Jump to content

Talk:The Hunting Party (album)/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Yash! (talk · contribs) 21:15, 28 May 2015 (UTC)[reply]

I will be doing this. — Yash! (Y) 21:15, 28 May 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Lead

[edit]
  • self-produced - produced
  • Unlink Rock (music) in the second mention
  • Shinoda as simply "a rock record", serves a statement by the band against contemporary mainstream and active rock bands, accused by Shinoda - try not to repeat Shinoda in one sentence.
  • based off - based on
  • There is no mention of critical reception, commercial performance, charts or accolades.
  • Lead says there were two producers and infobox says four.
  • Include year in brackets after Meteora.
  • Unlink the common link studio album
  • material being improvisationally written in the studio by the band. - material being improvisationally written by the band.
  • There should be a "other uses" template at the top of the lead.
  • Machine Shop should be mentioned in the lead.
  • Use Los Angeles instead of LA.
  • Another thing I just noticed, quotes should not be in the lead if possible per WP:QUOTE#Formatting so try to phrase them
    • I'm not sure how to go about fixing these.

Background

[edit]
  • electronic and experimental sound - they did release two studio albums with electronic sound so I believe it was no more experimental. It is just a suggestion and I wouldn't mind if you differ.
    • Since "experimental" is sourced, I think it would be best to keep that term in there.
  • link Living Things Tour
  • You need to include year in brackets after every time you mention the album.
    • Every time? I can understand the first time you mention a particularly, but every other time seems unnecessary.
  • Unlink the common link Demo (music)
  • were still commercially - were commercially
  • Right now we talk too much about the previous two albums that it goes off topic. Trim the last part of the first paragraph
  • produced and recorded demos - recorded and produced
  • continued the sound of A Thousand Suns and Living Things, for the band's sixth studio album during - continued the sound of A Thousand Suns and Living Things during... - Add the years as well
  • which received a positive reception - which received positive reception
  • although - though
  • The big quote in the last part of the first paragraph is in German. Is the current part translated? If yes, you will need to include the original German quote (and trim the German and English quotes down) or find the English version of it.
    • The video in the source is in English, and contains that quote.
  • remove "itself"
  • composed and recorded the album in vein of the album - text could be clearer
  • Try not to repeat "composed and recorded"
  • Same goes for "in context"
  • inspired by artists members of the band listened to before the band started their musical career. - Make it clearer
  • remove "music magazine"
  • Period should be inside the quotes in the last quote.

Composition

[edit]
  • Period should be inside the quote if the person who quotes the quote ends the sentence. Check that throughout please
  • rock record "It's - rock record; "it's
  • stated - described
  • 90s - 1990s
  • Unlink the common link Guitar solo
  • Reference for the media file?
  • The sample is of 168 kbps. That is too much. It should be 128 at most,.
  • The sample is of 30s. It should not be more than 10% of the original song.
    • I honestly have no idea how to work samples. Someone else uploaded it. Would it be better if I just removed it altogether?
  • many more guitar solos? Compared to what? And remove "many"

Recording

[edit]
  • Unlink chiropractor
  • Any more formal way of saying "marathon-recording"?
  • Check for the period issue
  • interview with Kerrang!: - interview with Kerrang! that
  • The mention of golden age hip hop, American rock, American alternative rock is not really needed

Packaging

[edit]

Artwork

[edit]
  • Unlink album cover
  • Unlink single
  • remove Taiwanese American
  • Unlink visual artist
  • Unlink t-shirt
  • art book by Jen himself. - art book by him.
  • Period issue possibly

Title

[edit]
  • Unlink rock bands
  • interview with Kerrang!. He explained: "We - interview with Kerrang! explaining: "We
  • "Period."

Promotion

[edit]
  • remove "American rapper"
  • Unlink lead single
  • Unlink music video
  • was also produced and premiered - premiered
  • Unlink video game
  • the seventh track on the album, - no need to mention that
  • June 11. - June 11, 2014
  • released early on the iTunes Store on June 1, 2014,[34] and was later released as a single on June 2 - released on the iTunes Store on June 1, 2014,[34] and later as a single on June 2
  • BBC radio 1 show to - BBC radio 1 to
  • the same day on June 3, 2014. - the same day.
  • Are there specific details about the place where the listening sessions were held in LA on May 23?
    • Not as far as I can tell.
  • What is Linkin Park Underground?
    • Basically, it's Linkin Park community, whose members sometimes gets to meet members of the band.
  • remove "American alternative rock band"
  • I believe the last paragraph needs some updating. And merge it with the paragraph above it.
    • The tour is apparently still going on.
Yeah, probably not so much, me thinks it be over. Also, why did someone find it necessary to include a picture of THIRTY SECONDS TO MARS on a page dealing with LINKIN PARK? if you want to see what 30S2M looks like, use the links embedded in the text. Cheers! FiggazWithAttitude (talk) 15:04, 29 March 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Reception

[edit]

Critical reception

[edit]
  • remove "UK national newspaper"
  • remove "Auckland-based newspaper"
  • "."

Commercial performance

[edit]
  • 29,000 copies in the United States. - 29,000 copies.
  • US - United States - for consistency

Accolades

[edit]
  • where it lost to "Three Days Grace"'s Painkiller. - Italics and "" are wrongly used.

I will go through References tonight. It looks good to go. BTW, on a side note, I loved their electronic work ("Iridescent" and "Waiting For The End" are my favourites by them). I am not really a metal fan but I enjoyed "In The End", "Numb" and few others. Didn't really like this album, what about you? — Yash! (Y) 10:02, 1 June 2015 (UTC)[reply]

  • I've always been a fan of their first two albums (Hybrid Theory and Meteora). This one is my favorite album by them since Meteora. I also like some songs from their other three albums though. In fact, "Lost in the Echo" from Living Things is one of my favorite songs by the band overall. Also, everything from above should be fixed now. I'll get to the references later. Kokoro20 (talk) 18:51, 2 June 2015 (UTC)[reply]

References

[edit]
  • Dead links [1]
    • I actually looked through all the sources before nominating this, and I have noticed that. The problem is, I couldn't get any archives for those pages through Internet Archive.
  • #20 needs more parameters
  • #27 not MTV.com, use MTV and the publisher is Viacom
  • #40 same as above
  • #49 use linkinpark.com
  • #60 TDT should be in italics
  • #62 Billboard in italics
  • #63 same as above
  • #71 needs more parameters
  • #75 same as above
  • #82 needs work
  • #84 same as above
  • #100 same as above
  • #103 same as above
  • #104 same as above
  • #105 same as above
  • #113 needs accessdate
    • Accessdate won't work on that, for some reason.
  • #114 any specific title? Link? If not, best to remove the doubful claim
  • #135 needs more parameters
  • #143 same as above
  • #144 Loudwire is not italicised while previously it was.

I will deal with the audio tonight. — Yash! (Y) 13:38, 8 June 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Nice work guys! Pleased to see it made GA. DannyMusicEditor (talk) 01:40, 13 June 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:The_Hunting_Party_(album)/GA1&oldid=890026741"