Jump to content

Talk:Dominika Stará

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Untitled

[edit]

Hello. Dominika Stará is a young pop singer who won third place in the Czecho-Slovak joint contest Česko Slovenská Superstar, held in 2009. The participation in the contest is the only thing she is known for and the subject totally fails WP:MUSICBIO (in my opinion), as there are no sources indicating her notability outside of the contest. The issue was discussed at Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Czech_Republic#.C4.8Cesko_Slovensk.C3.A1_Superstar and the consensus was that the article should be redirected to Česko Slovenská Superstar (btw, the same solution is used on the Czech Wikipedia). I've redirected the unreferenced and promotional article to the main contest article and nominated the images lincensed under {{PD-old}} for deletion. Now I'm starting to become involved in one of the endless revert battles with a single-purpose account MichalMajkl (talk · contribs) refusing any communication. On the other hand, WP:IDOL allows existence of stand-alone articles for the finalists of the contests. Dumb reverting is boring, please advise me: should we follow WP:MUSICBIO and WP:BLP1E or the recommendations of WP:IDOL? Thank you in advance. --Vejvančický (talk | contribs) 10:52, 5 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]