Talk:Traveling (song)/GA1
Appearance
GA Review
[edit]GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 03:21, 2 June 2016 (UTC)
Infobox
[edit]- Looks good :)
Lead
[edit]Paragraph 2
[edit]- "both on" should be flipped to state "on both"
- Below it says it was also "certified gold"
- Add the respective years to the tours in the sentence: "It has been performed on some of Utada's tours, including Utada in Bokuhan and Utada United."
Background and release
[edit]Paragraph 1
[edit]- It's up to you, but instead of saying "her debut album First Love in 1999;", you could also say "her debut album First Love (1999);" But like I said, it's up to you
- Instead of putting the instruments in parentheses, I would reword it as such: "The song included live instrumentation by Saito Mitsutaka, who played the bass guitar, and Tsunemi Kazuhide, who played synthesizers, while it was arranged by Utada and Kawano Kei."
Paragraph 2
[edit]- Reword first sentence to "It was released as a CD single, in both Japan and China." please
- No source for the first two sentences
- Put "behind the scenes" in quotation marks like I just did :P
- Add "vinyl's" before "artwork was a screenshot taken by Kiriya.[7]" please
Composition
[edit]- Looks good to me! :)
Critical response
[edit]- The "associate professor of biological sciences and" part is highly unnecessary
- Semi-colon after "... it as the album's best track." instead of the period/full stop
- "as one of her best songs" --> "as one of Hikaru's best songs"
- Since you start mentioned accolades and awards for the song, I would add a small section title to this called "Accolades", right before the "At the 16th Japan Gold Disc Awards,..." sentence
Commercial performance
[edit]- Nothing for this section at all; great, great work!!!
Music video
[edit]Paragraph 1
[edit]- "travelling" --> "traveling"
- "include the song's title..." --> "includes the song's title..."
- "cover their face." --> "cover their faces."
- "ore-chorus" --> "pre-chorus"
- 'Intercut' is one word
Paragraph 2
[edit]- Every sentence in this paragraph begins with "the", followed by the corresponding part of the song; you can change it up, with something like "In the bridge section,...", "During the song's chorus..."
- Rest looks good
Live performances and promotion
[edit]- "It's" --> "Its"
- Rest also looks good
Track listings and formats
[edit]- Lowercase the 'v' in "vinyl" please
Chart and certifications
[edit]Weekly charts
[edit]- The section title is "Weekly charts", but includes daily, weekly, monthly, and yearly charts. I would divide them up accordingly, making sure to place "yearly" charts in a separate section like you have and did in my previous GA reviews for your articles
- Add the Billboard Adult Alternative Radio Songs chart here since you mentioned it previously
- Pluralize "Certification" to "Certifications" since there are multiple (two) certifications listed
Other notes
[edit]- Needs a "Release history" section to further support the statements previously mentioned in the article, plus most singles articles have it...
End of GA Review:
[edit]On hold for seven days; great work! Carbrera (talk) 21:56, 3 June 2016 (UTC)
- @Carbrera: Done and dusted Regarding the charts section, I had re-organized and added a DVD chart for the DVD single. You can contact me whether its good for the article, or you can ask me to remove it. Your call; cheers CaliforniaDreamsFan (talk · contribs} 03:16, 4 June 2016 (UTC)
- @CaliforniaDreamsFan: Just made one fix. "Wait & See (Risk)" is up next for review! Carbrera (talk) 03:28, 4 June 2016 (UTC)