Wikipedia:Picture peer review/BungyViewCairns
Photo taken by me, currently appears in Bungee jumping. While I feel it does give a good feeling of height, I am unsure whether it would look better with the platform removed, (rotated and cropped), or whether it's unsuitable as it's too far from the perspective of the jumper (which no photo editing can fix!)
- Nominate and support. - MartinRe 09:46, 6 June 2006 (UTC)
Comments:
- Sorry if I sound too critical. There are a lot of distractions in this photo. It's definitely an interesting angle, even though it's a touch out of focus. As for rotating/cropping it, I think the angle of the water below balances the angle of the platform, though others may think differently. This picture might lose points in the "encyclopedic" category in that it just shows the ground, not an actual person jumping. In other words, what is this a picture of, really? It's not of a person jumping, but rather their view before they jump. That also makes the image overall a bit uninteresting. --Tewy 20:31, 28 June 2006 (UTC)
Seconder: