Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Machu Picchu
Could I get comments on quality and chances at FPC? I'm not sure if this image can pass FPC or not, and would like to hear a few opinions before writing up a caption and reasons for nom. Thanks.
Appears in Machu Picchu
Created by Allard Schmidt (no link provided on image info page)
Comments:
- This is certainly a very nice image, and it's very valuable to the encyclopdia, making good contributions to several articles. However, I'm afraid it is unlikely to become a featured picture. For one thing, the sky is "blown" -- it's completely white, and contains no information. For another, the walls and the grass are not sharp at any resolution. The image is certainly large enough, and I love it. I'm not sure whether or not I would vote for it at FP, but I suspect it would not be promoted as a featured picture. I honestly don't think there is anything to be done to make the image better. Enuja (talk) 18:34, 25 October 2007 (UTC)
Seconder: