Talk:Lucid (Aṣa album)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Kyle Peake (talk · contribs) 18:03, 30 May 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Good Article review progress box

Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV ()

3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant ()

Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

Will review this soon --Kyle Peake (talk) 18:03, 30 May 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Infobox and lead

Use bullet points instead of hlist in the infobox Done
Sure you can't find a source for recording date? ✗ Not done I'm not sure exactly what you mean. The release date is sourced in the release history section.
Target neo-soul to Neo soul Done
Lead could do with expanding; maybe mention the title info in it and definitely for the tour info. Done Expanded it.
Also, split it into two paras, though my suggestions may change/new ones could be introduced after you have done this. Done
Remove wikilink on studio album Done
Labels are in the wrong order; do same order as in the infobox. Done
"Musically, Lucid is a" → "Musically, the album is a" Done
"The album is a departure from" → "It is a departure from" Done
"in that it is more personal" → "due to being more personal" Done
Target political to Music and politics Done
"It was primarily produced by" → "The production was primarily handled by" Done
I think after this sentence, you should start para 2? Done
Target ballads to Sentimental ballad Done
"The album explores topics such" → "The lyrics explore topics such" Done
Mention at the end of the singles sentence that they were in 2019 Done
"It received positive reviews" → "The album received generally positive reviews" Done
Target music critics to Music journalism Done
"and considers it to be her" → "and considered it to be her" Done
"most emotionally robust record to date" → "most emotionally robust record" as "to date" is not needed, especially when she may later release more Done Removed "to date".

Background and promotion

"Aṣa took a 5-year hiatus" → "Aṣa took a hiatus of five years" per MOS:NUM Done
"music prior to unveiling plans to" → "music, prior to unveiling plans for releasing" Done
"She told France 24 she spent" → "To France 24, she recalled having spent" Done
"she announced the album's title" → "Aṣa announced the album's title" Done
"she said the album's title depicts the place" → "she said the title Lucid depicts the place" Done
"She also said some of the album's songs" → "Aṣa also said some of the songs" Done
"her flat in Paris while others" → "her flat in Paris, while others" with the appropriate wikilink shown here Done
"she said she wrote the album" → "she stated to have wrote the album" Done
"plans for the album's release" → "plans for the release of Lucid" Done
"to her critically acclaimed" → "to Aṣa's critically acclaimed" Done
"Musically, it is a" → "Musically, the former is a" Done
Are you sure the above sentence shouldn't be in the Composition section instead? Done Removed to the music and lyrics section.
[1][4][2] put in numerical order ✗ Not done Don't know how to do this.
"previous albums in that it is" → "previous ones, in that it is" Done
Target political to Music and politics Done
This sentence is fine here despite discussing subject matter, since it is about the Background of the album Done
The following three sentences; shouldn't they be in the Composition section instead? Done Removed to the music and lyrics section.
"drummer Marlon B and contains" → "drummer Marlon B, and contains" Done
Target neo-soul to Neo soul Done
[4][2] put in numerical order ✗ Not done Don't know how to do this.
Target ballads to Sentimental ballad Done
"in support of the album" → "in support of Lucid" and mention the tour year in this sentence Done added the month and year the tour commenced at the beginning of the sentence
"in major cities in" → "in major cities of" Done
Target Eko Convention Centre to Eko Hotels and Suites Done

Composition

Retitle to Music and lyrics Done
"The album's opener "Murder in the USA", a" → "The opener of Lucid, "Murder in the USA", a" Done
"it makes references to police" → "it makes references to police" Done I don't see a difference
"which narrates the story" → "that narrates the story" Done
"said her mother's abusive relationship with her father" → "said the abusive relationship between her mother and father" Done
"who offered an advice to" → "who offered advice to" Done
Target Afropunk.com to Afro-punk Done
Target vocal tone to Tone (linguistics) Done
Wikilink pop-soul to itself Done
"she cites arguments and" → "Aṣa cites arguments and" Done
"is reminiscent of songs produced" → "is reminiscent of tracks produced" Done
"about her desire to rip her" → "about a desire to rip her" Done
"puts her through a heart break" → "puts her through a heartbreak" Done
[6][2] put in numerical order ✗ Not done Not sure what you want me to do here; I cannot swap both sources.
Remove wikilink on jazz Done
"her worries and documents the" → "her worries, and documents the" Done
Target uptempo to Tempo Done
Remove wikilink on sentimental ballad Done
Target Yoruba to Yoruba language Done
"draining 5-year relationship" → "draining relationship of five years" Done
"the strength she endured after the emotional turmoil she's been through" → "the strength that she endured, after having been through emotional turmoil" Done
"The closing track "My Dear" is" → "The closing track to Lucid, "My Dear", is" Done
"to "Happy People"; Aṣa sings" → "to "Happy People", with Aṣa singing" Done

Singles

"The album's lead single "The Beginning" was" → "Lucid's lead single, "The Beginning", was" Done
Mention what format the release was; do this for the other two singles as well ✗ Not done Not sure about the format you're talking about.

Versace1608 I mean digital download and streaming, as in formats for release. --Kyle Peake (talk) 08:26, 10 June 2020 (UTC)[reply]

"on Instagram prior to releasing it" → "on Instagram, prior to its release" Done
"second single "Good Thing" was" → "second single, "Good Thing", was" Done
"The accompanying music video for the song was" → "The accompanying music video was" Done
Mention that the video was released two months later Done Added it to the end of the sentence.
"who overcomes the urge to overdose" → "who overcomes the urge of overdosing" with the target fixed like this too Done
"the album's third and final single "My Dear", along" → "the third and final single, "My Dear", along" Done

Critical reception

"received positive reviews from" → "was met with generally positive reviews from" Done
Remove what was praised, specifically, as that should solely be in the lead. Done
Refs do not need to be at the end of the opening sentence because the section backs up that Done Removed refs.
"awarded the album a rating of 7.5 out of 10, commending Aṣa for documenting" → "commending the album for showing Aṣa documenting" Done
"perspectives while criticizing the record" → "perspectives, though criticized it" Done
"Chuks Nwanne of" → "Chuks Nwanne from" Done
"awarded the album four-and-a-half stars out of five, characterizing it as" → "characterized the album as" Done
"cohesiveness and said the record" → "cohesiveness, and said it" Done
Put The Lagos Review quote into your own words in bits, since the quoting is heavy on this one. Done Shortened it.
"also notes that while it" → "also notes that while the album" Done
"fails to outdo her last offering" → "failed to outdo her last offering with the album" Done
"familiar lines while failing" → "familiar lines, while failing" Done

Track listing

Add ref after "All tracks are written by Bukola Elemide." to verify this information. Done
Are you sure you can't add producer info somewhere in this section? Done I added additional info.

Personnel

Add a ref at the top of this section, that the credits are adapted from. Done

Release history

How is this various when the ref only sources a US release? Response: It was released in other regions other than the U.S. Do you want me to clutter the article with multiple iTunes links? I can do that if that's what is required.
Use the proper column for ref; see Jesus Is King for example. Done
Chapter Two Records → Chapter Two Done
Wagram Music → Wagram Done

References

Make sure all of these are archived using the tool.
Copyvio score looks good at 31.5%
Date formatting needs to be the same for all refs; use the May 2, 2020, since that is preferable for the musician's nationality.
Similarly, author layout needs to be consistent on all refs; probably cite the first name followed by last, since that's how most are currently.
Cite OkayAfrica as publisher on ref 1 instead, with the wikilink
Cite Pulse Nigeria as publisher instead on refs 6, 8 and 11
MOS:QWQ issues for ref 9's title
Cite Okayplayer as publisher on ref 10 instead, with the wikilink and fix MOS:QWQ issues in the title
Cite Afropunk.com as publisher on ref 12 instead, with target to Afro-punk
MOS:QWQ issues for ref 13's title
Cite Apple Music as publisher instead on ref 16, with the wikilink
Target Guardian to The Guardian (Nigeria) on ref 18 and fix MOS:QWQ issues in the title
Delete Medium ref 21 since that is unreliable per WP:SELFPUB and replace or remove the info sourced from that
MOS:QWQ issues for the titles of refs 23 and 24
You should merge multiple countries' Apple Music on the citation of ref 25 to verify it was a various release.

Final comments and verdict

On hold after taking this on, since it was not a fail like falsely reported but needs fixes to not ultimately be one! --Kyle Peake (talk) 16:40, 31 May 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Medium is not a reliable source, it is a blog. Should be removed. MarioSoulTruthFan (talk) 12:46, 9 June 2020 (UTC)[reply]

MarioSoulTruthFan Thanks for that reminder! --Kyle Peake (talk) 08:26, 10 June 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Versace1608 I may have to fail this soon if you haven't responded to the issues soon since it's been on hold for a while now. --Kyle Peake (talk) 16:40, 11 June 2020 (UTC)[reply]

✗ Fail will have to be given to this article unfortunately, due to it having the construction template planked on while the nominator has yet to respond to certain issues, meaning that the article comes under the immediate failure criteria. --Kyle Peake (talk) 11:06, 13 June 2020 (UTC)[reply]