Jump to content

Post-election pendulum for the 2022 Australian federal election

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Australian Labor Party won the 2022 federal election, winning 77 of 151 seats in the House of Representatives. The Coalition holds 58 seats, and crossbenchers hold the remaining 16.[1]

Classification of seats as marginal, fairly safe or safe is applied by the independent Australian Electoral Commission using the following definition: "Where a winning party receives less than 56% of the vote, the seat is classified as 'marginal', 56–60% is classified as 'fairly safe' and more than 60% is considered 'safe'."[2] Here, 'the vote' is defined as the vote after preferences, where the distribution of preferences has continued to the point where there are only 2 candidates left.

Pendulum

[edit]

The Mackerras pendulum was devised by the Australian psephologist Malcolm Mackerras as a way of predicting the outcome of an election contested between two major parties in a Westminster style lower house legislature such as the Australian House of Representatives, which is composed of single-member electorates and which uses a preferential voting system such as a Condorcet method or instant-runoff voting.

The pendulum works by lining up all of the seats held in Parliament for the government, the opposition and the crossbenches according to the percentage point margin they are held by on a two party preferred basis. This is also known as the swing required for the seat to change hands. Given a uniform swing to the opposition or government parties, the number of seats that change hands can be predicted.[3]

Government seats - 77
Marginal
Gilmore NSW Fiona Phillips ALP 0.17
Lyons Tas Brian Mitchell ALP 0.92
Lingiari NT Marion Scrymgour ALP 0.95
Bennelong NSW Jerome Laxale ALP 0.97
Higgins Vic Michelle Ananda-Rajah ALP 2.06
Robertson NSW Gordon Reid ALP 2.27
Tangney WA Sam Lim ALP 2.37
McEwen Vic Rob Mitchell ALP 3.24
Paterson NSW Meryl Swanson ALP 3.27
Boothby SA Louise Miller-Frost ALP 3.28
Hunter NSW Daniel Repacholi ALP 4.08
Parramatta NSW Andrew Charlton ALP 4.30
Blair Qld Shayne Neumann ALP 5.23
Reid NSW Sally Sitou ALP 5.24
Shortland NSW Pat Conroy ALP 5.25
Dobell NSW Emma McBride ALP 5.61
Werriwa NSW Anne Stanley ALP 5.89
Hasluck WA Tania Lawrence ALP 5.95
Fairly safe
Dunkley Vic Peta Murphy ALP 6.27
Chisholm Vic Carina Garland ALP 6.34
Bruce Vic Julian Hill ALP 6.58
Isaacs Vic Mark Dreyfus ALP 6.90
Holt Vic Cassandra Fernando ALP 7.12
Hawke Vic Sam Rae ALP 7.63
Corangamite Vic Libby Coker ALP 7.64
Richmond NSW Justine Elliot ALP 7.76
Macquarie NSW Susan Templeman ALP 7.73
Eden-Monaro NSW Kristy McBain ALP 8.09
Wills Vic Peter Khalil ALP vs. GRN 8.53
Cooper Vic Ged Kearney ALP vs. GRN 8.68
Macarthur NSW Mike Freelander ALP 8.69
Hindmarsh SA Mark Butler ALP 8.95
Pearce WA Tracey Roberts ALP 8.98
Swan WA Zaneta Mascarenhas ALP 8.99
Rankin Qld Jim Chalmers ALP 9.09
Moreton Qld Graham Perrett ALP 9.09
Solomon NT Luke Gosling ALP 9.37
McMahon NSW Chris Bowen ALP 9.49
Gorton Vic Brendan O'Connor ALP 9.97
Safe
Whitlam NSW Stephen Jones ALP 10.07
Lilley Qld Anika Wells ALP 10.54
Cowan WA Anne Aly ALP 10.79
Makin SA Tony Zappia ALP 10.80
Gellibrand Vic Tim Watts ALP 11.41
Greenway NSW Michelle Rowland ALP 11.54
Oxley Qld Milton Dick ALP 11.59
Adelaide SA Steve Georganas ALP 11.91
Bendigo Vic Lisa Chesters ALP 12.11
Canberra ACT Alicia Payne ALP vs. GRN 12.20
Macnamara Vic Josh Burns ALP 12.25
Jagajaga Vic Kate Thwaites ALP 12.34
Maribyrnong Vic Bill Shorten ALP 12.38
Calwell Vic Maria Vamvakinou ALP 12.39
Lalor Vic Joanne Ryan ALP 12.82
Spence SA Matt Burnell ALP 12.90
Bean ACT David Smith ALP 12.95
Ballarat Vic Catherine King ALP 12.97
Corio Vic Richard Marles ALP 13.01
Chifley NSW Ed Husic ALP 13.36
Franklin Tas Julie Collins ALP 13.70
Hotham Vic Clare O'Neil ALP 14.25
Kingsford Smith NSW Matt Thistlethwaite ALP 14.51
Cunningham NSW Alison Byrnes ALP 14.70
Perth WA Patrick Gorman ALP 14.80
Blaxland NSW Jason Clare ALP 14.94
Burt WA Matt Keogh ALP 15.21
Watson NSW Tony Burke ALP 15.21
Barton NSW Linda Burney ALP 15.54
Scullin Vic Andrew Giles ALP 15.58
Fenner ACT Andrew Leigh ALP 15.69
Kingston SA Amanda Rishworth ALP 16.35
Sydney NSW Tanya Plibersek ALP vs. GRN 16.56
Brand WA Madeleine King ALP 16.71
Fraser Vic Daniel Mulino ALP 16.73
Fremantle WA Josh Wilson ALP 16.89
Grayndler NSW Anthony Albanese ALP vs. GRN 17.06
Newcastle NSW Sharon Claydon ALP 17.98
Opposition seats - 58
Marginal
Deakin Vic Michael Sukkar LIB 0.19
Sturt SA James Stevens LIB 0.45
Moore WA Ian Goodenough LIB 0.66
Menzies Vic Keith Wolahan LIB 0.68
Bass Tas Bridget Archer LIB 1.43
Casey Vic Aaron Violi LIB 1.48
Dickson Qld Peter Dutton LNP 1.70
Cowper NSW Pat Conaghan NAT vs. IND 2.32
Aston Vic Alan Tudge[a] LIB 2.81
Monash Vic Russell Broadbent[b] LIB 2.90
Longman Qld Terry Young LNP 3.08
Banks NSW David Coleman LIB 3.20
Bonner Qld Ross Vasta LNP 3.41
Leichhardt Qld Warren Entsch LNP 3.44
Canning WA Andrew Hastie LIB 3.59
Nicholls Vic Sam Birrell NAT vs. IND 3.81
Flynn Qld Colin Boyce LNP 3.82
Wannon Vic Dan Tehan LIB vs. IND 3.92
Bradfield NSW Paul Fletcher LIB vs. IND 4.21
Forde Qld Bert Van Manen LNP 4.23
Durack WA Melissa Price LIB 4.27
Forrest WA Nola Marino LIB 4.29
Petrie Qld Luke Howarth LNP 4.44
Bowman Qld Henry Pike LNP 5.51
Fairly safe
Lindsay NSW Melissa McIntosh LIB 6.34
Capricornia Qld Michelle Landry LNP 6.59
Flinders Vic Zoe McKenzie LIB 6.70
Groom Qld Garth Hamilton LNP vs. IND 6.89
O'Connor WA Rick Wilson LIB 6.97
Hughes NSW Jenny Ware LIB 7.01
Hume NSW Angus Taylor LIB 7.72
Braddon Tas Gavin Pearce LIB 8.03
Fisher Qld Andrew Wallace LNP 8.67
La Trobe Vic Jason Wood LIB 8.69
Fairfax Qld Ted O'Brien LNP 8.97
McPherson Qld Karen Andrews LNP 9.34
Calare NSW Andrew Gee[c] NAT vs. IND 9.68
Berowra NSW Julian Leeser LIB 9.77
Safe
Grey SA Rowan Ramsey LIB 10.07
Hinkler Qld Keith Pitt LNP 10.07
Dawson Qld Andrew Willcox LNP 10.42
Fadden Qld Stuart Robert[d] LNP 10.63
Mitchell NSW Alex Hawke LIB 10.69
Page NSW Kevin Hogan NAT 10.74
Wright Qld Scott Buchholz LNP 10.89
Moncrieff Qld Angie Bell LNP 11.19
Wide Bay Qld Llew O'Brien LNP 11.34
Herbert Qld Phillip Thompson LNP 11.77
Cook NSW Scott Morrison LIB 12.44
Lyne NSW David Gillespie NAT 13.80
Riverina NSW Michael McCormack NAT 14.85
Farrer NSW Sussan Ley LIB 16.35
New England NSW Barnaby Joyce NAT 16.43
Barker SA Tony Pasin LIB 16.62
Parkes NSW Mark Coulton NAT 17.84
Mallee Vic Anne Webster NAT 18.99
Gippsland Vic Darren Chester NAT 20.57
Maranoa Qld David Littleproud LNP 22.12
Crossbench seats - 16
Greens seats - 4
Marginal
Ryan Qld Elizabeth Watson-Brown GRN vs. LNP 2.65
Brisbane Qld Stephen Bates GRN vs. LNP 3.73
Safe
Melbourne Vic Adam Bandt GRN vs. ALP 10.15
Griffith Qld Max Chandler-Mather GRN vs. LNP 10.46
Other Crossbench - 12
Marginal
Curtin WA Kate Chaney IND vs. LIB 1.26
Fowler NSW Dai Le IND vs. ALP 1.63
Mackellar NSW Sophie Scamps IND vs. LIB 2.50
Goldstein Vic Zoe Daniel IND vs. LIB 2.87
North Sydney NSW Kylea Tink IND vs. LIB 2.91
Kooyong Vic Monique Ryan IND vs. LIB 2.94
Wentworth NSW Allegra Spender IND vs. LIB 4.19
Fairly safe
Indi Vic Helen Haines IND vs. LIB 9.08
Safe
Warringah NSW Zali Steggall IND vs. LIB 10.92
Mayo SA Rebekha Sharkie CA vs. LIB 12.27
Kennedy Qld Bob Katter KAP vs. LNP 13.10
Clark Tas Andrew Wilkie IND vs. ALP 20.82

Analysis

[edit]

ABC psephologist Antony Green observed that due to the considerably expanded size of the crossbench following this election, the traditional two-column format of the Mackerras pendulum had become strained, and that the crossbench deserved more attention than its position at the bottom-right of the table suggested.[4]

Election analyst Ben Raue observed that the use of the two-party-preferred count in the Mackerras Pendulum also had the effect of classifying several seats as safer than they really were: for example, the seat of Macnamara ended up with a 12.25% margin of victory for the Labor candidate, but if just 0.64% of voters had changed their preference to rank the Greens higher than Labor, Labor would have finished third, with the Greens winning the seat by a similarly large margin.[5]

To overcome some of these limitations, the pollster Jim Reed produced a new Reed Pendulum after the 2022 election.[6] This uses a two-candidate-preferred margin to classify each seat instead of a notional two-party preference count for the major parties, and has three arms so that contests involving minor parties and independent candidates are more clearly identified. One or two swing figures can be used to calculate seat changes along the arms.

Change in composition

[edit]

Seats changing classification

[edit]
  • Includes gains.
Seat Classification Swing
(to winner)
2019 2022
Aston (VIC) Safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –7.32
Banks (NSW) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –3.06
Bendigo (VIC) Fairly safe Labor Safe Labor +3.29
Bennelong (NSW) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Labor +7.89
Boothby (SA) Marginal Liberal Marginal Labor +4.66
Braddon (TAS) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Liberal +4.94
Brisbane (QLD) Marginal LNP Marginal Greens +53.73
Calwell (VIC) Very safe Labor Safe Labor –7.32
Chisholm (VIC) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Labor +6.86
Cooper (VIC) Very safe Labor Safe Labor –6.16
Corangamite (VIC) Marginal Labor Fairly Labor +6.55
Cowan (WA) Marginal Labor Safe Labor +9.96
Cowper (NSW) Fairly safe National Marginal National –4.47
Curtin (WA) Safe Liberal Marginal Independent +51.20
Bonner (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Marginal LNP –4.00
Bowman (QLD) Safe LNP Marginal LNP –4.73
Capricornia (QLD) Safe LNP Fairly safe LNP –4.00
Dunkley (VIC) Marginal Labor Fairly safe Labor +3.52
Eden-Monaro (NSW) Marginal Labor Fairly safe Labor +7.35
Fairfax (QLD) Safe LNP Fairly safe LNP –4.00
Fisher (QLD) Safe LNP Fairly safe LNP –4.03
Flinders (VIC) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Liberal +1.06
Flynn (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Marginal LNP –4.84
Forde (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Marginal LNP –4.37
Fowler (NSW) Safe Labor Marginal Independent +51.63
Gippsland (VIC) Safe National Very safe National +3.90
Goldstein (VIC) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Independent +52.87
Gorton (VIC) Safe Labor Fairly safe Labor –7.32
Greenway (NSW) Marginal Labor Safe Labor +8.73
Griffith (QLD) Marginal Labor Safe Greens +60.46
Groom (QLD) Very safe LNP Fairly safe LNP –13.60
Hasluck (WA) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Labor +11.89
Herbert (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Safe LNP +3.41
Higgins (VIC) Marginal Liberal Marginal Labor +4.67
Indi (VIC) Marginal Independent Fairly safe Independent +7.55
Jagajaga (VIC) Fairly safe Labor Safe Labor +6.46
Kooyong (VIC) Marginal Liberal Marginal Independent +52.94
La Trobe (VIC) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Liberal +3.56
Lilley (QLD) Marginal Labor Safe Labor +9.90
Lindsay (NSW) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Liberal +1.30
Mackellar (NSW) Safe Liberal Marginal Independent +52.50
Macnamara (VIC) Fairly safe Labor Safe Labor +7.34
Macquarie (NSW) Marginal Labor Fairly safe Labor +7.58
Mallee (VIC) Safe National Very safe National +3.31
McPherson (QLD) Safe LNP Fairly safe LNP –2.86
Melbourne (VIC) Very safe Greens Safe Greens –12.44
Menzies (VIC) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –6.34
Monash (VIC) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –3.96
Moreton (QLD) Marginal Labor Fairly safe Labor +7.19
Nicholls (VIC) Very safe National Marginal National –16.22
North Sydney (NSW) Safe Liberal Marginal Independent +52.92
Oxley (QLD) Fairly safe Labor Safe Labor +5.20
Pearce (WA) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Labor +14.23
Petrie (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Marginal LNP –3.96
Reid (NSW) Marginal Liberal Marginal Labor +8.37
Richmond (NSW) Marginal Labor Fairly safe Labor +4.15
Robertson (NSW) Marginal Liberal Marginal Labor +6.50
Ryan (QLD) Fairly safe LNP Marginal Greens +52.65
Scullin (VIC) Very safe Labor Safe Labor –6.08
Sturt (SA) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –6.42
Swan (WA) Marginal Liberal Fairly safe Labor +11.99
Tangney (WA) Fairly safe Liberal Marginal Labor +11.88
Wannon (VIC) Safe Liberal Marginal Liberal –6.24
Wentworth (NSW) Marginal Liberal Marginal Independent +54.19

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Alan Tudge resigned from parliament in 2023 and the ensuing by-election was won by Labor candidate Mary Doyle
  2. ^ Broadbent resigned from the Liberal party after losing preselection in November 2023, and now sits as an independent
  3. ^ Andrew Gee resigned in 2022 to sit as an independent.
  4. ^ Stuart Robert resigned from parliament in 2023 and the ensuing by-election was won by LNP candidate Cameron Caldwell

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Seat summary". AEC Tally Room. Australian Electoral Commission. Retrieved 27 May 2022.
  2. ^ Division Classifications, Virtual Tally Room 2016, Australian Electoral Commission. Retrieved 21 August 2016.
  3. ^ Sakkal, Paul; Rooney, Kieran (14 November 2023). "Veteran Liberal Party MP Russell Broadbent quits party, moves to crossbench". The Sydney Morning Herald.
  4. ^ Antony Green (19 June 2022). "2022 Post-Federal Election Pendulum". Antony Green's Election Blog. Retrieved 29 June 2022.
  5. ^ Ben Raue (27 June 2022). "Understanding 3CP trends". The Tally Room. Retrieved 29 June 2022.
  6. ^ Jim Reed (13 June 2022). "2022 Post-Federal Election Reed Pendulum" (PDF). Resolve Strategic. Retrieved 8 July 2022.