Jump to content

Talk:Maria Gabriella Sagheddu

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Questionable Wording and Bias in this Article

[edit]

This article doesn't really abide by a neutral point of view. The points in it are often based on reason or opinion, which would be acceptable if they were taken as direct quotes or in reference to some scholarly work. However, this article does not do that. For instance, this section from the opening paragraph: "Her childhood saw her noted as stubborn and obstinate though her increased activeness in teaching catechism and joining Azione Cattolica saw those qualities melt and become gentleness and careful attentiveness." This sentence reads like it is taken from a religious pamphlet praising her life, not an encyclopedia. This isn't some kind of overtly negative or harmful bias, but the information is not conveyed in the neutral point of view to be expected in Wikipedia articles. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Rynoxeros (talkcontribs) 21:27, 5 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

Image removed

[edit]

I removed the image of the "First class relic." Maria Gabriella is considered a "Blessed" in the Catholic Church. I could not find a source for this relic. First class relics are only issued after the subject is declared a saint. I have seen this sort of thing populating several pages among the Blesseds and Saints and at the same time found they were also for sale on eBay. Seems as though these sellers are using Wikipedia to give credibility to their claims. Since there is absolutely no source so I removed it. Bodding (talk) 19:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Page does not come up when searching "Saint Gabriella"

[edit]

Given that she is a saint, and in the context of Catholicism she is referred to as Saint Gabriella, rather than by her full name, it makes sense to have this page come up for the search term "Saint Gabriella".

I just tried to find the page using that term and since nothing relevant came up, I assumed there was no page on her.

Saint Gabriel came up above anything else. But no Saint Gabriella at all. VoidHalo (talk) 20:35, 15 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]