Jump to content

Rape during the Vietnam War

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Rape
Types
Effects and motivations
By country
During conflicts
Laws
Related articles
Portals
icon Law portal
Photograph taken by Ronald L. Haeberle of South Vietnamese women and children in Mỹ Lai before being killed in the massacre.[1] According to Haeberle, soldiers had attempted to rip the blouse off the woman in the back while her mother, in the front of the photo, tried to protect her.[2]

Rape, among other acts of wartime sexual violence, was frequently committed against female Vietnamese civilians during the Vietnam War. It was an aspect of the various human rights abuses perpetrated by the United States and South Korea, as well as by local Vietnamese combatants. According to American political scientist Elisabeth Jean Wood, the sexual violation of women by American military personnel was tolerated by their commanders.[3][4][5]: 65  American professor Gina Marie Weaver stated that not only were documented crimes against Vietnamese women by American soldiers ignored during the international legal discourse that occurred immediately after the conflict, but modern feminists and other anti-war rape campaigners, as well as historians, have continued to dismiss them.[6]

Some American veterans[vague] believe that sexual violence against Vietnamese women was motivated by "racism, sexism, or a combination of both" as a result of the strong social reform movements that were roiling the United States in the early 1970s.[5] According to one source,[which?] only 25 cases of rape from the United States Army and 16 cases of rape from the United States Marine Corps resulted in court-martial convictions involving Vietnamese victims between 1965 and 1973.[citation needed]

The issue of pregnancies resulting from rapes has had a significant impact on South Korea–Vietnam relations: these people, conceived through the rape of Vietnamese women by South Korean soldiers, continue to be subjected to discriminatory treatment by the Vietnamese government, while their presence in South Korea is unacknowledged by the South Korean government.[7][8][9][10][11] In Vietnam, the term "Lai Đại Hàn" ([laːi ɗâˀi hâːn]) refers to a person beget by a Vietnamese mother and a South Korean father during the Vietnam War. The extent of these relationships' sexual consent is still debated;[12][13] one Japanese study determined that over half of Lai Đại Hàn births had resulted from rape.[14]

By American personnel

[edit]

During the Vietnam War, U.S. soldiers stationed in South Vietnam engaged in various sexual interactions, including consensual sex, prostitution, and rape. Mixing consenting sexual activity and rape may also be viewed as the outcome of indifference toward a nation at war.[15]: 181  According to Gregory A. Daddis, certain U.S. Army drill instructors assured recruits that they could rape Vietnamese women, which Daddis partially attributed to "Orientalist" beliefs that portrayed Asian women as "creatures of a male power fantasy."[15]: 180  Men's adventure magazines contributed to a culture that accepted sexual aggressiveness and violence towards Vietnamese women.[15]: 176 

According to Gina Marie Weaver, the primary sources are rich in accounts of violence, including testimony provided in open hearings held during the war, court cases, military investigations, oral reports gathered for publishing both during and long after the war, and literary works, such as poems, novels, and memoirs.[5]: 6  Sexual mistreatment of the Vietnamese women during the Vietnam war has been witnessed by numerous U.S. veterans and other eyewitnesses.[5]: 47 

According to Kerry Crawford, rape of Vietnamese women was a "normal operating procedure",[16]: 13 [15]: 194  and brothels were built inside military installations to maintain morale and discipline.[16]: 13  Approximately 100 recruits who were interviewed in Cam Ranh Bay, Vietnam, had little to say about the war's greater difficulties since "the men’s personal concerns were mostly sexual."[15]: 175  Many U.S. servicemen sought local women in hopes of filling the void created by the frustrating war in Vietnam. According to Daddis, military leaders were likely aware of this, as one deployed officer noted that his in-processing briefings covered topics ranging "from the current Viet Cong infrastructure to the common venereal diseases in Vietnam."[15]: 175  A U.S. soldier in Vietnam reportedly said:[17][18]

They are in all-male environment...There are women available. Those women are of another culture, another colour, another society...You've got an M-16. What do you need to pay a lady for? You go down to the village and you take what you want.

During the Winter Soldier Investigation, sponsored by Vietnam Veterans Against the War (VVAW), some of the testimonies of Vietnam veterans included the rape and murder of Vietnamese women,[19] with some being tortured and sexually mutilated.[17] According to Mark Baker, who interviewed Vietnam veterans for his book, one became a "double veteran" by "having sex with a woman and then killing her."[17][18][20] One marine recalled an incident where a Vietnamese girl was gang-raped by members of his unit, with the final perpetrator shooting the victim in the head. In a similar incident, a soldier observed that the female victim "freely submitted" to rape to avoid death.[15]: 181  At a hospital in Da Nang, a nurse was killed after being raped by seven marines.[21]

In his controversial study The Perfect War: The War We Couldn't Lose and How We did, James William Gibson contends that raping women was a means by which some soldiers could demonstrate their power over Vietnamese women. According to Gibson, U.S. soldiers would rape Vietnamese girls, then kill them in horrific ways, including allegedly making their "stomachs explode" by sticking "hand flares" inside their vaginas.[22]: 183 

Prosecutions and notable cases

[edit]

According to one source, only 25 cases of rape committed by army soldiers and 16 by marines resulted in court-martial convictions involving Vietnamese victims from 1965 to 1973. Daddis argues that the low number of complaints and convictions reported by the UCMJ, the only service that keeps track of its war crimes cases, demonstrates the faults in the UCMJ system.[15]: 195 

The incident on Hill 192 refers to the kidnapping, gang rape, and murder of Phan Thi Mao, a young Vietnamese woman[23]: 1  by an American squad during the Vietnam War[23]: 1  on 19 November 1966.[23]: 2  The woman was raped by the soldiers, after which she was stabbed and shot in the head.[24] All soldiers involved faced court sentences and were also dishonorably discharged from the Army.[23]: 3  The Mỹ Lai massacre is another infamous incident where[25] almost 20 Vietnamese women and girls, some as young as 13, were raped by the U.S. troops.[15]: 202 

In August 1967, a 13-year-old Vietnamese girl was raped by an American MI interrogator of the 196th Infantry Brigade[26] while interrogating her as a suspected VC member. A general court martial tried the soldier, and he was given a dishonorable discharge and 20 years in prison with hard labor. However, his sentence was reduced to one year upon appeal. In total, he was incarcerated for only seven months and 16 days.[15]: 196 

According to Daddis, the UCMJ system discriminated against Vietnamese rights in favor of American rights. The court system did not protect local women or listen to their stories. For example, military officials detained a 20-year-old Vietnamese woman who later alleged that 10 American soldiers raped her while she was jailed. The woman could only identify two of her rapists when questioned by investigators. Later, she stated that "she was not sure," and the case was swiftly dismissed due to a lack of sufficient evidence to support her assertions.[15]: 195 

By South Korean personnel

[edit]

Approximately 320,000 South Korean soldiers served while fighting in the Vietnam War, with each typically serving a one-year tour of duty.[27] Maximum troop levels peaked at 50,000 in 1968, with all being withdrawn by 1973.[28] Rapes of Vietnamese women by South Korean military personnel occurred throughout the conflict, some of which resulted in forced pregnancies. According to Kim Nak-yeong, who was a staff sergeant at Bình Khê in Bình Định Province, South Vietnam, from May 1971 to June 1972, "Some of the units didn't cause any problems because they were strictly instructed not to harm civilians. However, I heard a lot of talk about brutal sexual assaults taking place throughout the operation zones, and my understanding is that there's a definite possibility it was true." The same article from The Hankyoreh in April 2015 also reported quotes from the interviews of ten elderly Vietnamese women who said they were victims of sexual assaults perpetrated by the South Korean military during the Vietnam War in Bình Định Province. One stated, "Four people took turns doing it to me one at a time." Another was quoted as saying, "They'd put one person at a time in the trench, keep me there all day and night and just rape me again and again".[28]

In October 2016, it was reported that the head of the Vietnam Veterans' Association of Korea was representing 831 plaintiffs in a defamation lawsuit against Ku Su-jeong [vi] for her 2014 interview in the Japanese newspaper Shūkan Bunshun and 2016 interview in The Hankyoreh, as well as her statements in a video.[further explanation needed] They said that Ku's statements of about the actions of the South Korean military during the Vietnam War were all "falsehoods and forgeries", that the victims were just "Viet Cong disguised as civilians", and that "no sexual violence occurred".[29]

Lai Đại Hàn

[edit]
Main article: Lai Đại Hàn

In Vietnamese, "Lai Dai Han" is a derogatory epithet that means "mixed blood." The Vietnamese-Korean children contend their lives have been wrecked by shame in a culture that has not recognized them or their mothers' sexual abuse. Many are illiterate as a result of being denied an education, and they have limited access to healthcare and social services.[30] The exact number of Lai Dai Han is unknown. According to Busan Ilbo, there are at least 5,000 and as many as 30,000.[31] According to Maeil Business, however, there are 1,000 at least.[32] A 1998 paper which was cited in a 2015 paper said that the South Korean government put the number of Lai Dai Han at 1,500.[33] The Lai Dai Han community continues to face social exclusion due to their mixed ethnicity.[7][8] It has been reported that many cannot read or write, with most not having access to basic health or education services.[9] In addition to living with "stigma, shame and prejudice", the community also faces acute poverty as of 2020.[10] A 27 March 2020, article in BBC News details some testimonies of the women of the Lai Dai Han community, who reported that their children "have faced a lifetime of abuse and discrimination, mocked for being Lai Dai Han".[11] One rape victim's father was beaten to death by Vietnamese government personnel shortly after the war ended. Both the Korean and Vietnamese governments have sidelined or ignored the issue, and requests by the BBC to make a documentary were turned down by the Vietnamese government.[11]

South Korea has never recognized allegations of sexual assault by its forces against Vietnamese women and girls (some as young as 12 years old) or the children conceived as a result. Justice for Lai Dai Han (JLDH) is a campaign group that is seeking recognition from South Korea for both the children born as a consequence of rape by Korean troops and their mothers. According to JLDH, tens of thousands of children were born as a consequence of rape by Korean troops, with roughly 800 mothers still living today.[30] Vietnamese women raped by South Korean personnel during the war continue to seek reparations.[34] On 19 October 2015, a petition with close to 29,000 signatures asked South Korean president Park Geun-hye for a formal apology from the South Korean government for the systematic rape and sexual assault perpetrated by South Korean soldiers during the war.[35][36] According to Nadia Murad, winner of the 2019 Nobel Peace Prize, the Lai Dai Han have long been marginalized in Vietnamese society. She went on by saying that as we collaborate to seek justice, the victims and their families deserve to be acknowledged.[30] Also in 2019, British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw asked the United Nations Human Rights Council to launch a comprehensive inquiry into sexual abuse during the Vietnam War, and has urged South Korea "to confront a murky period in its past."[30]

Academic commentary

[edit]

According to Gina Marie Weaver in her book Ideologies of Forgetting Rape in the Vietnam War, the role of rape in the Vietnam War has been omitted from the narratives[5]: 1  and the impact of war on women has altered considerably because war in the twentieth and twenty-first century has evolved into total war.[5] Weaver argues that the United States' replacing of the national conversation about the war onto "the medical and psychological issues of the Vietnam veteran" has suppressed the traumas experienced by "the truest victims of the Vietnam war—Vietnamese civilians, namely, women." Weaver argues that by acknowledging the atrocities committed by the U.S. soldiers in Vietnam, the American's ability to view the veteran as a victim would be "mitigated" or possibly "destroyed".[5]: 11  Weaver stated that not only were documented crimes against Vietnamese women by United States military personnel ignored in the international legal discourse immediately after the war, but modern feminists and other anti-war rape campaigners, as well as historians, have continued to dismiss them.[5]: 5 

According to Daddis, gang rapes were common throughout the war, allegedly because United States military personnel implemented a "systematic, purposeful command policy of violence" against the Vietnamese people.[15]: 194  Numerous personnel viewed both consensual sex and forced rape as time-honored results of the battle, either as "just rewards" or as "collateral damage."[15]: 177 

According to Gina Marie Weaver, the primary sources are rich in accounts of violence, including testimony provided in open hearings held during the war, court cases, military investigations, oral reports gathered for publishing both during and long after the war, and literary works, such as poems, novels, and memoirs.[5]: 6  Additionally, Weaver argues that American discourse around the Vietnam War has largely encompassed only American experiences and the cost to America. There are primary sources from Vietnamese women on their sexual abuse, but due to the nature of the abuse, it is harder to talk about due to its "deeply private nature".[37] Weaver concludes that "true healing" occurs when the public listens to the victims of the war, and become involved in the recovery of Vietnam.[38]

Prevalence in media

[edit]

According to Mark Heberle, despite the fact that the violence of war is typically depicted in its entirety, with violent battles and atrocities done by all sides, rape and sexual violence are frequently avoided and in some cases purposefully omitted from the majority of films.[39]: 52  Although veterans have long given testimony to such crimes, Hollywood war productions have altered or omitted veteran accounts in such a way as to deny their existence or imply that they were the work of deviants instead of typical soldiers.[6] In South Korea, analyses of these works which problematize contentious Vietnam War recollections show "aesthetic, ethical, and political" restrictions and opportunities for depicting memories of sexual abuse and (un)conditional apologies during wartime in visual art.[40]

Incident on Hill 192 is covered in a book by Daniel Lang.[23]: 4  The 1970 film o.k. by Michael Verhoeven was based on the same incident. The 1989 film Casualties of War was based on Lang's book and directed by Brian De Palma.[23]: 4 [41] De Palma's film contains scenes that do not appear in Lang's account of the incident. These sequences include a scene in which the men witness the death of their favorite friend at the hands of VC forces and a scene in which it is implied that these soldiers would not have planned to kidnap and rape a Vietnamese girl if they were permitted to vent their "anger, aggression, and sexual needs on prostitutes".[39]: 50  Furthermore, Peter Conolly-Smith argues that through using a bystander as the viewer of the sexual violence, the film absolves itself of responsibility, allowing a graphic reenactment of the act. This leads to the conclusion that sexual violence in combat films prospers through a "confirmation (however critically it may be articulated) of American hegemony" that is achieved through the domination and subjugation of people, and particularly women, of colour.[42]

In her memoir When Heaven and Earth Changed Places, Le Ly Hayslip wrote about her experience of being raped by Viet Cong soldiers when she was fourteen years old.[43] The 1993 Oliver Stone film Heaven & Earth was based on her memoir. The books Between Heaven and Earth by Le Ly Hayslip and Then the Americans Came by Martha Hess are said by Elisabeth Wood to provide a voice to women who were sexually abused during the war.[5]: 7 

In the book Against Our Will by Brownmiller, her chapter on war offers a thirty-page investigation of the sexual exploitation of women in Vietnam, citing information that has come to light since 1975.[5]: 6 

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Report of the Department of Army review of the preliminary investigations into the Mỹ Lai incident. Volume III, Exhibits, Book 6 – Photographs, 14 March 1970" (PDF). Library of Congress. p. 50.
  2. ^ "Report of the Department of Army review of the preliminary investigations into the Mỹ Lai incident. Volume II, Exhibits, Book 11 – Testimony, 14 March 1970" (PDF). Library of Congress. p. 18. Haeberle: they started stripping her, taking her top off, and the mother, if that was her mother, was trying to protect her. The GI's were punching her around and one of them kicked her in the ass.
  3. ^ Wood, Elisabeth Jean (7 May 2018). "Rape as a Practice of War: Toward a Typology of Political Violence". Politics & Society. 46 (4): 513–537. doi:10.1177/0032329218773710. S2CID 158990694.
  4. ^ West, Philip; Levine, Steven I.; Hiltz, Jackie (3 June 2015). United States and Asia at War: A Cultural Approach: A Cultural Approach. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-45293-5.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Weaver, Gina Marie (1 February 2012). Ideologies of Forgetting: Rape in the Vietnam War. SUNY Press. ISBN 978-1-4384-3000-3. Retrieved 20 June 2022.
  6. ^ a b Weaver, Gina Marie (2007). Ideologies of forgetting: American erasure of women's sexual trauma in the Vietnam War (Thesis). Rice University. hdl:1911/20667. Retrieved 14 September 2022.
  7. ^ a b ey3media (21 August 2018). "Vietnam's Skewed Sense of Social Justice". Justice for Lai Dai Han. Retrieved 28 July 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  8. ^ a b "The Vietnamese women whose mothers were raped in wartime seek justice for a lifetime of pain and prejudice". The Independent. 11 September 2017. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
  9. ^ a b ey3media (21 August 2018). "The invisible struggle of the refugees [Translated]". Justice for Lai Dai Han. Retrieved 28 July 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  10. ^ a b "Sir David Lidington: In 2020, sexual violence is still being used as a weapon of war". The Independent. 19 June 2020. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
  11. ^ a b c "1968 – the year that haunts hundreds of women". BBC News. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
  12. ^ "Vietnam War Rape Survivors Demand Justice from South Korea – Bringing Justice to the Lai Dai Han". 10 August 2021. Retrieved 21 October 2021.[permanent dead link‍]
  13. ^ jp:名越二荒之助 『日韓2000年の真実』〜ベトナムの方がのべる韓国の残虐行為〜、2002年
  14. ^ A. Kameyama, Betonamu Sensou, Saigon Souru, Toukyou [Vietnam War, Saigon, Seoul, Tokyo], Iwanami Shoten Publishing, 1972, p. 122
  15. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m Daddis, Gregory A. (22 October 2020). Pulp Vietnam: War and Gender in Cold War Men's Adventure Magazines. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-49350-5.
  16. ^ a b Crawford, Kerry F. (2017). Wartime Sexual Violence: From Silence to Condemnation of a Weapon of War. Georgetown University Press. ISBN 978-1-62616-466-6.
  17. ^ a b c Rotman, Deborah L.; Savulis, Ellen-Rose (2003). Shared Spaces and Divided Places: Material Dimensions of Gender Relations and the American Historical Landscape. Univ. of Tennessee Press. ISBN 978-1-57233-234-8. Retrieved 2 September 2022.
  18. ^ a b Goldstein, Joshua S. (17 July 2003). War and Gender: How Gender Shapes the War System and Vice Versa. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-00180-9.
  19. ^ Vuic, Kara Dixon (15 August 2017). The Routledge History of Gender, War, and the U.S. Military. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-44908-9.
  20. ^ Baker, Mark (1983). Nam: The Vietnam War in the Words of the Men and Women Who Fought There (1st ed.). New York City: Berkley Books. pp. 187, 298. ISBN 9780425060001. Retrieved 28 October 2022 – via Open Library.
  21. ^ Mikaberidze, Alexander (25 June 2013). Atrocities, Massacres, and War Crimes: An Encyclopedia [2 volumes]: An Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-1-59884-926-4.
  22. ^ Cottrell, Robert C. (14 October 2015). "Introduction: Sex and Saigon: Gendered Perspectives on the Vietnam War". Journal of American-East Asian Relations. 22 (3): 179–186. doi:10.1163/18765610-02203002. ISSN 1058-3947.
  23. ^ a b c d e f Fitzpatrick, Tom (30 August 1989). "There is yet more to Casualties of War". Phoenix New Times. Archived from the original on 19 February 2022. Retrieved 25 July 2010.
  24. ^ Borch (III), Frederic L. (2003). Judge Advocates in Vietnam: Army Lawyers in Southeast Asia, 1959–1975. DIANE Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4289-1064-5. Retrieved 22 August 2022.
  25. ^ Theiss, Evelyn. "Behind the Photos That Showed the World What Really Happened at My Lai". Time. Retrieved 24 August 2022.
  26. ^ Turse, Nick. "The Vietnam War Crimes You Never Heard Of". Columbian College of Arts & Sciences. Retrieved 24 August 2022.
  27. ^ "1965년 전투병 베트남 파병 의결" (in Korean). Donga Ilbo. 2 July 2008. Retrieved 17 July 2011.
  28. ^ a b Koh, Kyoung-tae (25 April 2015). "Vietnamese war victims speak of sexual violence by S. Korean troops for the first time". The Hankyoreh.
  29. ^ Ahn, Young-choon. (2016). [News analysis] South Korea coming to confront Vietnam War civilian massacres. The Hankyoreh. Retrieved 18 November 2016, from link
  30. ^ a b c d "Women raped by Korean soldiers during Vietnam war still awaiting apology". The Guardian. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 21 September 2022.
  31. ^ "조흥국교수의 동남아 들여다보기 <17> 라이따이한 문제". Busan Ilbo. 18 September 2004. Archived from the original on 1 March 2005. Retrieved 25 September 2008. (in Korean)
  32. ^ "베트남에 대한 5가지 오해 ". Maeil Business. 5 October 2004. Retrieved 9 November 2008. (in Korean)
  33. ^ Moon, Katharine H.S. (2015). South Korea's Demographic Changes and their Political Impact. Center for East Asia Policy Studies at Brookings. link
  34. ^ Hendry, Sharon (13 September 2017). "Vietnamese women raped in wartime seek justice for a lifetime of pain and prejudice". Independent.co.uk.
  35. ^ Voices of Vietnam Delivers 29,000 Petition Signatures to Korean Embassy Demanding Apology from President Park. (2015). Voices of Vietnam. Retrieved 15 November 2016, from link Archived 19 September 2016 at the Wayback Machine
  36. ^ Tuason, Czarelli. (2015). Republican Norm Coleman Calls For South Korean President Park Geun Hye To 'Publicly Apologize' To Raped Women During The War in Vietnam. Korea Portal. Retrieved 16 November 2016, from link
  37. ^ Weaver, Gina Marie (2010). Ideologies of Forgetting : Rape in the Vietnam War. Albany: State University of New York Press.
  38. ^ Weaver, Gina Marie (2010). Ideologies of Forgetting : Rape in the Vietnam War. Albany: State University of New York Press.
  39. ^ a b Heberle, Mark (14 January 2009). Thirty Years After: New Essays on Vietnam War Literature, Film and Art. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4438-0367-0.
  40. ^ Kwon, Vicki Sung-yeon (3 July 2022). "Contested Memories, Precarious Apology: The Vietnam War in Contemporary Korean Art". Asian Studies Review. 46 (3): 415–436. doi:10.1080/10357823.2020.1852176. ISSN 1035-7823. S2CID 230565960.
  41. ^ Keesey, Douglas (2015). Brian De Palma's Split-Screen: A Life in Film. University Press of Mississippi. ISBN 9781628466973. JSTOR j.ctt155jp86. Retrieved 24 August 2022.
  42. ^ Conolly-Smith, Peter (October 2013). "Race-ing Rape: Representations of Sexual Violence in American Combat Films". War & Society. 32 (3): 233–251. doi:10.1179/0729247313Z.00000000025. ISSN 0729-2473. S2CID 153942385.
  43. ^ David K. Shipler (31 December 1989). "A Child's Tour of Duty". The New York Times.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Rape_during_the_Vietnam_War&oldid=1252308217"