Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/June 2014 Backlog Elimination Drive/Darylgolden

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Checked reviews

[edit]
  1. (Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Mobile Spy
     Pass - Article not perfect at time of move, but acceptable and has since been approved SuperHamster
  2. (Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Birdnet.cn
     Pass - Good use of comment to specify problem SuperHamster
  3. (Declined) Draft:GuruAid
     Pass - Good use of comment to specify problem SuperHamster
  4. (Accepted) Draft:Joel Ward
     Pass - SuperHamster
  5. (Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Como Brothers Band
     Pass - Hewhoamareismyself
  6. (Declined) Draft:Mechanics and Farmers Bank
     Pass - I hope I would have added a bit more than your brief comment, perhaps an example top show the route forward. But I may not have done Timtrent
  7. (Declined) Draft:Oconomowoc Lake Club
     Pass - ThaddeusB
  8. (Accepted) Draft:Kevin Morris (author)
     Pass - ThaddeusB
  9. (Declined) Draft:Ian Walker (sports writer and screenwriter)
     Pass - ThaddeusB
  10. (Declined) Draft:Farhad Shahnawaz
     Fail - The decline reason (NN referencing the fact that only The Hindu sources were present) was wrong - the coverage was reliable, indepth, and over several years. The fact it was all from the same publication was irrelevant. ThaddeusB
  11. (Declined) Draft:This Wild Life
     Fail - The decline reason (only 1 in depth source) was wrong as several of the sources are in depth. Are they all reliable? I'm not sure, but Alternative Press covering the band many times combined with the other coverage should be enough to pass ThaddeusB