Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/News/July 2016/Book reviews
|
The Australian Imperial Force - Jean Bou and Peter Dennis |
- By Nick-D
The Australian Imperial Force is the fifth and final volume of the Australian semi-official history produced to mark the centenary of the First World War. It provides an organisational history of the First Australian Imperial Force (AIF), the main Australian force of the war which saw extensive combat in Gallipoli, France and the Middle East, and was jointly written by veteran historian Peter Dennis and up-and-comer Jean Bou.
The book doesn't cover the battles the AIF took part in (these are addressed by other volumes in the series) and instead describes and analyses the factors which underpinned the performance of the force. It is organised into thematic chapters on the AIF's organisation, manpower, service conditions, social history and legacy. Overall, this approach works well. Bou and Dennis cover a lot of ground, and provide first-rate analysis of a remarkable range of topics. This analysis is supported by excellent maps, charts and tables. For my mind, the most important conclusion they reach is that the AIF was over-expanded and somewhat over-committed, though simply treating this much-mythologised part of Australian history as an organisation is a significant step forward, which will hopefully encourage more hard-headed analysis by other historians.
Despite these positives, I was a little bit disappointed by the book. The main shortfall is that despite its high cost ($A60), it only runs to 192 pages. As a result, no topics are really treated in depth, and The Australian Imperial Force falls short of its ambition to provide a definitive reference. This is a common failing of this series, and seems somewhat inexplicable given the otherwise very high standard of its volumes. I personally would have particularly liked to see more detail on how the AIF was trained and retrained throughout the war, and I'm sure that other readers will have similar reactions on their topics of interest.
Overall, The Australian Imperial Force is a fine work, and will be of great value to editors working on the histories of the Australian Army and Australia's contribution to the First World War. It's just a shame that cost-cutting or compressed timelines ended up selling its content somewhat slightly short.
Publishing details: Bou, Jean; Dennis, Peter (2016). The Australian Imperial Force. The Centenary History of Australia and the Great War. Volume V. South Melbourne: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195576801.
Recent external reviews |
Stevens, David (2014). In All Respects Ready: Australia's Navy in World War One. South Melbourne: Oxford University Press Australia. ISBN 0195578589.
- Stice, Elizabeth (June 2016). "David Stevens. In All Respects Ready: Australia's Navy in World War One". H-Net Reviews. H-Net Humanities & Social Sciences Online.
Lynch, Marc (2016). The New Arab Wars: Uprisings and Anarchy in the Middle East. New York City: PublicAffairs. ISBN 161039609X.
- Fisher, Ian (10 June 2016). "'The New Arab Wars,' by Marc Lynch". The New York Times.
McDonough, James Lee (2016). William Tecumseh Sherman: In the Service of My Country: A Life. New York City: W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 0393241572.
- Ricks, Thomas E. (15 June 2016). "'William Tecumseh Sherman,' by James Lee McDonough". The New York Times.
Yenne, Bill (2016). When Tigers Ruled the Sky. The Flying Tigers: American outlaw pilots over China during World War II. Berkley. ISBN 9780425274194.
- Wilson, David (28 June 2016). "Book review: When Tigers Ruled the Sky vividly evokes Flying Tigers' war with Japan". South China Morning Post.
|
