Wikipedia:WikiProject Scottish Islands/Assessment/Archive 1
 | This is an archive of past discussions on Wikipedia:WikiProject Scottish Islands. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current main page. |
| Archive 1 |
- Waulking song Banner removed. Very marginal to project. (<-How?)
- North Berwick Harbour (because of Fidra etc - see article. put "low importance", but not sure of quality) Banner removed. Very marginal to project. I have no intention of arguing over this, but I just don't think it is relevant.
- Caittil Find start/low (done stub -> start, has some decent ref.s)
- Conall mac Comgaill stub/low (done)
- Áedán mac Gabráin FA/mid
- Fishing industry in Scotland B/High (
lacks banner) - Scottish Fisheries Protection Agency B/High (
lacks banner) - Football at the Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 1989 Island Games stub/low (done)
- Football at the 1991 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 1993 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 1995 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 1997 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 1999 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 2003 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 2005 Island Games start/low (done)
- Football at the 2007 Island Games start/low (done)
- Isle of Skye Music Festival start/mid
- Gavin Maxwell class=start|importance=mid Could make B class with a little tidying up.
- Inchmahome Priory class=start|importance=mid
- Sir John Macpherson, 1st Baronet start/mid
- Daniel Macmillan stub/low
- Flora MacDonald (Scottish Jacobite) start/mid
- William Lever, 1st Viscount Leverhulme start/mid
- Gulf of Corryvreckan start/high
- William Balfour Baikie start/high ?copyvio
- Arthur Anderson (businessman) start/low
- Threave Castle B/low
- Shetland official football team start/low
- Knock Castle (Isle of Skye) stub/Mid
- Hugh Marwick, OBE (fairly notable IMO) stub/mid
- Gills Bay (Caithness, ferry terminal) stub/low
- Earl's Palace, Kirkwall stub/Mid
- Dunvegan Castle stub/Mid
- Duntulm Castle stub/low
- Cunninghame start/low
- Calgary, Mull stub/low
- Castle Tioram start/low
- When Eight Bells Toll start/low
- When Eight Bells Toll (1971 film) stub/low. Comments left
- Lerwick and Bressay Parish Church stub/low
- Ayre (landform) stub/mid
- Fionnlagh MacCailein B/low
- Sigurd Magnusson class=start importance=low
- Oban (because of ferries) start/mid
- Compton Mackenzie (one time owner of Shiants, writer of Whisky Galore, buried Barra) class=start|importance=high
- John of Islay, Earl of Ross B/mid
- Uí Ímair stub/low
- List of Kings of Dál Riata B/Mid
- Nidaros (Archbishopric of the North Atlantic) B & mid
- Treaty of Perth class=stub importance=High
- Godfred VI of the Isle of Man class=start importance=low
- Battle of Largs B & High
- Magnus III of the Isle of Man class=stub importance=low
- Harald I of the Isle of Man class=stub importance= mid
- Olaf II of the Isle of Man class=start importance=mid
- Dubgall mac Somairle class=start importance=mid
- Donnchadh of Argyll class=B importance=mid
- Guðbrandur Vigfússon class=start importance=low
- Clan MacDougall class=B importance= mid
- Alexander III of Scotland class=B importance=top
- Aonghas Mór of Islay ("Mòr" would be current Gàidhlig) class=B importance=top
- Margaret, Maid of Norway class=B importance=high
- Magnus VI of Norway class=start importance=high
- Hákonar saga Hákonarsonar class=stub importance=mid
- Haakon IV of Norway class=B importance=Top
- Lady Isle (reassessment please) re-assessed to B class and mid.
- Point, Outer Hebrides class=start|importance=mid
- Castle Stalker class=start|importance=mid
- Westray promoted to B. Importance downgraded to high- not that well-known an island.
- Vaila promoted to Start. Brief comment added to banner
- Wyre promoted to Start. Comments per others
- Burray promoted to B - with comments
- Papa Stronsay Start. No comments added, but similar to Burray
- Papa Westray Start - comments left
- South Walls promoted to Start. Comments are pretty much per Burray and P Westray
- Stronsay remains Start although moving in the right direction. Comments left.
- Literature of Shetland class-start importance-top
- Muckle_Flugga class-start importance- mid
- Hebridean Celtic Festival Done
- Lewis and Harris Football League Done
- Skye Camanachd Done
- Lewis Camanachd Done
- Crofters' Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886 Done
- Bishop of Argyll Done
- Bishop of Orkney Done
- Bishop of the Isles Done
- Kingdom of Mann and the Isles Done
- The Edge of the World class=Start|importance=mid
- Battle of May Island (sic) class=B( just) |importance=Mid
- Lismore, Scotland class=start|importance=High
- List of Marilyns on Scottish islands B
- List of Orkney islands Done
- List of Shetland islands B
- Balfour, Orkney Reviewed - class=Start importance=Mid
- Lunga, Firth of Lorn. Reviewed. Rated A-class.
- Rockall Ah, one for Mr. Lurker I beleive. BM. I've given it a "B". The article is a good length and is well-written in places, but needs a lot of cleaning up- uncited assertions and trivia should be dealt with. Lurker (said · done) 09:55, 13 August 2007 (UTC)