Wikipedia talk:Meetup/Black Lunch Table/Juneteenth Photo Challenge 2018

How to enter

Is this explanation clear to the relevant audience? The point about having an account does not say explicitly that anyone with a Wikipedia account already has a Commons account. The link for instructions goes directly to the Commons Upload Wizard, rather than to an explanation. The "details section" is recommended without any link. The injunction to "MESSAGE US IF YOU ARE CONFUSED" does not list the recommended ways to do that. Jim.henderson (talk) 12:48, 16 June 2018 (UTC)[reply]

Sorry, Jim.henderson. This was our first effort doing this. We were trying to be as brief and easy to do as possible and got lots of tips for next time. The link to the Commons Wizard should take new users to a page that prompts them to create an account and log in, no? The details section I was referring to is in the upload... the box that asks for "details" from them... I don't think that is possible to link to. The "message us" should provide a "talk" link to my page but maybe I should've been more explanatory and included other options? Thanks for your feedback!

--Heathart (talk) 13:44, 21 June 2018 (UTC)[reply]

Images

Hi all,

Great work on the photos. I've added a few to relevant Wikipedia articles (a few in English and one on the German Wikipedia). I've also nominated a few for Valued Image on Commons. They still need to be reviewed, but I will post here and on the relevant user pages if/when they are promoted. If anyone comes across these nomination pages, I'd urge you not to vote unless you've already been involved with the Valued Image process in the past (for COI reasons but also because it can be rather specific and doesn't quite operate like a vote).

I was going to also nominate this image from a previous event: File:Sam Vernon.jpg. Looking closer, however, I'm concerned that nominating it would attract some attention to a couple potential problems. Is Blacklunchtable, the uploader in that case, operated by a single person? Group accounts are not allowed on Wikipedia. If it is operated by a single person, is that person Noelle Theard (she looks to be credited in a category and whoever uploaded it said it's their own work). I ask that, being fairly certain it's not the case, in which case this file would need to be deleted for copyright reasons. If the uploader is not the owner of the copyright, the copyright owner would need to go through OTRS. In other words, permission to upload isn't sufficient on Commons (or on Wikipedia) -- a documented release needs to come from whoever owns it. I'm not saying I'm going to delete it or anything, but these are things to consider as any Commons user would be justified in deleting it/nominating it for deletion. If you'd rather discuss this stuff offline, let me know (and then feel free to remove this message). — Rhododendrites ^talk \\ 15:44, 21 June 2018 (UTC)[reply]

Update: The following 4 images have been recognized as Valued Images on Commons — Rhododendrites ^talk \\ 20:49, 26 June 2018 (UTC)[reply]

Simone Leigh
Kenyatta A.C. Hinkle
Junius Paul
Wardell Milan