With Ballot and Bayonet
With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers is a 1998 non-fiction book by Joseph Allan Frank, published by University of Georgia Press.[1]
Stephen V. Ash of University of Tennessee, Knoxville stated that despite the title, the book covers how preceding history had formed mindsets and that the actual topic "is considerably broader."[2]
Background
[edit]The author used diaries and letters,[2] from soldiers on both sides as sources.[3]
Contents
[edit]The book's discussion portions do not often classify soldiers by their intensity of political understanding, but the organization of sources does organize by intensity of political understanding.[3]
According to Ash, the book highlights how Confederate and Union soldiers had "similar" "minds" with "remarkably parallel" "beliefs".[2]
Reception
[edit]![[icon]](/wiki/File:Wiki_letter_w_cropped.svg){kind=small} | This section needs expansion. You can help by adding to it. (December 2023) |
Martin Crawford of University of Keele wrote that the subject is important,[3] and that researchers on the subject "will need to deal with" the book's content.[4] Crawford criticized "overblown" wording, "repetitive" statements,[3] and "one-dimensionally made" and "too insistently" done conclusions.[5]
Brian Dirck of Anderson University described the book as "sophisticated" and "scholarly",[6] and that it "is an important addition to this growing body of literature."[7] Dirck criticized how the work does not define what "conservative" and "liberal" mean, and he argued the book has "sometimes murky" organizing and style of writing.[7]
Mark Grimsley of Ohio State University argued that the "fundamental argument" is "sound", but that the book does not properly "demonstrate" it, with what Grimsley describes as wrongly conflating "racism" with "politics".[8]
References
[edit]- Ash, Stephen V. (1999). "Joseph Allan Frank. With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers. Athens: University of Georgia Press. 1998. Pp. ix, 304. $40.00". The American Historical Review. 104 (3): 911–912. doi:10.1086/ahr/104.3.911-a.
- Crawford, Martin (1999). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". The Georgia Historical Quarterly. 83 (3): 603–604. JSTOR 40584128.
- Dirck, Brian (1999). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers / Was Jefferson Davis Right?". The Journal of American History. 86 (2). Oxford University Press: 784–786. doi:10.2307/2567108. JSTOR 2567108. - Also available at ProQuest
- Grimsley, Mark (1999). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". Journal of Southern History. 65 (4): 884–885. doi:10.2307/2587624. JSTOR 2587624.
Notes
[edit]Further reading
[edit]- Brown, Canter (2000). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". The Florida Historical Quarterly. 78 (3): 373–375.
- McPherson, James M. (1999). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". The Journal of Military History. 63 (1): 186–188. doi:10.2307/120353. JSTOR 120353.
- Parish, Peter J (1999). "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". TLS. Times Literary Supplement: 3.
- "With Ballot and Bayonet: The Political Socialization of American Civil War Soldiers". The Virginia Quarterly Review. 75 (3): 81. 1999.