Talk:Private library
 | This article is rated Stub-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
| |||||||||||
Removal of cleanup mark
[edit]What else should be done to this article before the Cleanup mark can be removed? It seems to meet most MoS suggestions. Grika Ⓣ 16:31, 4 October 2005 (UTC)
A lot more. You are right in doing an article on private libraries. They are certainly very important and they merit pages and pages of description, with links to the articles that deal with books and book collecting, and also mansions. For several centuries there were very few public libraries or none at all and the transmission of knowledge depedned a lot on private libraires. This is still true in many countries. However, at several places in this article you are confusing true private libraries, which are in the homes of individuals, and "special librairies", which are small, specialised libraries in the offices of lawyers, big companies, and all kinds of organisations. This term, "special libraires" is the correct term, in most of the english speaking world for this type of library. The older term "documentation center" is used also sometimes. There is already an article on the Special Libraries Association with a link to the web pages of the association, but there is not yet an article on "special libraries" Go take a look at the web site of the special libraries association to have a better idea of the importance of that particular term and the difference with a private library. --AlainV 04:03, 5 October 2005 (UTC)
Lists of private libraries
[edit]I'm raising the generic topic of creating a page for List of Private Libraries. In an age when so many people are merely adding an ebook to their kindle library, it is worth noting that there are bibliophiles out there who have interesting private collections of several thousand volumes (e.g., George Lucas). However, these private libraries are not individually sufficiently noteworthy for their own pages (or they are not well documented). The current short list of Famous private libraries on this page is for historic exemplars rather than for a list of contemporary private libraries, which should probably be noted along with their size and perhaps topical area, if any. If no one comments back I will cross-post to an appropriate page on Wikiproject:Libraries. But creating such a list page is perhaps not really of much concern from library science perspective. Zatsugaku (talk) 16:33, 14 August 2020 (UTC)