Talk:Pietro Delfino

Dividing concepts

"redlink to San Michele di Murano, for consistency" - your edit summary at Pietro Delfino. I thought I'd air this issue with you, since I disapprove of splitting concepts without a good reason. If "[[monastery of X]]" is divided as "[[monastery]] of [[X]]", that may seem OK, but would you really divide "[[X Abbey]]" as "[[X]] [[Abbey]]"? On the whole, dividing within redlinks should be a sign that there is no need of an article, I think. Charles Matthews (talk) 08:19, 10 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]

The consistency I had in mind was with two other redlinks to the same monastery, viz. in our articles on Giacinto Placido Zurla and Nicola Giacomo Mittarelli. I agree that an article is justified, and no, I wouldn't divide "[[X Abbey]]" as "[[X]] [[Abbey]], but San Michele di Murano could only be the monastery: the place where the monastery was is Murano. I'm not sure that Monastery of San Michele at Murano is the most likely title of an article on this, but perhaps it's a bit academic, until someone starts one, and there isn't even one on the Italian Wikipedia yet. Regards, Xn4 (talk) 15:01, 10 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Not Blessed

I have removed the reference to Paul Giustiniani as being Blessed. He has not been beatified by the Catholic Church, but is merely called that by his Order. The link to Blessed implies that he has been beatified. Caeruleancentaur (talk) 19:18, 23 July 2012 (UTC)[reply]