Cantonese nasal-stop alternation

In Cantonese phonology, a close relationship exists between the nasal codas (-m, -n, -ŋ) and the stop codas (-p, -t, -k). These two types of codas can also be classified into three homorganic pairs: the bilabial m/p, the dental n/t, and the velar ŋ/k. Their close association is best evidenced by the very fact that all stop sounds come from nasal sounds.^{[citation needed]}

The phonological alternation

Apart from phonetical association, the homorganic pairs are also semantically related. For some characters (or words) with syllables ending in nasals, there are semantically similar characters which have the homorganic stops. For example, both dam3 揼 and “dap1” 耷 means ‘to hang down’. The initial consonants and the vowels of the alternating pair are identical while the terminal nasal /–m/ and stop /–p/ are a homorganic pair. In Cantonese phonology, this interesting phenomenon is known as nasal-stop alternation (陽入對轉), mainly an alternation of homorganic consonants between nasal and stop finals. In other dialects, it could be oral-nasal or oral-stop alternation.

Regarding the initial consonants, a few items may alternate between aspirated and unaspirated initial stops, e.g. “kim4” 拑 ‘to pinch’ and “gip6” 挟 ‘to squeeze together’. As for tones, high or low tones on syllables with nasal codas usually (but not always) correspond to high or low tones on syllables with stop codas, e.g. “ngam4” 吟 ‘to grumble’ has a low tone whereas “ngap1” 噏 ‘to babble’ has a high tone.

Many of these characters are colloquial verbs which lack standard Chinese characters as their written forms. For example, there is not a widely accepted character for “jip3”, ‘to pickle in salt’. Consequently, the homorganic character “jim1” 腌 is also used to represent both syllables.^[1] The same is true for ‘‘doeŋ3’’ 啄 ‘to peck’ being used to stand for ‘‘doek1’’ as well.

As for their semantics or usage, the paired characters are not completely equivalent or interchangeable in every case. The colloquial verb “kam2” 冚 seems to be more commonly used than the corresponding “kap1” 扱, both meaning ‘to cover on top’. On the other hand, “fiŋ6” 捹 and “fik6” 扐 both mean ‘to throw away; to swing an object in the hand’ and are interchangeable; the same is also true for “niŋ1” 拎 and “nik1” 搦 ‘to carry in the hand’.

Different theories

Most linguists believe that the syllables with nasal codas are the more basic originals while the stops are the colloquial variants.^[2] A few opine that there are an equal number of word pairings that are originated from the syllables with stop codas.^[3] However, it is generally agreed that the usage of the nasal members are less restricted than their stop counterparts.

Other linguists regard the alternation between homorganic final consonants in pairs of semantically-related words as a feature widely found among languages of Southeast Asia as well as south China (Chuang-chia and Hmong for example). Such paired words belong to a “word-family”, a term first used by Bernhard Karlgren (1934) to refer to sets of words with similar (but not identical) sound in Archaic Chinese that were related in meaning, representing relics of morphological processes.^[4] Similarly, Bauer notes that the Cantonese phenomenon is believed to be a remnant of an ancient word-derivation process, now no longer productive, in which different types of suffixes (causative and transitive) were attached to lexical roots.^[5]

Some examples

In the Cantonese syllabary, there are about 50 pairs of such characters that show alternation between homorganic nasal and stop codas. The following is a list of some examples for reference:

Nasal codas			Stop codas
laam5	覽	look at	laap3	䁽	glance at
dam3	揼	to hang down, sag	dap1	耷	to hang down, droop
kam2	冚	to cover on top	kap1	扱	to cover on top
ŋam4	吟	to grumble	ŋap1	噏	to babble, gossip
jim1	腌	to pickle in salt	jip3	醃	to pickle in salt
saan3	散	to disperse, spread	saat3	撒	to scatter, sow, spill
ŋan3	䟴	to stand on tiptoes	ŋat6	趷	to stand on tiptoes
bin6	辨	to distinguish	bit6	別	to identify
kin2	掀	to open up (book); remove	kit3	揭	to open up (book); unveil
fun1	寬	spacious	fut3	闊	wide
ciŋ3	掅	to lift up (luggage)	cik1	摵	to pull up (trousers)
fiŋ6	捹	to fling away; swing (a limb)	fik6	扐	to fling away; swing (a flag)
niŋ1	拎	to carry by hand	nik1	搦	to carry by hand
toŋ3	趟	to slide open (a door)	tok3	托	to push up (a bar)
doeŋ1	啄	to peck	doek3	剁	to cut

References

^ 陳伯煇:《論粵方言詞本字考釋》. Hong Kong: Chung Hwa Bookstore, 1998, p.89
^ Tsou, Benjamin: “Homorganic Nasal/Stop Alternations in Cantonese”, University of Hong Kong
^ Zhan Bohui: 廣東粵方言概要 “(An Outline of Yue Dialects in Guangdong)”, Guangzhou: Jinan University Press, 2002, pp 19-20
^ Chan, Marjorie: Cahiers de Linguistique Asie Orientale (1999) 28.1:101-112
^ Bauer, Robert: “Modern Cantonese Phonology”, London: Routledge, 1997, pp 92-93

External links

Modern Cantonese Phonology by Robert S. Bauer and Paul K. Benedict (Ohio State University)
Homorganic Nasal/Stop Alterations in Cantonese by Benjamin K. T'sou (University of Hong Kong)

[1] 陳伯煇:《論粵方言詞本字考釋》. Hong Kong: Chung Hwa Bookstore, 1998, p.89

[2] Tsou, Benjamin: “Homorganic Nasal/Stop Alternations in Cantonese”, University of Hong Kong

[3] Zhan Bohui: 廣東粵方言概要 “(An Outline of Yue Dialects in Guangdong)”, Guangzhou: Jinan University Press, 2002, pp 19-20

[4] Chan, Marjorie: Cahiers de Linguistique Asie Orientale (1999) 28.1:101-112

[5] Bauer, Robert: “Modern Cantonese Phonology”, London: Routledge, 1997, pp 92-93

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]