Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/June 2014 Backlog Elimination Drive/JordanKyser22

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Checked reviews

[edit]
  1. (Declined) Draft:Kkr irfaan (Deleted Revision)
     Pass - test page Mz7
  2. (Declined) Draft:Turntable Kitchen
     Fail - The submission has sufficient context to identify the subject. I'm not sure what you mean when you say you need "3 headings". The core issue with the submission, in my opinion, is the notability of the subject. Mz7
     Fail - WP:LAYOUT is not criteria to decline a draft. Declining this draft because of "context" is patently false. This submission looks to pass GNG to me, so you should have accepted it. Chris troutman
  3. (Declined) Draft:Enchanted (book)
     Fail - The submission has sufficient context to identify the subject. You should only use that decline reason if you truly can't tell what the article is about by reading the article. For example: "He is a funny man with a red car." Mz7
     Fail - You should be accepting or declining on notability and verifiability, not context. Chris troutman
  4. (Accepted) Leadfinger
     Fail - Fails WP:NBAND; a single mention in The Courier-Mail doesn't pass WP:GNG. Chris troutman
  5. (Accepted) Draft:International Ballet
     Pass - Chris troutman
  6. (Declined) User:João Horta Belo/sandbox
     Pass - Chris troutman