Talk:Routine Of Nepal Banda

Concern regarding advertising and COI

I would like to bring to your attention some concerns regarding the recent edits made by you in this article. Before your edits, I noticed that the article appearead to be written in a promotional tone. So I had therefore placed a Conflict of Interest (COI) tag on the article. After you removed the parentheses from "RONB," I found that the article had been deleted twice previously following deletion discussions in 2020 and 2022. It is also worth noting that the editor who originally created the article has been blocked by Wikipedia for writing paid articles.

Upon reviewing the discussions from the previous deletion occasions, it is clear that while the subject may be popular, the article was written by someone closely connected to the topic without declaring their COI, which is in violation of Wikipedia's policies. The current version of the article does not appear to differ significantly from the previous promotional versions. In particular, the references cited are not from reliable sources, and there are discrepancies between the data provided and the information in the article.

Moreover, I suspect that the article was reviewed and approved within 24 hours of its publication, which raises concerns about the thoroughness of the review process for such topics. Additionally, the recent edits made by an IP address (adding core team members without citing references) suggest that the article is being vandalized, further reinforcing the presence of a COI.

Given these issues, I strongly recommend a thorough review of the article in light of Wikipedia's policies on neutrality and reliable sourcing. Rahmatula786 (talk) 03:18, 22 October 2024 (UTC)[reply]