Jump to content

Talk:Tonight (I Wish I Was Your Boy)/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: K. Peake (talk · contribs) 08:04, 22 February 2021 (UTC)[reply]


Good Article review progress box
Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV ()
3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant ()
Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

I will review this soon; hopefully your response will be as timely as usual! --K. Peake 08:04, 22 February 2021 (UTC)[reply]

Infobox and lead

[edit]
  • Infobox looks good!
  • Remove the release sentence because the song did not have a separate release from the album  Done
  • "It was written by" → "The song was written by"  Done
  • "different pieces together" → "different pieces of music together"  Done
  • There is too much info listed for the lead about what the style contains; probably cut out parts like pianos and synths but you can keep the influences  Done
  • The themes are not properly sourced in the body; they should be mentioned in the comp section as well as or instead of reception  Done
  • "The song's intro samples" → "The song samples"  Done
  • Remove release years of the songs  Done
  • "Reviewers praised the song's lyrics, its use of the Temptations sample" → "Contemporary reviewers praised the song's lyrics, its sampling of the Temptations"  Done
  • "number 14 in New Zealand," should be changed to mention the New Zealand Hot Singles Chart because otherwise it is misleading what you are referring to  Done
  • Wikilink music video  Done
  • Wikilink teddy bear  Done

Background

[edit]
  • Retitle to Background and development  Done
  • Target retro to Retro style on the quote text  Done
  • First para looks good!
  • "a piano piece that" → "a piano arrangement that" with the wikilink  Done
  • "unsure of how to" → "being unsure of how to"  Done
  • Target demo to Demo (music)  Done
  • "of his album." does this refer to the other person's album or Healy's? If the former, then keep as is and if the latter, then change to "of Notes on a Conditional Form."  Done
  • "and so they merged them" → "thus they merged them"  Done
  • Target pop to Pop music  Done
  • [11][12][1] should be put in numerical order  Done
  • "specifically their sophomore album," → "specifically the latter of the four's sophomore album"  Done
  • "the band wanted to" → "the 1975 wanted to"  Done

Composition

[edit]
  • "and funk-influenced" → "and a funk-influenced" on the audio sample text  Done
  • ""Tonight (I Wish I Was Your Boy)" is a mid-tempo" → "The song is a mid-tempo" and this should be swapped with the following sentence because genres belong first  Done
  • "Musically, it is an" → "Musically, "Tonight (I Wish I Was Your Boy)" is an"  Done
  • Wikilink upstrokes per MOS:LINK2SECT  Done
  • "deemed it a "a" → "deemed it "a"  Done
  • Target high-pitched to Pitch (music)  Done
  • "modified through a" → "that is modified through a"  Done
  • "noted was reminiscent of Kanye West." → "noted as reminiscent of West."  Done
  • "away with me"." → "away with me."" because those are full lyrics quoted  Done
  • "It then drops" → "The song then drops"  Done
  • "a rigged game"." → "a rigged game.""  Done
  • Are you sure the Genius source can be used for reprising of the sample?
  • "fucked it royally"." → "fucked it royally.""  Done

Reception

[edit]
  • "of the Temptations" → "of the Temptations'" on the img text  Done  Done
  • The section should be ordered by thematic elements as accurately as possible, so best songs of 2020 rankings should be grouped together directly after the NME and PF weekly lists  Done
  • "commending the mixture" → "with Troy Smith commending the mixture"  Done
  • Attribute the Spin review to Brenton Blanchet  Done
  • "calling it the" → "calling the track the" to avoid confusion  Done
  • "was the best non-single" → "is the best non-single"  Done
  • "are singing about."" → "are singing about"." per MOS:QUOTE  Done
  • Attribute the highlighting from Insider to Callie Ahlgrim  Done
  • "a standout from the album," → "a standout from Notes on a Conditional Form,"  Done
  • "included it on" → "included the song on"  Done
  • Target hook to Hook (music)  Done
  • "in album's central run, saying:" → "in the album's central run, saying that"  Done
  • "never sounded better."" → "never sounded better"."  Done
  • "lauded the lyrics" → "lauded the line"  Done
  • "for its simplicity and" → "for the simplicity and"  Done
  • "was clean, gentle and" → "is clean, gentle and"  Done
  • "number 14 in New Zealand" → "number 14 on the New Zealand Hot Singles chart" per earlier comment  Done

Music video

[edit]
  • Soon, but you can go over my initial concerns in the meantime
  • Remove comma after art exhibition, but this part is unsourced  Done
  • "The video begins with" → "It begins with"  Done
  • The source mentions the teddy bear being depressed but not the video beginning in the bedroom, unless translate isn't working properly for me
  • "to be longing, anxiety and" → "as being lost between anxiety and"  Done
  • Target 2D animations to Traditional animation  Done
  • The quote about "situating the voice in the song that seemed to be stuck in a moment, thinking of another time and even another timeline" can be added, but maybe paraphrase to avoid potential copyvio issues  Done
  • "said: "[the] teddy bear who, like" → "said that the teddy bear "like" because who is redundant here  Done
  • "of his computer."" → "of his computer"." per MOS:QUOTE  Done

Credits and personnel

[edit]
  • Maybe mention the keyboards in comp if the personnel section credits them?  Done

Charts

[edit]
  • Make the positions sortable, as there are four here  Done

References

[edit]
  • Copyvio score looks too high at 46.8%; cut down the amount of lyrics quoting definitely to fix this, plus the Uproxx issue should be fixed if you edit that bear quote
  • Make sure all of these are archived by using the tool
  • Target Complex to Complex (magazine) on ref 15 per MOS:LINK2SECT  Done
  • Target Insider to Insider (website) on ref 19 per above  Done
  • Remove or replace ref 20 per WP:RSSM  Done
  • I was considering this issue for ref 23 too, but WP:RSSM says reputable student media can be reliable sometimes and this is one of three fully independent student newspapers in the UK, plus has received numerous awards so I think it is a decent source
  • Remove target on Insider for ref 39  Done
  • Remove target on Rolling Stone Italy for ref 46  Done
[edit]
  • Good

Final comments and verdict

[edit]
  • (CA)Giacobbe This article looks very good for such a short time since my review comments; regarding the issue with archiving, I have encountered that before and it is acceptable as long as the majority of refs are archived; remember, GA standard is not as high as FA where something like this would have to be 100% completed. On the subject of the copyright level, the 42% is fine and this context and good job cutting down the lyrics! You have two more issues remaining though; remove the target on samples in the second para of the lead and remove the comma after sophomore album in the body. --K. Peake 17:25, 22 February 2021 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Tonight_(I_Wish_I_Was_Your_Boy)/GA1&oldid=1140123793"