Wikipedia:Peer review/Sega Saturn/archive1

Sega Saturn

This peer review discussion has been closed.
Sega Saturn has had a tumultuous, but mostly positive, history over the last four months. The article was a complete mess until a user asked User:Red Phoenix to whip it into shape after a sock-puppet filled content dispute. Red did an admirable job of cleaning up and reorganizing the article, and it received promotion to GA after a rigorous and extended nomination overseen by me. User:TheTimesAreAChanging picked up the torch at that point and shifted through a large number of new and often contradictory sources to greatly improve the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the article. After a helpful FAC that further tightened the article's sourcing, but did not result in a promotion, Times decided he was satisfied with his work on the article and would not renominate. I plan to take over the FAC process from here and plan to renominate after the mandatory waiting period has expired. Any and all feedback welcome.

Thanks, Indrian (talk) 17:57, 11 June 2014 (UTC)