazer and Discovery, Inc.[5] Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Leap Year has won Other work In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama.[14] Also in 2014, Cleveland wrote and starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man and SPiN.[15] In 2015, Cleveland appeared in three episodes of The Annoying Orange and created/executive produced the documentary series Courageous Leaders.[16] In 2016, Cleveland created and starred in the revenge drama Intricate Vengeance for New Form Digital.[5] References
|
spintendo 19:38, 15 June 2018 (UTC)
Draft revision
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
- @Spintendo: Thank you so much!
- Done: Replaced items in
strikeout fontwith suggestions that were made in red font - Added and Resubmitted text (in bold) that was deleted because of non WP:RS with new citations for your review.
- Looking forward to your next round of feedback. I really appreciate your help!
Draft Revision No. #1
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),[1] Suite 7 (2010-2011),[2] and The Temp Life (2006-2011). He has also written and acted in the short films Kept Man (2014),[3] SPiN (2015),[4] and Intricate Vengeance (2016), which he produced for New Form, the digital studio co-founded by Ron Howard, Brian Grazer and Discovery, Inc.[5] Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) In his January 14, 2011 New York Times review, critic Mike Hale wrote Suite 7 was “worth checking out,” singling out the episode ‘’Good in Bed’’ as “the best so far.”[17] Jim Edwards of CBS News called Shannen Doherty’s performance “jarringly emotional” and observed that the cast “seems to be having a ball and delivering performances of a far higher quality than they have often done on regular TV.”[18] On May 21, 2012, Cleveland and Doherty won the Webby Award for Best Individual Performance for the episode, "Company."[19] Leap Year (2011-2012) Other work In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama.[26] Also in 2014, Cleveland wrote and starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man and SPiN.[27] In 2015, Cleveland appeared in three episodes of The Annoying Orange and created/executive produced the documentary series Courageous Leaders.[28] In 2016, Cleveland creatednd starred in the revenge drama Intricate Vengeance for New Form Digital.[5] References
|
— Preceding unsigned comment added by Wilsoncleveland (talk • contribs) 05:40, 16 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to Draft revision 16-JUN-2018
Below you will see two extended content sections. The first is a reply quote box where the bolded text from your draft revision has been quoted with individual advisory messages placed underneath suggesting which added parts would be either approvable or not-approvable. Please see the enclosed notes for feedback. Following the reply quote box is the latest draft suggestion #2 which contains all approvable content up to this point.
Draft revision reply quote box
|
---|
|
Draft Suggestion No. #2
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011–2012) and The Temp Life (2006–2011). Career
Leap Year (2011-2012) Suite 7 (2010-2011)
Other work
References
|
spintendo 09:43, 16 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to Draft suggestion #2 16-JUN-2018
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
- @Spintendo: Thanks very much again. In reviewing Draft suggestion #2, we seem to have lost some approvable content from Draft suggestion #1 that was unchanged in the Draft revision.
- On verifying my education: Boston University doesn't provide open access links to Proof of Enrollment records. I have a PDF of my Proof of Enrollment document from BU's partner National Student Clearinghouse that I could host on my own URL if you think that would work. Otherwise, the Proof of Enrollment document is on my LinkedIn under Education (cited in revised draft below) and I speak about attending BU in this Indiewire interview[1]
- I've reworded the New Media Rockstars claim per Note 5 regarding Cleveland's sexuality.
- I don't have a specific source verifying my 3 guest appearances in The Annoying Orange aside from the listing on Amazon Video which is not UGC. Would that suffice?
Below is a proposed third draft combining approvable content from both drafts and all of your feedback to date.
Draft Revision No. #2
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),[2] Suite 7 (2010-2011),[3] and The Temp Life (2006-2011). He has also written and acted in the short films Kept Man (2014),[4] SPiN (2015),[5] and Intricate Vengeance (2016), which he produced for New Form, the digital studio co-founded by Ron Howard, Brian Grazer and Discovery, Inc.[6] Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Other Work
In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV[22] for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama.[23] Also in 2014, Cleveland starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man[24] and SPiN.[25]Cleveland and Sawyer shared a 2015 Webby Award for Best Drama for Kept Man[26]and won the same award again for SPiN in 2016[27]. Between November 2015 and March 2016, Cleveland appeared in three episodes of The Annoying Orange.
In 2010, Cleveland was a co-creator and producer on The Webventures of Justin and Alden, a five-episode web series sponsored by Trident [28]and produced in association with the 2010 Streamy Awards. In 2015, he created/executive produced the documentary series Courageous Leaders.[29] In 2016, Cleveland created and starred in the revenge drama Intricate Vengeance for New Form Digital.[6] References
|
Wilsoncleveland (talk) 01:25, 17 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to Draft revision #2 16-JUN-2018
Thank you for your suggested revisions. My inserted feedback is given in draft suggestion No. #3, shown below.
Draft Suggestion No. #3
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),[1]
In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV[21] for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama.[22] Also in 2014, Cleveland starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man[23] and SPiN.[24] Cleveland and Sawyer shared a 2015 Webby Award for Best Drama for Kept Man[25]
References
|
spintendo 10:33, 17 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to Draft suggestion #3 17-JUN-2018
- @Spintendo: Thank you. May I ask why Advertising Age, GigaOm and Tubefilter are considered WP:RS? I'll have a new draft for you shortly. Wilsoncleveland (talk) 16:06, 17 June 2018 (UTC)
- Thank you for your question. With respect to Tubefilter, this is considered a trade publication, a source with little journalistic background[1] that naturally merits increased scrutiny due to its ties to the industry it reports upon. Exceptions to this increased scrutiny are made for publications with longer histories of reliability in their particular industry, in this case, those in the entertainment industry such as Variety and Hollywood Reporter. With those publications, the amount of time they have existed is taken into consideration because that increased time has allowed for greater examples of unchallenged reporting. An exception to this exception would be Adage, a trade publication that despite its relatively long life[2] continues to merit scrutiny of individual authors to ensure fact checking, a process which — owing to changes in the publication's format priorities[3] — can differ depending on the story and the story's author.[4] GigaOM's financial difficulties,[5] including its issues over branding and its purchase by Knowingly 3 years ago, have all rendered that publication and its reporters as ones that merit extra caution with regards to the information they report upon. (See WP:RSVETTING.) spintendo 18:27, 17 June 2018 (UTC)
- @Spintendo: Thank you. May I ask why Advertising Age, GigaOm and Tubefilter are considered WP:RS? I'll have a new draft for you shortly. Wilsoncleveland (talk) 16:06, 17 June 2018 (UTC)
References
- ^ Wakabayashi, Daisuke (30 December 2017). "Inside the Hollywood Home of Social Media's Stars". The New York Times.
- ^ Elliott, Stuart (6 January 2014). "Advertising Age to Reduce Its Print Frequency". The New York Times.
- ^ Elliott, Stuart (26 August 2012). "Advertising Age Redesigns Print Magazine, to Push Deeper Content". The New York Times.
- ^ Carr, David (12 August 2012). "Wondering How Far Magazines Must Fall". The New York Times.
- ^ Somaiya, Ravi (9 March 2015). "Tech Blog GigaOm Abruptly Shuts Down". The New York Times.
Draft revision #3 17-JUN-2018
- Wilson Cleveland is the producer of The Webventures of Justin & Alden
- The Webventures of Justin & Alden was produced in partnership with the 2010 Streamy Awards
This article was written in 2010 five years before the company's investors sold the company-due to cash flow concerns.[2] The piece was written by Liz Shannon Miller, the current TV editor at IndieWire[3] and former Web editor at Variety[4]. Any chance you'd reconsider allowing it to be used as references? If not, Draft revision #3 below reflects all of your feedback from Draft suggestion #3. Hopefully we're close to a final. Thanks for your help!
References
- ^ Miller, Liz Shannon (June 1, 2010). "How The Webventures of Justin & Alden Survived the Streamy Awards". GigaOm. Retrieved May 27, 2018 – via Knowingly, Inc.
- ^ Kafka, Peter (March 15, 2015). "Long Story Behind Gigaom's Sudden Demise". Recode. Vox Media. Retrieved June 17, 2018.
- ^ "Liz Shannon Miller - TV Editor". IndieWire. Retrieved June 17, 2018.
- ^ "Author Liz Shannon Miller". Variety. Retrieved June 17, 2018.
Draft Revision No. #3
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),[1] Suite 7 (2010-2011)[2] and The Temp Life (2006-2011).[3] Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Other Work References
|
— Preceding unsigned comment added by Wilsoncleveland (talk • contribs) 00:06, 18 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to draft suggestion #4 18-JUN-2018
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
- @Spintendo: Thank you!
- Including the 2 Liz Shannon Miller articles allowed me to add back the Suite 7 section (reference #5) and mention of Webventures of Justin and Alden in the Other Work: Producer section (reference #20) in Draft Revision #4 below.
- I found a Digiday piece verifying Cleveland as creator of Suite 7 (reference #4). If Digiday is problematic from a WP:RS standpoint, the article was written by Mike Shields, current Advertising Editor at Business Insider [1] and former Senior Editor at The Wall Street Journal[2]
- Regarding reference #6 identifying Cleveland as the writer of the Suite 7 episode, "Captive Audience" - I know YouTube videos are not typically WP:RS but I wasn't certain if that applied to videos uploaded by verified YouTube channels belonging to broadcast television networks.
- I found an Adweek piece identifying Cleveland as the founder of Unboxd Media (reference #21), which allowed me to add back the Wall Street Journal piece identifying Unboxd as a producer of Courageous Leaders (reference #22). There is a Tubefilter article identifying Cleveland as executive producer of Courageous Leaders but as you've stated, Tubefilter isn't WP:RS
Are we getting closer to a final? Thanks so much again for your help and guidance!
Draft Revision No. #4
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star of Leap Year (2011-2012), Suite 7 (2010–2011) and The Temp Life (2006–2011). Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Other Work In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV[15] for which he received a Streamy Award nomination for Best Actor in a Drama.[16] Also in 2014, Cleveland starred opposite Hartley Sawyer in the short films Kept Man and Spin.[17] Cleveland and Sawyer shared a 2015 Webby Award for Best Drama for Kept Man and[18] SPiN was named Best Drama by the Webbys the following year.[19] Also in 2016, he created and starred in Intricate Vengeance[20] Producer References
|
Wilsoncleveland (talk) 23:59, 18 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to draft revision #3 18-JUN-2018
Draft suggestion No. #4. Remind me where those references were to be placed again, the Liz Miller ref and the other 3? Please advise.
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
- @Spintendo: Included in Draft revision #4 added yesterday. Thank you! Wilsoncleveland (talk) 20:22, 19 June 2018 (UTC)
Draft Suggestion No. #4
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and star(Specify separately) of the web television series Leap Year (2011-2012),
Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012)
References
|
spintendo 11:18, 18 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to draft revision No. #4 19-JUN-2018
Draft suggestion is below, on the right. Below on the left, you can see the delay in deciphering the different labels used by just three of the sources. The terms directed by, executive produced by, and written by are all terms that imply different roles. The term created by on the other hand is unique in that its usage is malleable, used at different times for one or all of the other three terms. In searching the references provided for Suite 7, its variegated use delayed verification:
Source reference | Suite 7 | |
---|---|---|
Creator of Suite 7 ? | Other terms used | |
Hollywood Reporter | No | co-Director co-Writer |
GigaOM | No | Actor Writer Executive producer co-Director |
Digiday | Yes | Producer Actor |
Draft Suggestion No. #5
|
---|
Wilson Cleveland (born July 4, 1974) is an American actor, producer and writer. He is known as the creator, producer and co-star of Leap Year (2011-2012), Career The Temp Life (2006-2011) Suite 7 (2010-2011) Leap Year (2011-2012) Other Work In 2014, Cleveland starred in the season five premiere of BlackBoxTV.[12] Producer References
|
In any event, I think the proposal as it stands now is better than its predecessors. If there is nothing further I will implement suggestion #5 in place of the existing text. spintendo 21:02, 19 June 2018 (UTC)
Reply to draft suggestion #5 20-JUN-2018
This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. |
- @Spintendo: You are amazing. Yes, please implement suggestion #5. Thank you! Wilsoncleveland (talk) 18:46, 20 June 2018 (UTC)
Changes implemented 20-JUN-2018
Article changes implemented. A substantive re-write of the article has finished and the discussed changes were implemented. Please note the following:
- The status of at least one of the existing maintenance templates will be discussed and possibly addressed within the next few days. Until then, the templates stand as is.
- Just a reminder, only edits to remove obvious vandalism or correct spelling/typographic errors should be made to the main article from the COI editor's account.
- Thank you!
- Regards, spintendo 22:21, 20 June 2018 (UTC)