Jump to content

Ziyavudin Magomedov

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In this name that follows Eastern Slavic naming customs, the patronymic is Gadzhievich and the family name is Magomedov.

Ziyavudin Magomedov
Born25 September 1968 (1968-09-25) (age 56)
Makhachkala, Dagestan ASSR, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union
NationalityRussian
EducationMoscow State University
OccupationFormer Russian oligarch
Websitewww.summagroup.ru/en/

Ziyavudin Gadzhievich Magomedov (Russian: Зиявудин Гаджиевич Магомедов, born 1968) is a former Russian oligarch who amassed a business empire during presidency of Dmitry Medvedev, who stood in for Vladimir Putin from 2008 to 2012.[1][2] According to Finance magazine, during just one year of Medvedev's presidency, Magomedov's wealth increased by more than eleven times – from $70M to $800M.[3][4]

Dmitry Medvedev supervises the signing of a cooperation agreement between the head of the port of Rotterdam, Hans Smits, and the head of Summa Capital, Ziyavudin Magomedov.

Prior to his arrest Magomedov was the owner of Summa Group,[5] a large Russian diversified private holding that primarily operated in sectors requiring government licenses and approvals.[6][2][4][7] He used his political ties to acquire assets in port logistics, transport and infrastructure, engineering, construction, telecommunications and technology, as well as oil and gas. Companies of the Summa Group were present in almost 40 regions of Russia, as well as abroad, and employed more than ten thousand people.

Magomedov relied especially on his long and close friendship with Arkady Dvorkovich,[4][8][9][10][11][6] who was a key economic advisor to President Dmitry Medvedev.[12] Zuyavudin was also closely connected to Vladimir Putin's press secretary Dmitry Peskov[13][14] and Gennady Timchenko,[15][16][17] Putin's close friend since the early 1990s and one of the richest oligarchs in Russia.

In 2022 Ziyavudin was included in the list of bribe-takers and warmongers, aka the 6,000 List, compiled by the Anti-Corruption Foundation founded by Alexey Navalny. The purpose of the list was to create a comprehensive list of enablers of the Russo-Ukrainian War and the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. Magomedov was categorized under ‘Individuals involved in corruption’ as ‘a businessman, a friend of Putin's, paid for a honeymoon on a yacht for Peskov's family".[18][19][20]

Key Russian opposition activists and political prisoners Alexey Navalny and Mikhail Khodorkovsky have accused Magomedov of paying multimillion-dollar bribes by renting or purchasing super-yachts for high-profile Russian officials, including Dmitry Peskov and Vladimir Putin himself.[13][15]

In March 2018 Ziyavudin Magomedov was arrested in Russia along with his business partner, brother and Russian ex-senator, Magomed Magomedov.[21] Kremlin representatives claimed that Magomedov's arrest was ‘part of the Russian government's efforts to fight corruption’.[22][23] Magomedov's defenders led by his cousin Ahmed Bilalov insisted that he was persecuted "under politically motivated circumstances".[24][25] Independent political analysts acknowledged that the specific charges of 'embezzlement of state funds' during the construction of a soccer World Cup venue in the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad against Magomedov were largely unfounded. However, they also believed that Ziyavudin fell out of favor and gained several enemies among Vladimir Putin's closest and most powerful allies.[10][26]

Prominent anticorruption activist, Russian opposition leader, and political prisoner Alexey Navalny refrained from characterising Magomedov's arrest as political persecution. Instead, he viewed it as 'merely one set of corrupt officials and fraudsters outmaneuvering another group of corrupt officials and fraudsters.' He further commented,

'Overall, this isn't related to politics. The country's economic base is dwindling, money is becoming scarce, resulting in these swindlers preying on each other. Essentially, it's all part of a larger process of defrauding us, the Russian taxpayers'.[27]

Magomedov's arrest was also associated with infighting among Russian elites[28] and the crackdown against the so-called "Medvedev’s clan",[29][30][31][32] which gradually lost its power and influence after Dmitry Medvedev ceded the post of Russian President to Vladimir Putin in 2012. Magomedov was among several oligarchs and high-profile government officials generally linked to Medvedev's clan who were either arrested, removed from office, or fled the country between 2013 and 2019. This group included Magomedov's cousin, Akhmed Bilalov, former Deputy Prime Minister Mikhail Abyzov, and former Minister of Defense Anatoly Serdyukov.

In December 2022 Ziyavudin was sentenced to an unprecedented term of 19 years in prison.[33] A year later in December 2023 the court of appeal reduced his sentence by six months – from 19 years to 18 years and 6 months.[34][35][36]

In July 2023 Magomedov filed a $13.8bn legal claim in London's High Court alleging a Kremlin-led conspiracy to seize his assets.[37][38][39][40] Defendants include private equity firm TPG, Dubai-based ports operator DP World, Transneft, and former executives at Magomedov's company. The claim is one of the largest ever brought before the English High Court.[41]

Early life

[edit]

Ziyavudin Magomedov was born in 1968 in Makhachkala, Dagestan.[42] His ethnicity is Avar.[43]

Magomedov's father was a surgeon, his mother worked as a teacher. Ziyavudin was one of four children in the family. His elder brother and business partner, Magomed Magomedov, also gained fame; from 2002 to 2009, he served as a member of the Federation Council of the Russian Federation representing the Smolensk region.[44]

Education

[edit]

In 1993 Magomedov earned a bachelor's degree in international economics from Moscow State University.[45]

While studying at the university, Ziyavudin made acquaintances that became decisive in his future career. He became a close friend of Arkady Dvorkovich, who from 2008 to 2012 served as President Medvedev's right-hand man and was responsible for economic regulation. In 2012, Dvorkovich became Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian government, overseeing the industries in which Magomedov's company acquired assets.

According to Novaya Gazeta, a media outlet headed at the time by 2021 Nobel Prize winner Dmitry Muratov, Magomedov and Dvorkovich briefly shared a room on a university campus. Sometimes, Magomedov even beat those who offended Dvorkovich.

"After the election of a new president, Arkady Dvorkovich, with whom Magomedov studied in the same group at the Faculty of Economics of Moscow State University and for some time even shared the same room in the university dormitory, became the Kremlin curator of economic sectors that appealed to the head of the still little-known Summa group of companies. The friendship that began in their youth grew stronger every year until it turned into a full-fledged partnership in the mid-2000s. "They are complete antipodes. Arkady is small, delicate, avoids sharp corners, but is neat and has a sharp analytical mind. And Zia is tall, lean, powerful, decisive, talking to people from a position of strength. These opposites are attracted. They were interested in spending time together, they supported each other in their studies, they had a sense of back. A couple of times Zia even beat Arkady’s offenders," recalls an acquaintance of Magomedov."

Novaya Gazeta, The Prime Minister Removed from His Inner Circle: How the downfall of the Summa company and the arrest of its owners, the Magomedovs, will assist Dmitry Medvedev in retaining his position, 2018 [46]

Another of Ziyavudin’s neighbors in the university dormitory was Ruben Vardanyan (future founder of Troika Dialogue).[47]

Ziyavudin Magomedov earned a PhD in international economics in 2000 from Moscow State University.

Career

[edit]

Early stages

[edit]

While a student during Perestroika in the late 1980s, Magomedov sold imported computers with his brother out of their university dormitory.[48] In the early 1990s he founded the company Interfinance, specialising in investments and financial activities.

2000s

[edit]

Magomedov expanded his business interests in the early 2000s, acquiring land in Primorsk, Leningrad Oblast on which the Primorsk Trade Port was built, with a significant stake owned by Magomedov.  

From 2004 to 2005 he was chair of the board of directors of Trans-Oil and the chairman of the board of directors of First Mining Company.

In 2006 Magomedov acquired over 80% of the PJSC Yakutsk Fuel and Energy Company (YATEC), a gas and fuel production company and the main gas producer in the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).

In 2006 Magomedov's Summa, which had no prior experience in the telecommunications market, unexpectedly obtained a federal license to offer wireless Internet access services using the WiMAX standard.[49] However, the company was unable to build this business and eventually was stripped of frequencies in 2013.[50][51]

2008–2012: Rapid rise during Medvedev's presidency

[edit]

Magomedov toiled on the margins of Russian business until Dmitry Medvedev became Vladimir Putin’s place-holder president. Then in just three years Ziyavudin made most of his fortune through transport and logistics deals, often with the state.[7][4] Magomedov's business enjoyed wild success during Dmitry Medvedev's presidency. In 2009, the magazine Finance valued his wealth at $70 million. A year later, Magomedov's worth had jumped to $800 million.[3][46]

"Summa really only became an economic power in the last two years. They are essentially a Medvedev project," says one senior international banker.

Financial Times, "Russia: Eyes on the prize", 2012 [4]

Media and analysts associated Magomedov’s success with the role of Arkady Dvorkovich, who, as an assistant and then deputy to Medvedev, oversaw the fuel and energy complex, industry, agriculture and transport — the main sectors in which Summa was one way or another present.[52]

Ziyavudin once studied in the same course at the Faculty of Economics of Moscow State University together with Medvedev’s longtime ally and assistant Arkady Dvorkovich. The friendship remained for many years. Dvorkovich, being Medvedev's deputy, oversaw the fuel and energy complex, industry, agriculture and transport — the main sectors in which Summa was one way or another present.

Novaya Gazeta, "Summozakluchenie", 2022[52]

The Magomedovs’ largest customers were the structures of the Ministry of Transport, which was supervised by Dvorkovich. The amount of such contracts for 2012–2015 exceeded 120 billion rubles (approx. $4 billion by average exchange rate).

Forbes Russia magazine, "Family Affairs. How the Magomedov Brothers Built Their Business and the Consequences of Their Dispute", 2018[53]

Thanks to his connections with Medvedev’s right-hand man, Magomedov rapidly ascended in status. In 2010, he became Russia's representative in APEC and by 2012 he held the position of Chairman of ABAC, the APEC Business Advisory Council.[54]

Controversial NCSP deal

[edit]

In January 2011 Magomedov together with "Transneft" acquired a majority (50.1%) of the Novorossiysk Commercial Sea Port (NCSP), the largest Russian port operator and the 3rd largest operator in Europe in terms of cargo turnover. In 2012 Mr. Magomedov was made chairman of the board of directors of PJSC NCSP.

The deal was heavily criticized in media and by anticorruption activists. Summa was accused of purchasing NCSP using port's own funds in a highly questionable transaction.

Investors questioned the acquisition, because the deal did not technically cost Summa anything. In a complicated merger deal, the London-traded Novorossiysk port group first borrowed $2.1bn from the state's Sberbank to buy Primorsk port on the Baltic Sea from Summa and Transneft. Summa and Transneft then used the cash to acquire Novorossiysk from its former owners, who included Arkady Rotenberg, President Vladimir Putin's former judo partner. Some investors say Novorossiysk overpaid for Primorsk and tell-tale signs appear in the group's accounts. One is that $1.1bn is set aside in goodwill costs for the Primorsk acquisition, while pre-tax profits generated by Primorsk last year were not enough to repay annual interest on the loan. But the deal, which took the form of a reverse takeover, cost Novorossiysk $2.1bn while technically costing Summa nothing. Meanwhile, the group has not visibly improved value for the port's investors: indeed, the share price has fallen more than 40 per cent.

Financial Times, "Russia: Eyes on the prize", 2012[4]

Prominent anticorruption activist, Russian opposition leader, and political prisoner Alexey Navalny also commented on the sequence of transactions involving the Primorsk Trade Port and NCSP:

The Magomedovs purchased a plot of land, and the remaining resources for the construction of the Primorsk Trade Port were provided by Transneft. However, in this process, the Magomedovs obtained a 50% stake in a joint venture... At that time, Transneft was still under the leadership of Weinstock. One of Weinstock's major schemes was embezzling a considerable amount of money from Transneft alongside the Magomedovs during the establishment of the Primorsk Sea Port. Next comes the Novorossiysk Commercial Sea Port. This company bought the Primorsk Trade Port using a loan obtained from Sberbank. With these funds, the Magomedovs acquired a substantial stake in the Novorossiysk port, becoming the main shareholders. Essentially, they invested nothing in it, as they essentially obtained ownership in the Primorsk port virtually free of charge. They continue to own the Primorsk port, now a subsidiary of the Novorossiysk port, while simultaneously becoming the largest shareholders of the Novorossiysk seaport. They invested nothing, yet, through legal maneuvering, amassed enormous property worth many billions of rubles...

Navalny's YouTube Channel, ‘Kemerovo. Switchmen punished, Magomedovs arrested, Moscow mayoral elections’, Streamed on Apr 5, 2018. Timecode: 31:48 – 43:50.[27]

Medvedev’s government’s privatisation plan

[edit]

In 2012 Summa came under scrutiny as a beneficiary of favoritism during the new privatisation plan announced by the Dmitry Medvedev-led government. According to Financial Times it “put Summa at the centre of the controversy over the proposed sell-off, meaning the stakes it buys and the amount it pays are becoming a crucial test of Moscow’s ability to distance itself from earlier, tainted privatisations and thus bolster the market economy”.

The group, lacking any significant experience in international commodity trading, unexpectedly outbid foreign contenders, including the French commodities trader Louis Dreyfus, and secured a stake of 50 percent minus one share in the United Grain Company, the state trader, for $186 million in the new government's first sell-off in May 2012.[4][55]

In July 2012 Summa bought a stake in the Fesco Transport Group from Sergei Generalov,[56][57] a former Minister of Fuel and Energy of Russia. The Fesco Transport Group owned the Commercial Port of Vladivostok, the largest universal port in the Russian Far East.

King of State Contracts

[edit]

In July 2012 in a commentary to the Financial Times, Mr. Magomedov claimed that Summa's annual revenue had reached $10 billion.[58] A significant portion of this revenue, was derived from state contracts. During that year Summa secured the fourth position in the Forbes ranking titled 'The Kings Of State Contracts’, based on official government data analyzing the winners of state tenders.[59]

According to Forbes, in 2011 the company garnered 226 billion rubles (approx. $7.5 billion by the annual average exchange rate) from state contracts in railroad, electricity, and pipeline construction. Summa's major clients were state-owned entities like RZD, Transneft, and FSK Rosseti.

Forbes excluded the company's revenue from the Bolshoi Theatre renovation, which cost 35.4 billion rubles (or $1.13 billion by the annual average exchange rate), as Summa was not the sole subcontractor.[47]

Thus, major part of the company's revenue was connected to sources associated with the Russian state: a country which at the time was ranked 133rd in the Transparency Corruption Perception Index,[60] and where only 3.6% of government procurement was conducted entirely on a competitive basis.[61]

2013–2018: Downfall following the political job swap between Putin and Medvedev

[edit]

In 2012 Putin and Medvedev executed the famous "rokirovka",[62] leading to a job swap between them. Putin returned to the seat of the Russian President, while Medvedev downgraded to the position of prime minister. This political move marked the beginning of the downfall of the so-called 'Medvedev's clan,' consisting of oligarchs and high government officials close to him.[10]

By 2016 Magomedov was no longer in the Forbes 'Kings of State Contracts' ranking.[63][64] This marked rising tensions between his company Summa and their state clients, who were unsatisfied with the work done by Summa's construction subsidiaries. These tensions were confirmed to the Financial Times by a person close to Arkady Dvorkovich:

Though Mr Magomedov’s connections and fortune saw the US name him on its “Kremlin Report” in January, his ties to the US — where he was preparing to fly with his family before his arrest on Saturday — and combative negotiating style earned him several powerful enemies, a person close to Mr Dvorkovich said. “Ziya really wore everyone out. He built roads — they collapsed. He laid pipelines — they leaked.”

Financial Times, "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement", 2018 [10]

After Mr Putin replaced Mr Medvedev as president in 2012, state companies challenged the deals that had made Mr Magomedov’s fortune. Many of them were in industries regulated by Mr Dvorkovich, who went to Moscow State University with the Magomedov brothers.

Financial Times, "Billionaire's arrest points to Kremlin power struggle", 2018[11]

According to Novaya Gazeta, Ziyavudin Magomedov's situation was exacerbated by his combative negotiation style, particularly with state representatives, which was highly unusual in the Russian business environment. This approach even resulted in a conflict between Ziyavudin and his elder brother Magomed, who believed that being too harsh with state actors could jeopardize their business and lives:

Despite their kinship, the brothers turned out to be completely different in nature. The elder is characterized by calmness and prudence, and at the same time, a difficult character, while the younger by empathy but also a hot temper and unwillingness to compromise with business partners. The elder brother believed that it was dangerous to bargain and argue with the state. The younger one was inclined to dispute, even when business partners had significant administrative support from the state. Ziyavudin turned out to be an atypical representative of modern Russian business, a realm with its implicit concepts, codes, and rules, the violation of which is a direct path either to emigration or to prison. And Ziyavudin's inability to reach agreements with individuals close to the state is perhaps another reason why he and his brother found themselves in pre-trial detention.

Novaya Gazeta, Summozakluchenie, 2022[52]

Conflict with Transneft

[edit]

According to Novaya Gazeta, the first conflict between the co-owners of NCSP, namely Summa and the state monopoly Transneft, emerged right after the purchase of the port. Transneft suspected that Magomedov’s company was siphoning money from NCSP.

Despite the external harmony of this undoubtedly tactical alliance, the first shareholder conflict between the partners arose almost immediately. The parties had long disputed seats on the management board of NCSP. When Magomedov finally secured the right to operational management of the company, the leadership of Transneft suspected the partner of diverting part of the profits in favor of entities under his control.

According to a source in the FSB, the billionaire shifted the center of profit formation to the so-called "pilotage services," which, under contract, performed stevedoring and bunkering work for the port.

"Whoever controls management controls profitability. The port's management significantly inflated the expenses for service works, effectively engaging in the outflow of a large amount of money," says the source.

Novaya Gazeta, The Prime Minister Removed from His Inner Circle: How the downfall of the Summa company and the arrest of its owners, the Magomedovs, will assist Dmitry Medvedev in retaining his position, 2018 [46]

Technology investments that could anger Putin

[edit]

In 2015 Magomedov began investing in technology companies. By September 2016, he had invested $300 million in technology stocks such as Uber and Virgin Hyperloop One.[48] He was co-executive chairman of Virgin Hyperloop One prior to his arrest.[65]

According to several sources, Ziyavudin's act of diverting money earned from government contracts to a country that imposed sanctions on the Russian economy and was considered hostile by Putin could potentially anger the Russian President.

An aggravating circumstance could have been that recently the Magomedovs had been involved in financing foreign projects, such as the creation of a vacuum high-speed train based on Elon Musk's idea and the cultivation of artificial diamonds. They were transferring money abroad while benefiting from significant state contracts and failing important projects within the country.

Sobesednik, "From Summa to Prison", 2018[66]

Net worth

[edit]

Prior to his arrest in 2018, Magomedov's net worth was estimated to be $1.2 billion. At its peak in 2017, it was estimated to be $1.4 billion.[67]

Corruption allegations

[edit]

Putin's superyacht

[edit]

In September 2022 Dossier Center, which "tracks the criminal activity of various people associated with the Kremlin", said a group of Russian business figures led by Gennady Timchenko collected the €583 million needed to construct the 459 ft superyacht Scheherazade. The Dossier Center report didn't fully identify the other oligarchs involved, but it said that one of the offshore companies, High Definition – which donated $60 million – can be linked to Ziyavudin Magomedov.[15][68][69][70]

The funds were collected in 2014, and the yacht was constructed in a German shipyard, launching in July 2019. Multiple sources, including the Anti-corruption Foundation, claimed that it was presented as a Christmas gift to Russian President Vladimir Putin. These allegations were supported by evidence indicating that most of the yacht's crew members were affiliated with the Russian secret service.[15][16][71]

Despite this fact Magomedov and his ex-senator brother Magomed Magomedov were arrested. Even after Putin reportedly received the yacht, they remained behind bars, awaiting trial. In 2021, Timchenko, known as one of Vladimir Putin's closest allies, testified in court in support of the detained yacht donors, but this support did not lead to their release.[17][72][73][74][75][76][77]

Another superyacht for Putin's press secretary Dmitry Peskov

[edit]

In 2015 anti-corruption activist Alexey Navalny's group, Anti-Corruption Foundation, accused Dmitry Peskov, Vladimir Putin's longtime spokesman, of accepting a bribe to fund the rental of an expensive yacht during his honeymoon in the Mediterranean.[13][78][79] According to ACF, Peskov rented the famous 'Maltese Falcon,' a 260-foot yacht that at the time cost 385,000 euros ($426,000) per week. Navalny claimed that the money to pay for this fee came from Ziyavudin Magomedov.[14][80][81][82][83][84]

Mr.Magomedov later admitted to the Financial Times that he "liked talking to [Mr Peskov]", but denied paying for the yacht.[84]

Proximity to Putin's regime

[edit]

In 2002–2018 Ziyavudin Magomedov and his elder brother Magomed enjoyed close ties and even friendship with key figures of Vladimir Putin's regime. The list included:

Ziyavudin Magomedov accompanied by Dmitry Peskov, Putin's longtime press secretary, and Vladislav Surkov, the former main ideologist of the Kremlin.

The Magomedov brothers' proximity to the Putin regime manifested in other ways.

The Novorossiysk port, under the ownership of the Magomedovs, emerged as the primary sponsor of the Night Hockey League, in which Vladimir Putin himself participated. Magomed, the elder brother of Ziyavudin, even assumed the role of league's president.[10]

Additionally, Magomed Magomedov held a position on the board of trustees for the Russian Geographical Society. This society was presided over by Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu and chaired by Vladimir Putin personally. It played a role in shaping Russia's militaristic foreign policy. Magomed received a personal invitation to join the board of trustees from Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu.[85][86]

Genady Timchenko

[edit]

In September 2022 Dossier Center said that in 2014 Gennady Timchenko formed a group of Russian business figures to collect €583 million needed to construct the 459 ft superyacht Scheherazade. One of the offshore companies, High Definition – which donated $60 million – could be linked to Ziyavudin Magomedov.[15]

Timchenko expressed gratitude to the Magomedov brothers by attempting to act as a surety for them in court in 2021.

Timchenko asked the court to change the preventive measure for Magomedov to one not related to imprisonment under his guarantee.

"It seems to me that I have every reason to consider our relationship close, comradely, friendly. At one time, they, I mean the company, which, in particular, was also owned by Magomed Gadzhievich, actively helped the Night Hockey League, in which more than a thousand Russian teams play, and they did this for quite a long time, helped develop our hockey, in social In a sense, this is of great importance," Timchenko said.

He also stated that he could influence the arrested person. "I think I can say that yes, indeed, I can influence him as a senior comrade. In this sense, it seems to me that it is also in their, so to speak, national traditions to respect their elders. I remember this, it has always been," Timchenko said.

RBC, "Timchenko, who appeared in court, was denied bail for the former senator", 2021[17]

Nikolay Tokarev

[edit]

Many bankers and businessmen believe that, as with the 1990s oligarchs, Magomedov's rise and Summa's positioning for the next slice of assets may be dependent on its proximity to power. Magomedov is another with an uncanny ability to deal with Russia's power tandem. He forged close ties with Nikolai Tokarev, the current head of Transneft and a Putin ally from his KGB days in Dresden. But Magomedov also has very good relations with Medvedev officials too, including Arkady Dvorkovich, the deputy prime minister, with whom he studied at university.

Financial Times, "Russia: the politics of oligarchy 2.0", 2012 [2]

Vladimir Putin

[edit]

At first, the Valdai Club looked like a logical part of the Kremlin’s policy at the time: to charm the West with Putin, his openness and willingness to talk. Moreover, in the first years of the club’s work, Putin was clearly interested in communicating with the guests. However, the backstage life of the Valdai Club was already following the Kremlin’s favourite pattern. Money for the club’s work came from oligarchs and state companies close to the president. At various times, these included Sergei Chemezov, Putin’s KGB colleague and head of Rostec, Ziyavudin Magomedov, a now-disgraced businessman close to former President Dmitry Medvedev, companies of billionaires close to Putin – Alisher Usmanov, Viktor Vekselberg, Alexei Mordashov – as well as banks such as Alfa-Bank and state-owned Vnesheconombank (now VEB. RF) and VTB.

Proekt Media, "Advisory Board: A guide on Putin's experts", 2023 [87]

Sergey Lavrov

[edit]

From 2011 to 2014 Alexander Vinokurov, the son-in-law of Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, held the position of President at Summa Group.

Upon departing Summa to join the investment branch of Alfa Group, Vinokurov remained involved in various Summa projects, notably advising Ziyavudin Magomedov, the chairman of the board of directors, on the construction of the Zarubino port. Additionally, Vinokurov continued his roles on the boards of directors for Summa's major subsidiaries, including the Novorossiysk Commercial Sea Port (NCSP), United Grain Company (UZK), and Fesco.[88]

Presently Vinokurov is the largest shareholder in the retail company Magnit. Notably, on 9 March 2022 he was added to the EU Sanctions List for providing a substantial source of revenue to the government of the Russian Federation during the Russo-Ukrainian War.

Vladislav Surkov

[edit]

Ziyavudin Magomedov's wife Olga (maiden name Shipilova) maintained friendship and ran a joint business with Natalya Dubovitskaya, the spouse of Vladislav Surkov.

Among the Magomedovs’ "friends" are Patriarch Kirill, ex-Minister of Defense Anatoly Serdyukov, and head of Rostec Sergei Chemezov. Ziyavudin Magomedov's wife, Olga (maiden name Shipilova), is friends with and runs a joint business with the spouses of Dvorkovich and Surkov. She also maintains friendly relations with Dmitry Medvedev's press secretary, Natalia Timakova.

Sobesednik, "From Summa to Prison", 2018[66]

Night Hockey League

[edit]

Magomed Magomedov also became president of the Night Hockey League, where Mr Putin plays for fun with top officials and oligarchs, after NMTP took it over in 2016.

Financial Times, "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement", 2018[29]

In 2016, a significant milestone marked the careers of the Magomedov brothers: the Novorossiysk Commercial Sea Port (NCSP), under their ownership, became a sponsor of the Night Hockey League, in which Vladimir Putin actively participates. Even the southern-born Magomed had to don skates as he joined the team that played alongside the president, proudly wearing the number 88. "People in the hockey community noted, 'Everyone wants to sponsor the league where the president plays,'" they said at the time.

Sobesednik, "From Summa to Prison", 2018 [66]

Magomed Magomedov was friends with Sergei Shoigu. The latter, they say, will introduce him to the "Night Hockey League" — the official association of amateur hockey clubs whose games take place at night. It was founded in 2011 at the initiative of Vladimir Putin, who annually takes to the ice in the company of the current Defense Minister Shoigu, billionaires Arkady and Boris Rotenberg, Gennady Timchenko, and others. The athletic Magomedov quickly rose to become not just a player but, in the last years leading up to his arrest, the president of the executive board of the League. The Novorossiysk Commercial Sea Port, jointly owned by the Magomedovs and Transneft on a parity basis, became the main sponsor of the League.

Novaya Gazeta, "Summozakluchenie", 2022[52]

Political stance

[edit]

Before his arrest, Ziyavudin Magomedov never spoke out against the Putin regime and never condemned corruption in Russia. His business practices were also heavily criticized by prominent Russian opposition figures.

Vladimir Ashurkov, Executive director of the Anti-Corruption Foundation: «Ziyavudin Magomedov likely employed his business practices through rather unpleasant methods – criminal cases against counterparts, bribing judges, corrupt connections with officials. We have uncovered some of them in our investigations, such as Dmitry Peskov's trip on a yacht rented by the Magomedovs. Undoubtedly, what is happening to the Magomedovs is a selective application of the law. Is it a genuine a fight against corruption when some corrupt individuals are put behind bars because they happened to be weaker than other corrupt individuals? In my opinion, no».

Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, "The 'sum' of the Magomedovs' sins: who is imprisoning billionaires?", 2018 [89]

[edit]

After Navalny accused Mr. Magomedov of bribing Mr. Peskov, Ziyavudin sued the anti-corruption activist and won the trial. In a rather absurd ruling, the court declared the story false on a technicality, stating that Navalny's blog was anonymous. This decision was mocked by Navalny.

"I like talking to [Mr Peskov]," Mr Magomedov admits, but denies paying for the yacht or advocating for Mr Bilalov. Mr Magomedov won a court judgment declaring the story false on a technicality, after claiming that Mr Navalny's blog, which is one of Russia's most popular websites, was anonymous. Under Russia law, a court can rule anonymous comments are untrue without the plaintiff having to provide evidence. "Half the country knows it’s mine," Mr Navalny says. "Magomedov’s the only one who [pretends] he doesn’t."

Financial Times, "Ziyavudin Magomedov, Summa Group: hoping for a Moscow Hyperloop", 2016 [31]

MMA and Khabib Nurmagomedov

[edit]

In 2016 Ziyavudin bought MMA promotion Fight Nights Global and created the commercial company Eagles MMA for sponsoring MMA fighters.[90]

Ziyavudin also provided financial support to Khabib Nurmagomedov during the early stages of his career.[91] After winning the UFC lightweight title, Khabib, in a post-fight interview with Joe Rogan, switched to Russian and publicly asked Putin to release Ziyavudin. However, Putin, who usually favoured Nurmagomedov, ignored this appeal.[92][93][94]

Civic activities

[edit]

Magomedov's Summa Group financed the renovation of the Bolshoi Theatre, a project which had been pending since 2005. In 2007, Magomedov joined the Board of Trustees of the Bolshoi Theatre, with the Theatre reopening in autumn 2011.[95][56]

Magomedov also founded and financed the PERI Foundation which supports conservation and cultural heritage projects inside and outside of Russia. Projects PERI has worked on include the repair of the oldest mosque in Russia, the protection of ancient gravestones in Dagestan and the digitalisation of ancient Jewish manuscripts, in conjunction with the National Library of Israel.[96]

Mr Magomedov's Foundation has also funded a programme to develop IT and computing skills among young people in Dagestan and donated to dozens of orphanages and schools in the region.[97]

For his charitable activities, Magomedov had been awarded the Order of Friendship (2010),[98] Medal of Honour (2012) and Presidential Certificate of Merit (2012).[citation needed] He was stripped of these awards following his arrest.[99][100]

Arrest and imprisonment

[edit]

On 31 March 2018, while preparing to flee to the United States,[101] Magomedov was arrested and charged with "racketeering and embezzlement of state funds" by Russia's Ministry of Internal Affairs.

Magomedov denies the charges, but a Moscow court ruled on 31 March 2018 that he would remain in pre-trial custody, without bail, until 30 May 2018.[102][103][104] Magomedov remained in pre-trial custody until December 2022, when he and his brother were sentenced to 19 and 18 years in prison respectively.[105][106] He was incarcerated[37] in Lefortovo Prison, which the Federal Security Service uses as a maximum-security facility for members of political elite, including oligarchs,[107] former ministers,[108][109] and former senators charged with contracting murders.[110][111] The prison also detains high-profile hostages charged with espionage,[112] as well as former journalists and scientists charged with treason.[113][114] In February 2024, reports suggested that Magomedov had been "transferred to a penal colony in Kirov".[115]

While awaiting trial, the Russian courts froze numerous assets with a total value of several billion dollars, despite alleging $180 million in damages. These assets were subsequently confiscated by the Russian state, including a 32.5% stake in logistics group FESCO and $750 million held in an account at Sberbank.[116]

In March 2023, a ruling by the London Court of International Arbitration was revealed to have found that Magomedov's joint venture partner, Texas Pacific Group, exploited his incarceration and struck a secret deal to sell its interest in FESCO to Kremlin-linked businessman Mikhail Rabinovich.[117]

While in prison in Russia, Magomedov filed a $13.8bn legal claim in London's High Court alleging a Kremlin-led conspiracy to seize his assets.[37][38][39][40] The claim alleges that the Russian stated used his arrest to bring transportation group FESCO under the control of Rosatom, and that Transneft conspired to take his interest in NCSP. He alleges that US private equity firm TPG and Dubai-based ports operator DP World also participated in the conspiracy. The claim is one of the largest ever brought before the English High Court.[41]

Magomedov's imprisonment is believed to be part of an attempt by the Russian state to seize assets under his control, handing them to state entities such as Rosatom or Kremlin-affiliated businessmen[118][116] such as Mikhail Rabinovich.[117] It has been described as one of the highest-profile prosecutions of a Russian tycoon in years.[65]

Personal life

[edit]

Magomedov is married, with three children, and lived in Moscow prior to his arrest.[45]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Jailed oligarch accuses TPG of colluding with Kremlin to seize $14bn assets". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  2. ^ a b c "Russia: the politics of oligarchy 2.0". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  3. ^ a b "How Moscow arrested its latest billionaire, Ziyavudin Magomedov". Meduza. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g "Russia: Eyes on the prize". Financial Times. 3 July 2012. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  5. ^ "Summa Group". www.summagroup.ru. Retrieved 1 April 2018.
  6. ^ a b "Russia's transport assets: moving quickly". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  7. ^ a b "Ziyavudin Magomedov, Summa Group: hoping for a Moscow Hyperloop". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  8. ^ "Seller's market". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  9. ^ "Ex-Russian minister Mikhail Abyzov arrested on fraud charges". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  10. ^ a b c d e "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  11. ^ a b "Billionaire's arrest points to Kremlin power struggle". www.ft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  12. ^ Iosebashvili, Ira (1 July 2010). "The Wall Street Journal: 'Medvedev's Star Adviser. Arkady Dvorkovich has been charged with turning the Russian President's tough talk into action'". The Wall Street Journal.
  13. ^ a b c "Anti-corruption activist says Putin's spokesman accepted a 426-thousand-dollar bribe to rent a yacht". Meduza. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  14. ^ a b "Новые приключения молодожёна-чиновника: яхта Maltese Falcon за 26 млн рублей в неделю". Алексей Навальный. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  15. ^ a b c d e Tabahriti, Sam. "A superyacht linked to Vladimir Putin was a Christmas present from oligarchs, Russian opposition website claims". Business Insider. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  16. ^ a b "Новогодний подарок олигархов". Досье (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  17. ^ a b c "Пришедшему в суд Тимченко отказали в поручительстве за бывшего сенатора". РБК (in Russian). 29 November 2021. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  18. ^ "Warmongers under sanctions: Contributors to the War full list" (PDF). The Anti-Corruption Foundation.
  19. ^ "Warmongers under sanctions: Contributors to the war, subjects of ACF Investigations" (PDF). The Anti-Corruption Foundation.
  20. ^ "Together against Putin". Together against Putin (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  21. ^ "Russian tycoon Magomedov arrested on embezzlement charges". Reuters.
  22. ^ "Russia billionaire Ziyavudin Magomedov arrest over corruption, Vladimir Putin spokesman insists – CBS News". www.cbsnews.com. 2 April 2018. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  23. ^ "Kremlin Dismisses Any Political Link To Tycoon's Arrest". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. 2 April 2018. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  24. ^ "Akhmed Bilalov : Disgraced businessmen of the Russian government – Wattpad". www.wattpad.com. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  25. ^ "Akhmed Bilalov's Lawsuit" (PDF). Thomson Reuters.
  26. ^ "Премьера вывели из окружения. Как разгром компании "Сумма" и арест ее владельцев Магомедовых поможет Дмитрию Медведеву сохранить свою должность". Новая газета (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  27. ^ a b "Kemerovo. Switchmen punished, Magomedovs arrested, Moscow mayoral elections. Streamed on Apr 5, 2018. Timecode: 31:48 – 43:50". Navalny's YouTube Channel.
  28. ^ Seddon, Max (April 2018). "Billionaire's arrest points to Kremlin power struggle". Financial Times. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  29. ^ a b Seddon, Max (31 March 2018). "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement". Financial Times. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  30. ^ Seddon, Max (27 March 2019). "Ex-Russian minister Mikhail Abyzov arrested on fraud charges". Financial Times. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  31. ^ a b Seddon, Max (25 September 2016). "Ziyavudin Magomedov, Summa Group: hoping for a Moscow Hyperloop". Financial Times. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  32. ^ "Премьера вывели из окружения. Как разгром компании "Сумма" и арест ее владельцев Магомедовых поможет Дмитрию Медведеву сохранить свою должность". Новая газета (in Russian). Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  33. ^ Service, RFE/RL's Russian. "Former Russian Lawmaker And His Brother Handed Lengthy Prison Terms On Embezzlement Charges". RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  34. ^ "Мосгорсуд смягчил на полгода наказание братьям Магомедовым". TACC. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  35. ^ Мишина, Станислав Кучушев, Валерия (18 December 2023). "Сумма поменяется: почему братьям Магомедовым снизили сроки наказания". Известия (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  36. ^ Менибаева, Алсу (18 December 2023). "Мосгорсуд снизил сроки основателям группы "Сумма" братьям Магомедовым". Главные новости в России и мире – RTVI (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  37. ^ a b c Seddon, Max (27 September 2023). "Jailed oligarch accuses TPG of colluding with Kremlin to seize $14bn assets". Financial Times.
  38. ^ a b "Russian tycoon Magomedov launches $14 billion lawsuit in UK over port holdings". 27 September 2023 – via www.reuters.com.
  39. ^ a b Booth, James. "TPG hit with $14bn claim by jailed Russian oligarch over alleged conspiracy". www.fnlondon.com.
  40. ^ a b "Russian Tycoon Sues TPG, Rosatom From Moscow Jail for $13.8 Billion Over Conspiracy Claims". Bloomberg. 27 September 2023 – via www.bloomberg.com.
  41. ^ a b Tinson, Annabel (27 September 2023). "HSF defends in $13.8bn High Court claim brought by Russian businessman". The Lawyer | Legal insight, benchmarking data and jobs.
  42. ^ Vinogradov, Sergey (19 September 2012). "A port to withstand the storm". Retrieved 3 April 2018.
  43. ^ "Биография российского бизнесмена Зиявудина Магомедова – ТАСС". TACC. Retrieved 12 January 2024.
  44. ^ "Лентапедия: Магомедов, Зиявудин, Председатель совета директоров группы "Сумма"". Lenta.ru.
  45. ^ a b "Forbes profile: Ziyavudin Magomedov". Forbes. Retrieved 1 April 2018.
  46. ^ a b c "Премьера вывели из окружения. Как разгром компании "Сумма" и арест ее владельцев Магомедовых поможет Дмитрию Медведеву сохранить свою должность". Новая газета (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  47. ^ a b "Как братья Магомедовы складывали "Сумму"". Ведомости (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  48. ^ a b Seddon, Max (25 September 2016). "Ziyavudin Magomedov, Summa Group: hoping for a Moscow Hyperloop". Financial Times.
  49. ^ "Миллиардер Зиявудин Магомедов впервые рассказал о том, кто помогал ему создавать бизнес — Викиновости". ru.wikinews.org (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  50. ^ ""К финансовым потерям я всегда относился философски"". Ведомости (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  51. ^ "ВАС: "Сумма телеком" сама упустила частоты". Ведомости (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  52. ^ a b c d "Суммозаключение. История группы их компаний "Сумма" — пример новой реальности в России: вас больше не спасут ни добрые дела, ни дружба с властью". Новая газета Европа. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  53. ^ "Дела семейные. Как братья Магомедовы строили бизнес и к чему привела их ссора". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 26 July 2018. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  54. ^ "Ziyavudin Magomedov". www.summagroup.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 3 April 2018.
  55. ^ "UPDATE 1-Russia's Summa buys into the grain big league". Reuters. 2012. Retrieved 26 August 2017.
  56. ^ a b "Миллиард в клетке". newtimes.ru.
  57. ^ "Как братья Магомедовы складывали "Сумму"". Ведомости. 3 April 2018.
  58. ^ "Russia: Eyes on the prize". Financial Times. 3 July 2012.
  59. ^ "Короли госзаказа: спецпроект Forbes". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 1 March 2012. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  60. ^ "2012 Corruption Perceptions Index – Explore Russia's results". Transparency.org. 6 December 2012. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  61. ^ Соколов, Михаил (4 April 2018). ""Сумма" грехов Магомедовых: кто сажает миллиардеров?". Радио Свобода (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  62. ^ "Medvedev rejects Putin view on protests". Financial Times. 26 April 2012. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  63. ^ "Короли госзаказа — 2016: рейтинг Forbes". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 25 February 2016. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  64. ^ "Короли госзаказа — 2015: рейтинг Forbes". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 10 March 2015. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  65. ^ a b "Russian tycoon Magomedov arrested on embezzlement charges". 31 March 2018 – via www.reuters.com.
  66. ^ a b c "От "Суммы" до тюрьмы. История взлета и падения братьев Магомедовых". sobesednik.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  67. ^ "Ziyavudin Magomedov". Forbes.
  68. ^ "Расследователи назвали суперъяхту за $583 млн новогодним подарком Путину". Радио Свобода (in Russian). 7 September 2022. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  69. ^ "Construction of Putin's yacht Scheherazade cost nearly 600 million euros, Dosye reports". The Insider (in Russian). Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  70. ^ ""Досье": российские олигархи подарили Путину яхту "Шахерезада" за 583 млн евро на Новый год". Настоящее Время (in Russian). 7 September 2022. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  71. ^ Секрет Шехерезады. Яхта Путина за 75 000 000 000 ₽, 21 March 2022, retrieved 17 January 2024
  72. ^ "The Russian independent media writes about the 600-million-EUR yacht Putin got as a present and how a pro-war "patriot" made his fortune". www.veridica.ro. 12 September 2022. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  73. ^ "Timchenko, 2021: Speaking in defense of Magomed Magomedov".
  74. ^ "«Вы просто подписали или действительно вчитывались?» Миллиардер и друг Путина Геннадий Тимченко выступил в суде по делу братьев Магомедовых. И его неожиданно допросили как обычного гражданина". Meduza (in Russian). Retrieved 9 March 2024.
  75. ^ "Russian tycoon Gennady Timchenko, right, speaks with Chairman of the Board of Directors of Summa Group, a member of the Board of Trustees of the Bolshoi Theatre, Ziyavudin Magomedov, in the Kremli …". Las Vegas Review-Journal. Retrieved 9 March 2024.
  76. ^ "Суд отказал другу Путина Тимченко в поручительстве за совладельца группы «Сумма»". Главные новости в России и мире – RTVI (in Russian). 30 November 2021. Retrieved 9 March 2024.
  77. ^ "«Вы знаете, какая вас ждет ответственность?». Судья и прокуроры подвергли обструкции предпринимателя Геннадия Тимченко, осмелившегося выступить в суде поручителем за одного из братьев Магомедовых". Новая газета (in Russian).
  78. ^ "Vladimir Putin's spokesman honeymoons on board 'luxury yacht'". The Telegraph. 18 August 2015. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  79. ^ "Навальный рассказал, кто оплатил медовый месяц Пескова и Навки на самой дорогой яхте в мире". dp.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  80. ^ "Навальный нашел новые «доказательства» оплаты «яхты для Пескова»". РБК (in Russian). 26 August 2015. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  81. ^ "Навальный попросил ФСБ и Минюст США проверить отдых Пескова". РБК (in Russian). 24 August 2015. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  82. ^ "ФБК обвинил Пескова в получении взятки". Meduza (in Russian). Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  83. ^ "Суммозаключение. История группы их компаний «Сумма» — пример новой реальности в России: вас больше не спасут ни добрые дела, ни дружба с властью". Новая газета Европа. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  84. ^ a b Seddon, Max (25 September 2016). "Ziyavudin Magomedov, Summa Group: hoping for a Moscow Hyperloop". Financial Times. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  85. ^ "Президентский клуб: зачем миллиардеры опекают Русское географическое общество". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 5 August 2013. Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  86. ^ "Участники заседания Попечительского совета Всероссийской общественной организации "Русское географическое общество"". Президент России (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  87. ^ "Advisory Board: A guide on Putin's experts". Proekt Media.
  88. ^ "Президентом А1 стал экс-президент группы "Сумма" Александр Винокуров". Ведомости (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  89. ^ Соколов, Михаил (4 April 2018). ""Сумма" грехов Магомедовых: кто сажает миллиардеров?". Радио Свобода (in Russian). Retrieved 18 January 2024.
  90. ^ "Арестован главный спонсор Хабиба. 7 дней до боя Нурмагомедов – Фергюсон". matchtv.ru. April 2018. Retrieved 1 April 2018.
  91. ^ Открытие зала "Eagles MMA Moscow". Хабиб Нурмагомедов борется с Зиявудином Магомедовым., 28 April 2017, retrieved 19 January 2024
  92. ^ "Khabib asked Putin to come to oligarch's aid during UFC 223 post-fight interview".
  93. ^ "Нурмагомедов попросил Путина помочь задержанному совладельцу Fight Nights Global". www.championat.com (in Russian). Retrieved 17 January 2024.
  94. ^ UFC 223: Khabib Nurmagomedov Octagon Interview, 7 April 2018, retrieved 17 January 2024
  95. ^ "Russian tycoon Gennady Timchenko, right, speaks with Chairman of the Board of Directors of Summa Group, a member of the Board of Trustees of the Bolshoi Theatre, Ziyavudin Magomedov, in the Kremli …". Las Vegas Review-Journal.
  96. ^ Zion, Ilan Ben. "Russian Muslim tycoon funds digitizing Jewish manuscript collection". www.timesofisrael.com.
  97. ^ "Russian billionaires intend to invest in education". English vestion. 26 January 2017.
  98. ^ "Title". www.nmtp.info.
  99. ^ "Moscow court sentences Summa Group founder Ziyavudin Magomedov to 19 years in penitentiary". interfax.com.
  100. ^ "UK firm at heart of high-level fraud conviction in Russia". openDemocracy.
  101. ^ "Russian Billionaire Arrest Jolts Stocks, Fuels Cabinet Shake-Up Speculation". Bloomberg.com. 2 April 2018. Retrieved 3 April 2018.
  102. ^ Seddon, Max (31 March 2018). "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement". Financial Times. Archived from the original on 4 March 2023. Retrieved 1 April 2018.
  103. ^ Nikolskaya, Polina (31 March 2018). "Russian tycoon Magomedov arrested on embezzlement charges". Reuters. Retrieved 1 April 2018.
  104. ^ "Russian tycoon Magomedov to stay in pre-trial custody until May". U.S. Retrieved 3 April 2018.
  105. ^ Times, The Moscow (1 December 2022). "Russian Ex-Billionaire, Politician Brother Handed Lengthy Prison Terms for Fraud". The Moscow Times.
  106. ^ Service, RFE/RL's Russian. "Former Russian Lawmaker And His Brother Handed Lengthy Prison Terms On Embezzlement Charges". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.
  107. ^ "Абызов женился в "Лефортово" – ТАСС". TACC (in Russian). Retrieved 26 April 2024.
  108. ^ Sauer, Pjotr (24 April 2024). "Russian minister detained after taking bribe, law enforcement agency says". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 26 April 2024.
  109. ^ "Замглавы Минобороны Иванов помещен в СИЗО "Лефортово", жалоб у него нет". Interfax.ru (in Russian). 24 April 2024. Retrieved 26 April 2024.
  110. ^ Caucasus.Realities, RFE/RL's. "Former Russian Federation Council Member Rauf Arashukov Found Guilty Of Organizing Two Murders". RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty. Retrieved 26 April 2024.
  111. ^ "Экс-сенатор Арашуков и Абызов оказались в одной камере в СИЗО". Forbes.ru (in Russian). 14 February 2020. Retrieved 26 April 2024.
  112. ^ Forrest, Drew Hinshaw, Joe Parkinson and Brett. "'You Are Completely Alone': Inside the Infamous Russian Prison Holding Evan Gershkovich". WSJ. Retrieved 26 April 2024.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  113. ^ Times, The Moscow (27 February 2023). "Jailed Russian Journalist Safronov Says Moved to Siberian Prison". The Moscow Times. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
  114. ^ "Суд в Москве приговорил к 12 годам колонии 70‑летнего ученого Валерия Голубкина по делу о госизмене". Медиазона (in Russian). Retrieved 9 May 2024.
  115. ^ "Russian tycoon's 'anti-anti-suit injunction' succeeds as Transneft to face $14bn English claim". Yahoo Finance. 26 February 2024. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
  116. ^ a b "RUSSIA : Kremlin-backed oligarch operates Crimean railway from Gibraltar – 20/12/2022". Intelligence Online. 20 December 2022.
  117. ^ a b Harkavy, Rob. "CDR – Commercial Dispute Resolution". Arbitration,Litigation,Dispute Resolution | CDR Magazine.
  118. ^ Seddon, Max (31 March 2018). "Russian billionaire charged with embezzlement". Financial Times.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ziyavudin_Magomedov&oldid=1255577002"