Jump to content

Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2009-06-01/Arbitration report

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Arbitration report

The Report on Lengthy Litigation

The Committee amended the Ban Appeal Sub Committee procedure, providing that Arbitrators on the Committee shall be replaced monthly, rather than quarterly.

The Arbitration Committee opened no cases and closed one this week, leaving seven open.

Amended by motion

Evidence phase

  • A Man In Black: A case brought to examine the conduct of administrator A Man In Black.
  • ADHD: A case examining the dispute on the ADHD article and the conduct of the editors involved therein.

Voting

  • Obama articles: A case opened to review behavior of editors of articles related to Barack Obama.
  • Tang Dynasty: A case about editing conflicts on Inner Asia during the Tang Dynasty.
  • Mattisse: A case—brought when a recent Request for Comment failed to abate concerns regarding her behaviour—examining the conduct of User:Mattisse.
  • Macedonia 2: A case about naming disputes at the Macedonia article, and ChrisO's use of administrator tools in the dispute. Thirty-eight remedies have been proposed, most of which sanction editors involved in the dispute.
  • Date delinking: A case regarding the behavior of editors in the ongoing dispute relating to policy on linking dates in articles. An injunction has been issued prohibiting large-scale linking or delinking of dates until the case is resolved. Over 130 proposals have been presented, including remedies which restrict, ban, topic ban, or admonish certain parties. The case has only recently entered voting, and so none of the proposals presently pass.

Closed

  • Scientology: A case regarding behavioral problems in Scientology-related articles; the case is related to the prior case, COFS. Thirty-one remedies were passed, including the topic bans of twenty-six editors and the site bans of two editors, among other remedies. The Committee also provided that all IP addresses owned by the Church of Scientology are to be blocked as if they were open proxies. The full summary of remedies is available here. (See related story.)