Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/June 2014 Backlog Elimination Drive/Acalycine

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Checked reviews

[edit]
  1. (Declined) User:JackKelly'sGranddaughter/John B. "Jack" Kelly Senior, publisher and "PR Man" for President Theodore Roosevelt
     Pass - potentially interesting article.... but no sources at all 78.26
  2. (Declined) Draft:ITiffin
     Pass - clearly promotional 78.26
  3. (Declined) Draft:First Comic News
     Pass - blogs and such 78.26
  4. (Declined) Draft:ISKCON Ipoh
     Pass - SuperHamster
  5. (Declined) Jen Selter
     Fail - Moved to mainspace right after review; some sources are a bit iffy, but article was declined for notability when subject has fairly significant coverage from Fox, Vanity Fair, People, etc. SuperHamster
     Fail - Failed for notability but subject had received significant media attention in references. Now in mainspace. Bellerophon
  6. (Declined) Draft:Oconomowoc High School Volleyball
     Pass - Subject not notable as a typical high school volleyball team, and declined as such SuperHamster
  7. (Declined) Draft:Clipix
     Pass - SuperHamster
  8. (Declined) Draft:Syed Ahmed Ali Khan
     Pass - Subject not notable, and declined for such SuperHamster
  9. (Declined) Draft:Kyle Mack
     Pass - However the lack of a commentary on why you have blanked it does not help the author Timtrent
  10. (Declined) Draft:Rita Singha
     Pass - Bellerophon
  11. (Declined) Draft:AfterShock 26 (musical group)
     Pass - ThaddeusB
  12. (Declined) Draft:Alexey Shipenko
     Fail - The German Wikipedia article (linked in draft) appears to show notability and two likely RS were provided in draft, so more explanation was required if declining as NN ThaddeusB
  13. (Declined) User:Piyush00707/sandbox
     Pass - ThaddeusB
  14. (Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Hassan Esmail-Beygui
     Pass - Possibly notable, but impossible to tell based on provided references, so correct decline ThaddeusB
  15. (Declined) Draft:Saundarya Rajesh
     Fail - Declined based on lack of references, but almost entire article is referenced and most of the sources are clearly reliable. At minimum, more explanation that generic template was required. ThaddeusB