Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject United States Public Policy/Assessment/Mike Christie

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Mike_Christie's PPI Assessment Page

[edit]

Mike_Christie - Wikipedia expert

Assessment 1, part 1

[edit]

The purpose of this evaluation in not to gauge variability in article quality, but to look at the metric itself. How consistent is this assessment tool? and Is there a difference in scores between subject area expert assessment and Wikipedian article assessment?

Note: these articles were all assessed on 25 or 26 September 2010.

  • Comprehensiveness - 1/10
  • Sourcing - 0/6
  • Neutrality - 0/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 4/26
  • Comprehensiveness - 5/10
  • Sourcing - 4/6
  • Neutrality - 3/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 1/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 16/26

James Q Wilson (1 July 2010)

[edit]
  • Comprehensiveness - 3/10
  • Sourcing - 1/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 9/26
  • Comprehensiveness - 1/10
  • Sourcing - 1/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 7/26
  • Comprehensiveness - 1/10
  • Sourcing - 0/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 1/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 0/2
  • Total - 4/26
  • Comprehensiveness - 4/10
  • Sourcing - 2/6
  • Neutrality - 1/3
  • Readability - 0/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 0/2
  • Total - 7/26

Fly America Act (1 July 2010)

[edit]
  • Comprehensiveness - 4/10
  • Sourcing - 0/6
  • Neutrality - 1/3
  • Readability - 0/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 0/2
  • Total - 5/26
  • Comprehensiveness - 5/10
  • Sourcing - 2/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 1/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 11/26


Assessment request 2

[edit]

All from 1 October 2010 or there abouts, there are a couple of rereviews, hopefully those will be fast.

Permanent residence (United States) (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 7/10
  • Sourcing - 3/6
  • Neutrality - 3/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 1/2
  • Formatting - 2/2
  • Total - 18/26

Great Society (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 6/10
  • Sourcing - 2/6
  • Neutrality - 3/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 1/2
  • Formatting - 2/2
  • Total - 16/26

Executive Order 11478 (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 2/10
  • Sourcing - 2/6
  • Neutrality - 3/3
  • Readability - 3/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 11/26

Homeland Security Act (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 1/10
  • Sourcing - 1/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 3/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 8/26

Public Citizen (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 3/10
  • Sourcing - 1/6
  • Neutrality - 1/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 1/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 9/26

War on Drugs ([http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=War_on_Drugs&oldid=389386037 assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 7/10
  • Sourcing - 3/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 1/2
  • Formatting - 2/2
  • Total - 17/26

Equal Access to COBRA Act (assessed version

  • Comprehensiveness - 1/10
  • Sourcing - 0/6
  • Neutrality - 3/3
  • Readability - 3/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 8/26

Fly America Act (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 3/10
  • Sourcing - 0/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 2/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 8/26

Universal health care (assessed version)

  • Comprehensiveness - 5/10
  • Sourcing - 2/6
  • Neutrality - 2/3
  • Readability - 1/3
  • Illustrations - 0/2
  • Formatting - 1/2
  • Total - 11/26