Talk:Middlegame

Move to "Alchemical Journeys"

I believe that adding information about "Seasonal Fears" and redirecting to "Alchemical Journeys" would be a good change. This will allow all information about the series to be found in one article. I don't think "Seasonal Fears" is notable enough to have its own separate article, but it has received significant coverage.

My initial move was reverted, but I am in the middle of working on several edits and then I will plan to continue to move. (I was actually in the middle of adding information about "Seasonal Fears" and "The Up-and-Under" to the "Reception" section when the move was reverted). If any editors have thoughts about this or oppose the page move, please feel free to comment below.Michelangelo1992 (talk) 18:57, 26 August 2022 (UTC)[reply]

If "Seasonal Fears" has received significant coverage, then by definition it is notable.

I'm finding only one review in a reliable source. That's not enough to justify more than mentioning that "Seasonal Fears" exists (well, and its publication date and what its general relation is to "Middlegame").

This is not an article about the series. This is an article about the individual book. There are not sources about the series.

There's definitely enough coverage to justify a separate article on "Over the Woodward Wall", and once I finish reading it I'll write one unless someone else does it first. DS (talk) 00:46, 27 August 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Thank you for that POV. Upon further searching I agree. Although I really expected there to be more sources for Seasonal Fears, I just don't see many good ones right now besides the Publishers Weekly review that I already found. I'll table that thought for now and only re-examine it if Seasonal Fears wins awards, gets more coverage, etc. Thanks! Michelangelo1992 (talk) 23:28, 28 August 2022 (UTC)[reply]