Wikipedia:WikiProject EastEnders/Operation: Cleanup
Appearance
This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
Key for comments:
- (T) = Trampikey
- (F) = Frickative
- (G) = Gungadin
Present characters
[edit]Article | Assessment/comments | Creation? | Development? | Reception? | Plot length OK? | All tasks completed? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ian Beale | Needs a lot more on character development, plot could do with condensing. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Dot Branning | Majorly needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Pat Butcher | Needs character development and reception sections. Plot could do with condensing as well. (T) A lot of plot detail has recently been added to backstory, and while I think it's written well etc., the prior version possibly told the story adequately (G) I condensed the plot quite a bit (G) |
|||||
Ricky Butcher | Character development needs finishing (stuff about the return etc.) (T) | (incomplete) | ||||
Phil Mitchell | Character development could be updated to include recent Stella stuff. Plot needs condensing, particularly recent stuff. (T) Did some plot condensing. It's still rather huge though. The 200 to present stuff is the most excessive.(G) | (out of date) | ||||
Peggy Mitchell | Character development incomplete. (T) | (incomplete) | ||||
Bianca Jackson | I can't see anything wrong with it. (T) This one's a really excellent article, I think. The lead - as is the case with a lot of these - just needs expanding a bit so as to summarise the whole article, but beyond that, all I'd say is, with the OOU development bits so long, the storylines section in some places is a little bit repetitive of what's already been said - though really that just makes it easier to trim down a touch. It's definitely the best referenced thus far, and while a lack of references isn't necessarily that stands against GA noms, especially in the case of earlier characters for whom there are naturally less available, I'd say this one with a small bit of work would be an excellent nom. (F) |
|||||
Lucy Beale | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Peter Beale | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Ben Mitchell (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. It won't be hard to find sources about the Stella storyline or Charlie Jones's awful acting. (T) | |||||
Suzy Branning | Needs character development and reception sections. (T) | |||||
Billy Mitchell (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. It won't be hard to find sources about the Down's syndrome storyline (some of which could be lifted from Honey's article). "Homelessness" section needs condensing. (T) Started all OOU section, though all need much extending. Condensed storyline, may need more (G) | (incomplete) | (incomplete) | |||
Liam Butcher | Needs out of universe information. 2008 stuff needs condensing as he hasn't actually done anything. (T) | |||||
Charlie Slater | Needs out of universe information. Could do with condensing also. (T) | |||||
Garry Hobbs | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Mo Harris | Creation and evelopment needs expanding. (T) | (very little) | (very little) | |||
Patrick Trueman | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Minty Peterson | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Bobby Beale | Needs out of universe information, which will be a killer to find references for. (T) | Not applicable | Not applicable | |||
Yolande Trueman | Needs creation section and any stuff we can find about development before stuff covered in "Departure" section. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Jane Beale | Needs character creation section, plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Darren Miller | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Stacey Branning | Development section needs finishing with stuff on the Stax reveal and reception section needs expanding. (T) | (incomplete) | (needs more) | |||
Jean Slater | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. Stuff about bipolar storyline/the award should be easy to find. (T) | |||||
Dawn Swann | Needs a development section, which shouldn't be too hard with stuff from the Summer storyline. Also needs reception section. (T) | |||||
Bradley Branning | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Chelsea Fox | Needs development and reception sections. (T) | |||||
Denise Wicks | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Libby Fox | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. (T) Plot condensed, reception added (G) | |||||
Max Branning | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Tanya Branning | Needs creation section, more development and plot condensing. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Abi Branning | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Lauren Branning | Needs reception section, which will probably be easy to write after the Tony storyline. (T) | |||||
Sean Slater | Needs reception section and plot condensing. (T) Condensed storylines. (F) |
|||||
Janet Mitchell | Doesn't need a development section as she's only a baby. (T) | Not applicable | ||||
Shirley Carter | Needs development and reception sections and possibly more creation stuff. (T) | (may need more) | ||||
Jay Brown | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing, needs to be rewritten in parts as it seems a bit like a list of events. Stuff about stabbing storyline and Jase's death will be good for development section. (T) | |||||
Heather Trott | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Zainab Masood | Needs reception section. Development may be hard to do at the moment. (T) | |||||
Shabnam Masood | Needs reception section and plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Roxy Slater | Could do with a proper reception section. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Ronnie Mitchell | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Tamwar Masood | Could do with more development and a reception section, which would both be hard as he's hardly done anything. (T) Reception added, though some of it could be added to development (G) | (very little) | ||||
Vinnie Monks | Could do with development and reception, stuff about exit etc. There must be some stuff about reception with Bobby Davro being well known before joining. (T) | |||||
Masood Ahmed | Could do with development and a reception sections, which would both be hard as he's hardly done anything. (T) | |||||
Jack Branning | Needs major plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Christian Clarke | Could do with a proper reception section, there must be more stuff about him being the only gay in Walford and his "relationship" with Steven. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Whitney Dean | Needs more development (sources on talk page) and a reception section. (T) Expanded creation & development, added reception section and condensed storylines a bit. [1] Development's a fair length, but there's plenty of Tony stuff that could still be added in from various Coghill interviews etc. (F) |
|||||
Morgan Jackson-King | May need merging, out of universe information will be a killer to do, let alone a reception section. A creation section may be doable, as it could mention Bianca's return etc. (T) | Not applicable | Not applicable | |||
Tiffany Dean | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Lucas Johnson | Needs out of universe information, plot also too long for barely any screen time. (T) | |||||
Jordan Johnson (EastEnders) | Possibly merge as out of universe stuff is gonna be a bitch to find. (T) | |||||
Brenda Boyle | Possibly merge as out of universe stuff is gonna be a bitch to find. (T) | |||||
Archie Mitchell | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Callum Monks | Character development could be covered with the Stacey storyline, reception section needed. (T) | |||||
Danielle Jones (EastEnders) | Bit too early for development, reception section is needed. (T) Added development section, separated casting and reception. All a bit short but still comprehensive considering how new she is. (F) |
|||||
Tony King | The talk page references (especially the Guardian one) are begging to be harvested and go into great detail foir the character development section. Reception section is easily done because of the complaints, and there must be critics who've written about the storyline. If we do it right, this has the potential to be a great article. (T) | |||||
Totals | = 33 = 24 |
= 24 = 29 |
= 17 = 38 |
= 39 = 18 |
Former characters (by last appearance)
[edit]1980s
[edit]Article | Assessment/comments | Creation? | Development? | Reception? | Plot length OK? | All tasks completed? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reg Cox | Could a reception section be done? There may be something seeing as EE started with such a grim discovery. (T) | Not applicable | ||||
Hassan Osman | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Saeed Jeffery | Needs reception section. (T) | |||||
Andy O'Brien (EastEnders) | Needs reception section and more development if possible. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Cassie Carpenter | Needs out of universe information and has a trivia section. Eek. (T) | |||||
Roy Quick | Needs out of universe information. Possibly merge? (T) | |||||
Naima Jeffery | Needs reception section and more development if possible. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Kelvin Carpenter | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) | |||||
Tony Carpenter | Needs reception section and more development if possible. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Debbie Wilkins | Needs reception section and more development if possible. Plot could do with a bit of reduction. (T) | (very little) | (nearly there) | |||
Hannah Carpenter | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Kenny Beale | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Magda Czajkowski | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Lofty Holloway | Needs reception section. (T) | |||||
Tom Clements (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Angie Watts | Needs reception section and storylines condensing. (T) The plot could use a bit of trimming down before nominating, but I think the main thing a GA review of this article would pick up on would be the lack of a 'Reception' section. The end of the 'Development' section could certainly be split off into one, but I think unless that was expanded upon, a GA reviewer would probably question whether the article was sufficiently broad in scope. (F) |
|||||
Annie Smith (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. Possibly merge? (T) | |||||
Mary Smith | Needs reception section and more development if possible. Plot needs reduction. |
(very little) | ||||
Darren Roberts (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Lou Beale | Needs a proper reception section and may need more character development. (T) | (very little) | (needs more) | |||
Chris Smith (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information and has a trivia section! (T) | |||||
Joanne Francis | Needs character development and reception sections. (T) | |||||
Duncan Boyd | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
David Samuels (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Benny Bloom | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Brad Williams (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information and could do with some plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Junior Roberts | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Carmel Jackson | Can't see anything wrong with this article at the moment. (T) I think this is an excellent example of an article being broad in scope and coverage despite a limited number of sources available. Maybe cut down the level of detail in the 'Domestic violence' subsection, and tighten up the prose a touch (for instance, in the lead: "After six months of suffering, she wisely left him." isn't the most encyclopedic way of expressing that) but all in all, I think this would be another good nom. (F) |
|||||
Matthew Jackson | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Barry Clark | Reception is mixed in with creation and development. Would be handy to have it as a definitive section. Plot is a bit long. (T) I'd tighten the storylines section up a little bit - I think this is the shortest one so far, but it still weighs in at pushing 1500 words. I think this one lends itself quite neatly into splitting up to add a 'Reception' section using the stuff that's already there in 'Development', and with that done I'd say this would be my first GA nom suggestion thus far. (F) |
|||||
Gregory Mantel | Needs out of universe information. Some sources on talk page. Possibly merge? (T) | |||||
Guido Smith | Needs out of universe information and has a trivia section! (T) | |||||
Colin Russell (EastEnders) | Reception is mixed in with creation and development and plot is too long. (T) | |||||
Donna Ludlow | Needs out of universe information and plot condensing. (T) | |||||
Guizin Osman | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Mehmet Osman | Needs reception section. (T) | |||||
Sue Osman | Needs more development and reception section. Plot is too long. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Ali Osman | Needs more development and reception section. Plot is too long. Has a trivia section! (T) I think at pushing 1600 words, the plot on this one could do with a bit of trimming before taking it to GA. The lead needs fleshing out a bit, and with just two references once you discount the trivia piece (which would need to be integrated into the body of the article or just discounted on the grounds of being a bit crufty) it wouldn't be my first suggestion to nominate as is. (F) |
(needs more) |
1990s
[edit]Article | Assessment/comments | Creation? | Development? | Reception? | Plot length OK? | All tasks completed? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Paul Priestly | Needs reception section. Could do with some plot reduction. (T) | (nearly there) | ||||
Trevor Short | Needs reception section and some plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Sufia Karim | Needs out of universe information and plot expansion. (T) | (too short) | ||||
Ashraf Karim | Needs out of universe information and may need some plot condensing. (T) | (nearly there) | ||||
Danny Whiting | Needs out of universe information and some plot reduction. (T) | (nearly there) | ||||
Vince Johnson | Needs reception section. (T) | |||||
Marge Green | Needs creation and development which is easy as it would be the same as Vince, Laurie, Paul, Trevor and Julie's. Needs more reception. (T) | (needs more) | ||||
Rod Norman | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Mo Butcher | Needs out of universe information and plot expansion. (T) | (too short) | ||||
Simon Wicks | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Eddie Royle | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Charlie Cotton | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Disa O'Brien | Needs out of universe information. Also needs a picture. (T) | |||||
Gill Fowler | Needs out of universe information and plot expansion. The HIV/AIDS storyline must have caused loads of controversy to write about! (T) | (too short) | ||||
Lloyd Tavernier | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
James Willmott-Brown | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction. Rape storyline would be easy to write an OOU section about. (T) | |||||
Christine Hewitt | Needs character creation and development and more reception. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Kofi Tavernier | Reception section would be a bitch so I'm saying not applicable! (T) | Not applicable | ||||
Clyde Tavernier | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Celestine Tavernier | Needs out of universe information. (T) | |||||
Rachel Kominski | Needs out of universe information and plot expansion. (T) | (too short) | ||||
Pete Beale | Needs more character development and a reception section. Plot is way too long. (T) | (very little) | ||||
Aidan Brosnan | Needs a reception section. (T) |
2000s
[edit]Article | Assessment/comments | Creation? | Development? | Reception? | Plot length OK? | All tasks completed? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pauline Fowler | Featured article. (T) | |||||
Joe Macer | Needs reception section and plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Sonia Fowler | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Martin Fowler (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information about as much as Dot does (a lot!) and needs MAJOR plot reduction. High priority. (T) | |||||
Rebecca Miller (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information - can we get anything from the baby snatching storyline in 2002? Needs major plot reduction. (T) | |||||
Naomi Julien | Needs out of universe information - there must be stuff about the lesbian storyline. (T) | |||||
Harold Legg | Needs reception section and a bit of plot reduction. (T) | (nearly there) | ||||
Rob Minter | Needs out of universe information and plot reduction (T) | |||||
Li Chong (EastEnders) | Needs out of universe information. Possible merge? (T) | |||||
Stella Crawford | Wow, this article is bad. There are no character development or reception sections for a character who made such an impact and would be really easy to write about, it has an unreferenced "Personality" section, which basically amounts to original research, and has a ridiculously long plot for a character who was on screen for less than a year. It's bad because it has such potential to be a great article. High priority. (T) | |||||
Kevin Wicks | Way too much plot info. Few sources and development. (G) Plot condensed (G) | |||||
Carly Wicks | Way too much plot info. Few sources and development. (G) plot condensed {G) | |||||
Deano Wicks | Plenty of OOU and sources can be added. (G) | |||||
Diane Butcher | Needs more reception if we can find it, particularly from early stuff. A little plot reduction on her recent return for Frank's funeral too (G) | (needs more) | (nearly there) |
Awards
[edit]Character articles to edit w/award wins & nominations (This list was created in July 2009. Any awards given after that date may not be included in articles marked as done, and some articles may not be listed here if there were no awards or nominations for that character before July 2009.)