Wikipedia:WikiProject Brazil/Peer review
|
 Welcome to the WikiProject Brazil, a WikiProject created to better organize, coordinate, expand, and present information in articles related to Brazil. Our mission is to develop and improve all Brazil-related articles in order to make Wikipedia an accurate and reliable resource for Brazil-related information. If you would like to help, please consider join us or inquire on the talk page. For more information about WikiProjects, please see Wikipedia:WikiProject and Wikipedia:WikiProject best practices. I've listed this article for peer review because the article deals with an important (and controversial) event in the Cold War and Latin American history, and needs to be brought up to good standards. I would like feedback on possible room for expansion (questions which are unclear to a third-party audience), dealing with RS (it relies heavily on one author, for example) and potential stylistic issues. Basically: if you're not Brazilian, and you're reading this article, what would you be interested in reading about in this moment in history and how do you think the article can better help you understand it? After recently gaining WP:Good Article status, I've listed this article for peer review before nominating it for Feature Article candidate, as the reviewer recommended. So far I have only received feedback on format related issues. Because the article deals with an important Brazilian development, considered by many a successful policy on sustainable transport, even a landmark case for other tropical developing countries to replicate, but criticized and controversial for some environmentalists, I really would like feedback from editors familiar with the Brazilian context or with alternative or clean fuels, and particularly, please point out any significant omission or just make suggestion for improvements. Thanks. --Mariordo (talk) 05:50, 21 March 2009 (UTC) I've listed this article for peer review because it deals with important demographic issues, but is quite amateurish, supports some memes, and practically no one edits there, making it a case of possible violation of WP:OWNERSHIP. Thanks, Donadio 21:51, 3 September 2007 (UTC) I've listed this article for peer review because I think it has some doubtful things. Brazil Colonial is a name created for a period of Brazil history. But I don't know exactly how official or informal were other names used in the article: Colony of Brazil, Viceroyalty of Brazil, Principality of Brazil and State of Brazil. In short, this matter lacks references. Thanks
|