Talk:List of Death Note characters/Archive 1

This is an archive of past discussions about List of Death Note characters. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page.

Archive 1

Archive 2

Archive 3

Archive 4

Asperger's?

Is it really necessary to mention L and Asperger's? The section claims it's a popular theory, but I'd never heard it before, and it only cites that one page as a source. Demota 03:24, 17 November 2006 (UTC)

The fact is, he does act alot like one with that syndrome, so I think it should stay. MoChan 01:49, 24 November 2006 (UTC)

It's not stated by the creators or anything that he has any syndromes, so it seems like a lot of theory or opinion, which is not acceptable content for Wikipedia. Nique1287 01:57, 24 November 2006 (UTC)

I agree with Nique, it is impossible to state L has Asperger's, and he does not neccesarily show the symptoms. Remember, just because you act a certain way does not mean anything is wrong with you. He probably had friends growing up, but it would be more logical to say he distanced himself from everyone because he knew his parents to some extent. (Which seems to be indicated by the anime; however, this is not a well supported theory and is not my own!) L_Lawliet 00:49 27 May 2007 (UTC)

Real Name

Apparently, L's real name is something like "Elle Lawright". Pretty lame if I do say so myself. 169.237.214.145 18:39, 10 October 2006 (UTC)

I put down L. Lawliet, But yours sounds better. Any link to a good translation? - Malomeat 11:02, 14 October 2006 (UTC)

L. Lawliet is the official name, according to How To Read 13. That is, the Special Edition thereof that includes things like, relevantly, the L True Name Card. It's got an illustration of L, with "L Lawliet" written across it. Any other romanizations are false, just like the many people that still call Light 'Raito'. It's like Homer Jay Simpson all over again, isn't it? ;) Nique1287 19:52, 17 October 2006 (UTC)

Elle is also a girls name. It is french for "she" or "her" depending on use. Given the Rem wrote L's name in her Death Note, are we forced to assume that L's first name was simple "L?" Also, Ihve a question regarding names. If the Shingami eyes reveal the name of a person, not a pseudonym, then would on person A, would it show Bill or James? (This is a assuming Person A was born as "Bill" nd later had his name altered to "James," for example.) L_Lawleit 1:54, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

Yes, L's real first name is just the letter L, because that's what the creators made it. Just because it was written in a Death Note doesn't mean it couldn't be a letter. There have been stranger names than single letters before. As for your question, we don't know, the situation hasn't come up and the creators haven't said anything like that. Presumably, your birth name would be the name that would show and that you'd have to write in a Death Note, but if it was changed legally, then it might be the new name instead. There's really no accurate answer. Nique talk 14:54, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

Articles

Shouldn't L, Light, and Misa Amane among others have their own articles? MoChan 18:04, 24 November 2006 (UTC)

I don't know. I mean, if you got enough sources to go into character analysis of Light or L, you MIGHT be able to put together a fair-sized article, but most of them would just be stubs. There's not much worth saying that can't be said on this page, really. Death Note isn't precisely a short series, but a lot of the series is more action-based or consisting of exposition, and there's not all that much character development in comparison. The only characters that really change at all are Light, in his rather quick journey from innocent high school student to crazed Kira, and Misa, who goes from innocent girl to naive Kira and back again many times. Even L doesn't change significantly, he's the same person the first time you meet him as he is the *cough* last, except that he makes a couple of "friends" along the way. The only way you'd really get long articles on any of them would be either to have too much original research or opinion, or to put too much of what belongs on the Plot page on the character pages. Just my thoughts, though. Nique1287 18:55, 24 November 2006 (UTC)

Agreed. If we did make articles for each character, we would be making all those AfD obsessed people happy =D SuperDT 07:25, 26 November 2006 (UTC)

Light and L have mental disorders?

I am taking out that stuff saying Light has antisocial personality disorder and a god complex, and L has asperger's. Light's "diagnosis" is highly unverified and possibly original research, and L's source for his Asperger's actually says he probably doesn't have it(The guy/woman who made the page is in no way qualified to properly diagnose someone for AS anyways; he/she just has AS, nothing more, nothing less!). SuperDT 07:25, 26 November 2006 (UTC)

Actually, L stated the possibilty of Kira having reached a "divine level" at the time he added surveillence to the Yagami house. (And someone else, I forget the name.) It is possible to conclude that eventually, Light would develope some form of a God Complex, especially later in the Manga when the Kira worshipers begin to call themselves worshipers. Earlier it is shown to when his only complaint with being called a "divine saviour" on a web site, is that the name "Kira" is obviously derived from "Killer." However, his distaste for the shrine to Kira on Sakura's Kira's Kingdom shows he is not drunk with power. This evidence may conclude, as I before mentioned, a mild case, at best, of a God Complex. L_Lawleit 01:43 AM, 23 March 2007(UTC)

That's fine, but your conclusion is still Original Research. Using evidence to come up with a conclusion, even if the evidence was sourced, is still Original Research, unless that conclusion comes from a reliable source. In this case, until the creators of Death Note say "L has Asperger's, and Light has a God Complex," it should not be included in this article. SuperDT 21:28, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

So I assume the fact that Light has stated on several occasions that he will be the God of his new world is not credible enough by itself? 74.73.249.5 03:28, 23 May 2007 (UTC)

Saying that someone has a god complex is very non-neutral to begin with. Aside from the fact that so many people in the story think that Kira is a God, which is already mentioned (though perhaps not on this page), and the fact that he may act in the way someone with a god complex might, it's simply not encyclopedic to say "Light has a God complex". Nique talk 03:52, 23 May 2007 (UTC)

"The person who is said to have a 'god complex' can act so arrogantly that he might as well believe he is a god or appointed to act by a god" (Dictionary). While Light firmly believes he WILL BECOME a God of the new world, he never truly calls himself a God. In fact, it is his goal to "become Kira." His line of thinking would be "Kira is God," "Part of Light Yagami is Kira," but "If Light is not wholly Kira, Light Yagami is not God," as "Kira is wholly God." It is Light's aim to be God. His steps are documented by L and the Shinigami in their perception of Kira/Light. First, Ryuk calls Light "A fine Shinigami," then L acknowledges Kira has reached a "divine level," and in her death, Rem believes Light has surpassed a Shinigami. These are the three steps taken. In the last 5 books of the series, Light's whole purpose, in strugling with Near, is to become not "a god," but "The God." While his attitude is increasingly arrogant, as he believes himself to be becoming perfection, Light never becomes God. While he may have a "Shinigami complex," so to speak, he becomes a Shinigami, so this phrasing is wrong also. God complex is too strong, but Shinigami complex is bad phrasing. It is best suited to say Light did not think he was a God, but aimed to become God. L_Lawliet 27 May 2007 01:01 (UTC)

Raito

How come ライト is transcribed as Light? Is that specific meaning mentioned somewhere in the manga or film adaption that I missed? It could just as well be Right, Wright, Write or even Lyte etc. --Himasaram 14:49, 7 December 2006 (UTC)

Viz translated it as "Light" because it is "Light"; no buts about it.--(十八|talk) 15:31, 7 December 2006 (UTC)

The creator intended it to be based on the word "Light", hence it is "Light" not your other suggestions. I think it was explained by Light himself when he meets Misa in the manga, how his name means 'light' but is written with equivalent Japanese characters. I could be mistaken on that, but it WAS the creator's intention that it be Light. Nique1287 18:04, 7 December 2006 (UTC)

As a note, the equivalent Han character is that for moon. --Himasaram 09:12, 8 December 2006 (UTC)

Also note that the character introduction pages that begin each volume spell all of the characters names in English (even the original Japanese version), and in it he is named "Light Yagami." Chibi Gohan 02:43, 1 January 2007 (UTC)

Height and Weight according to other countries?

Are most of the editors anglosaxon/American? L might seem underweight considering his height and weight from an American point of view but that may not match up with other countries. I am roughly the same weight and height as L but I'm actually taller and heavier than most of my classmates in Europe. An American might consider L short and skinny but from a European point of view he is of average height and normal weight.83.193.117.236 12:19, 2 March 2007 (UTC)

5'10" and 110 lbs (179 cm and 50 kg) is not healthy. It's very underweight for the height. The article stating that he's underweight is going by guidelines which are not based on the American average, but physical healthiness of height/weight combinations. Your height and weight being more than most of your classmates may be true, and it may be average for the height where you live, however that doesn't make it healthy, hence the article stating that L is underweight. Nique talk 14:07, 2 March 2007 (UTC)

Nevermind about the weight

My bad. I only found out now how old L was supposed to be. I assumed he was a teen from how he looked.82.125.53.47 21:04, 7 March 2007 (UTC)

Mello

Do you guys want me to add a higher quality version of Mello's picture from the second opening as well? It has the MADHOUSE company name on it though. :( RyuuTaichou 21:45, 19 March 2007 (UTC)

As long as you have permission from MADHOUSE to use the picture, then yeah go for it. SuperDT 21:30, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

Pictures from the second anime OP

Can we switch back to manga pictures of Mello, Near, and Mikami until they're actually shown clearly in the anime? The anime OP sequence's images of them aren't very clear, nor very representative of their appearance in the manga, at the very least, nor likely their final appearances in the anime. You can only see half of Near's head, and only half of Mello's face from the shadow, as well. Does anyone else agree/are there any objections? Nique talk 02:55, 30 March 2007 (UTC)

I agree! The only reason I uploaded the two was because they were really low quality kinda like Raito's and L's on the Death Note page. They just don't match with the other images. RyuuTaichou 03:10, 30 March 2007 (UTC)

L trivia

His true birth name is L Lawliet. His date of birth is Halloween of 1989, making him notably OLDER than he appeared to have been. Shouldnt that be YOUNGER ? - Nytemyre 19:30, 7 April 2007 (UTC)

It's supposed to be 1979. --Pentasyllabic 19:35, 7 April 2007 (UTC)

Anime pictures of Mello and Matsuda

Matsuda's anime picture is a tilted, unclear picture from a TV show within the anime, and isn't perfectly clear. Why it was chosen for the entry is beyond me.

As for Mello, the quality and size is too low. I suggest they are both replaced for better, clearer ones. --Delf 02:26, 23 April 2007 (UTC)

EDIT: By lack of actions taken, I have uploaded better pictures for respective characters. --Delf 12:28, 24 April 2007 (UTC)

Japanese Kana

I've added most of the Japanese kana names for most of the character names that do not have them. I feel that it is necessary to add the kana in from the Japanese interwiki site. If there is a mistake, let me know here. Sjones23 19:56, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

The kana will improve the overall article. Just a heads up. Sjones23 20:02, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

In some cases, like David Hoope, the kana really just aren't necessary. It's an entirely English name, romanized. Why should the kana be there on the English Wikipedia? Nique talk 20:04, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

The reason is that the kana is really essential to all of the characters, except some companies and characters. Sjones23 20:11, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

I should also note that I took them from the Japanese interwiki site, so I feel that it is necessary to add them to anime related articles. Sjones23 20:14, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

I was not really impressed that the kana was removed. I am entirely against the removal of kana, unfortunately. Once again, I feel that adding any of the kana is necessary. If any of my comments were offensive, I apologize. Sjones23 20:30, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

I was a little insulted by your comments (sorry). The kana is not an indiscriminate collection of information, it is necessary for all of this page, as with most of the anime articles. Once again, please accept my apologies. Sjones23 20:43, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

I haven't done anything wrong, nor did I actually destroy anything. As I said before, the kana is really essential, as with most articles. :D All the best for May Sjones23 20:53, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

~~Jaguara, SuperDT and anybody else want to throw a couple of ideas and things in? Thanks. Do not bite me, however, please. Sjones23 21:08, 2 May 2007 (UTC)~~

One more thing, I know "David Hoope" is an entirely romanized english name, but it doesn't have any kana, so the kana transliteration is necessary. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Sjones23 (talk • contribs) 21:09, 2 May 2007 (UTC).

I know how "David Hoope" supposed to sound in Japan. If any of you look at the Japanese manga, the Japanese interwiki site, or any other Japanese Death Note sources, you can actually see how his name is spelled in English and Japanese. If any of my previous comments were offensive, I apologize Sjones23 21:13, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

I agree with your comments. Once again, please accept my apologies. Thanks for the help on that. Sjones23 23:14, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

Attempts to read wall of text, formatting, and strikethroughs* Okay, were 29 consecutive edits REALLY necessary here? Next time, instead of jumping to conclusions and acting like a martyr, just chill out, read what other people have to say, and reply, once, after a minute or three of thought. It's just a good thing I don't go through these edits one at a time to see what was changed! You don't have to confirm every little thing or add a new comment every time something pops into your head. Just think, write out EVERYTHING that's on your mind in ONE comment, and post that, and leave it at that until someone else posts a reply and gives you something new to ponder and agree or disagree with. This is a little off-topic, but your edit counts are ridiculous, and the amount of content that all those edits amounts to ("I agree, sorry for the misunderstanding.") makes the sheer number look more than a little ridiculous to me. Nique talk 01:28, 3 May 2007 (UTC)

I understand now, Nique. I apologise. Thanks for your comments. They are totally appreciated. All the best. Sjones23 11:29, 3 May 2007 (UTC)

Quick Question

I saw David Hoope's name rendered in katakana as this: デヴィッドホープ (Deviddo Hōpu) from the Japanese interwiki site, but it is only romanized as this: David Hoope. I have a few questions. Does Hoope's name as well as some companies in the manga and anime exist in katakana or just simple English? Thanks. Sjones23 21:35, 2 May 2007 (UTC)

Also, should all character names be bolded or not? I've noticed most of the anime characters' names appear in bold format. Sjones23 00:53, 4 May 2007 (UTC)

Never mind. Sjones23 01:07, 4 May 2007 (UTC)

If you're still curious, his name is written as デイビットホープ (Deibitto Hōpu) in the Japanese manga.

Chibi Gohan 20:54, 9 May 2007 (UTC)

Thanks and all the best. Sjones23 19:39, 10 May 2007 (UTC)

Volume 13 and names

Is volume 13 really an accurate source for the characters' names? I've found multiple spellings (er, three to be exact!) that contradict the manga: "Shidoh" (the tankobon character introductions show the spelling of Sidoh, even in the Japanese version), "Kal Snyder" (shown to be "Kal Snydar" in the actual manga), and vice president "George Psyruth" (shown to be George Sairas when typed in Light's laptop, even in the Japanese version of the manga).

So, can volume 13 really be trusted as the ultimate source of name spellings? To me, it seems like they consulted someone who spoke English to romanize the names who hadn't really read the manga. Thoughts?

Chibi Gohan 02:39, 9 May 2007 (UTC)

How To Read was penned by the creators. It is thus the most accurate recent source for names. That's why it's been accepted by most Death Note editors as being the standard: because it's exactly as the creators intended the names to be. Nique talk 02:56, 9 May 2007 (UTC)

I doubt Tsugumi Ohba actually wrote the information in 13. And why should volume 13 take precident over the actual manga? For instance, Kal Snydar is the name Misa say with her Shinigami eyes (while looking at Jack Neylon's picture), which is shown when Light writes it down (in roman letters), yet volume 13 writes it as Kal Snyder. Why on earth would we write the misspelled name? If volume 13 had the names that are "exactly as the creators intended the names to be," then why are they written differently in the actual manga?

Chibi Gohan 04:09, 9 May 2007 (UTC)

Why do you doubt that it was written by Ohba? I'm pretty sure Ohba wrote it to clarify and explain and give more information about the universe and the goings-on within it. And it should take precedence over the manga and the translation because, again, it's as-intended, all the English names in there are as Ohba intended them to look in English. All the information in there is what Ohba intended it to be. Why is it different from the manga? Who knows. The manga lettering was probably done by somebody else, so they may have just put their own interpretation of the kana to the name without asking Ohba. And that's exactly what happened in the translation. Either way, HTR is the most recent and accurate source for the names because it's exactly what Ohba intended. That is why it's used here for the names, info, etc. except in VERY rare cases (like the debate about Misa's clothing style on Talk:Death Note a while back, where HTR said that it was gothic lolita, but she doesn't actually fit the style for it almost at all). Nique talk 13:04, 9 May 2007 (UTC)

Ohba may have actually wrote it, I think. Sjones23 20:08, 10 May 2007 (UTC)

Not likely, considering A) Most manga guide books aren't, due to the author being, you know, busy writing the manga (which leads to little mistakes like the the Fullmetal Alchemist Perfect Guide Books or the Dragon Ball Daizenshuu).

And B) How to Read has an editorial staff listed in the front, so I believe people were hired to compile the info (and since they probably weren't native English speakers, they messed up on many of the English names).

I therefore feel that the manga's spellings and info should hold greater value than volume 13, since the manga came first and had more influence from Ohba.

Chibi Gohan 18:38, 11 May 2007 (UTC)

In case you didn't know the editorial staff was Shueisha's Weekly Shonen Jump editorial staff. edit: sounded a little thoughtless and bad, no offense. Sjones23 20:12, 11 May 2007 (UTC)

Firstly, you agree with /who/, SJones? Don't reply just to say you agree when it's not a vote. Secondly, Chibi Gohan, just because it has extra staff listed doesn't mean it wasn't written by Ohba. It's still THE source, given that it was, you know, published to supplement the series. And how do you figure that the manga is ANY closer to the author than the supplement? Aside from the fact that in many cases, the supplement is used as the source for names anyway. (For example, Bleach articles use supplement books and the like, including names in CD inserts, as the source for names, information, etc.) Nique talk 01:51, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

I believe the manga had greater influence from Ohba because common sense tells me so. There are many names written in English within the series (such as Kal Snydar, whose name is seen by Sidoh and clearly displayed as k-a-l s-n-y-d-a-r). There are three spellings that I've found (so far) that contradict the manga, and it doesn't seem like Ohba (who planned out such a thought out series) to not check the manga (or Ohba's own notes or whatever) for the spellings that were used in the manga text.

But it's all a matter of opinion, and we seem to be running out of points to debate, so I think we should have a vote (although I think we should have someone scan some pages from the Japanese manga. I'd do it myself if I had a scanner).

Chibi Gohan 04:12, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

Well, I think this article needs to cite reliable sources. Do you agree? Sjones23 15:37, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

Also, both Ohba and the Shonen Jump editorial staff worked together on How To Read 13. Sjones23 15:52, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

That's what the Unreferenced tag was for, before you removed it, which is why I restored it. And please stop changing your Talk page replies after you've made them, SJones.

As for the 'vote', Chibi Gohan, a vote you shall have, though remember that Wikipedia is not a democracy, it works on consensus. I'm putting it up on the Talk: Death Note page, so that more editors will see it in their watchlists and we can get a better idea of the current sentiments on the issue. Nique talk 15:59, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

Oops! I was sounded a little flustered and did not really use good knowledge in my previous comments. I did not realize that after I removed the referenced tag, I was embarrased by this removal (I was going to restore it). Sorry about that! ^^ Nique and Chibi Gohan, thank you both for your comments and Nique, thank you also for the reminders. I appreciate them very much. And Chibi Gohan, next time, please brush up on Wikipedia's policies and guidelines, okay? Once again, thank you. I apologize for both the removal of the Unreferenced tag and the changing of talk page replies. :D All the best. Sjones23 16:11, 12 May 2007 (UTC)

"written his own name"

The link on "written his own name" doesn't actually go anywhere useful right now since somebody felt they should delete all the rules from the target page. 150.101.121.216 09:01, 19 May 2007 (UTC)

The only reason it didn't go to the section proper is because the section was changed from 'Other Rules' to 'Other rules'. It now directs to the correct section, which just gives an explanation of the other rules, including the one relevant to that link as an example. Nique talk 14:42, 19 May 2007 (UTC)

Lind L. Taylor

L technically uses this name as an alias, though he himself doesn't portray the person. --BiT 19:18, 26 May 2007 (UTC)

It's not an alias, though. L doesn't appear as or claim to be Lind. He forces Lind to claim to be him. There's a big difference there. Nique talk 06:04, 27 May 2007 (UTC)

L took advantage of that person having, coincidentially, a middle name starting with the letter L. Considering Kira had no idea who L was or how he looked, such a small detail was great to use against him, as a sort of decoy. And whaddya know? Light took the bait. --Delf 18:23, 27 May 2007 (UTC)

Unecessary pictures?

Pictures removed, due to their lack of necessity, are:

Picture of Light with a siniter smile while hugging Misa; it bears no point whatsoever to the article, which is used to describe his character and plot elements of the story.
Light, looking evil after repossessing the Death Note. It is enough to mention in the article that he regains the notebook and his memories as Kira. There is no need to depic his evil smile. For that note, there is no need to depic everytime he smiles evilly...
~~Both pictures of L's death (falling down chair, closing eyes); a picture serves the purpose of showing him dying in the respective episode page (see List of Death Note episodes)~~ while him falling down his chair is not critical enough for a place in the entry. Him dying is explained in this page.

As it would appear, the episodes page has been stripped from pictures. Ergo, I've reinserted the picture of L dying in Light's arms, as it then granted validity.

Misa talking to Rem, as a picture of her anime persona is already available, and this one bears no point.
Rem standing over Jealous' remains is also an unecessary depictation of an event already explained in the article.
Picture of Reiji Namikawa from the anime; his anime persona, as well as the entire group's, are clearly shown in the group picture.

This page covers details well enough with words; pictures put all over it when none aren't really needed is kind of a bother. --Delf 18:39, 27 May 2007 (UTC)

That's harsh --BiT 18:44, 27 May 2007 (UTC)