Wikipedia:Peer review/Providence, Rhode Island/archive1
I have decided to clean up and expand this article so that it will one day reach featured status. Nevertheless, I am open to critiques of this article, and would appreciate help with it (notably from those familiar with the city). Pentawing 05:40, 10 November 2005 (UTC)
- Not criticism in any way, but simply ideas for possible topics:
- Banks: Fleet gets two mentions but not for banking. A word about its history and merger might be in order. It's easy to speculate that people outside the area associate it more with Boston (for the former Fleet Center) rather than its Providence home. Other banks, S&Ls etc., would be valuable additions to the Economy section.
- Providence within Rhode Island: It's the capital and principal city in the state, and (I expect) the economic and cultural center. Probably people commute into the city in large numbers. The relationship between the city and the state is worth elucidating a bit more.
- "Maritime endeavors" gets passing mention only as something the city turned away from, but could be very interesting. Industry could use additional information. Who were the major players?
- Neighborhoods: Downcity, Federal Hill and the East Side get mention in three different sections of the article. Information is spread out and could be collected and augmented. Do residents organize themselves into neighborhoods on the basis of wealth, ethnic identity, or other criteria?
- The Italian poplation only gets mention in the context of Federal Hill. Could be included in history section.
- Boston has a fair amount on crime. Providence might benefit from a discussion.
- Probably, the article can reach featured status without action on any of these suggestions. Just some ideas for fleshing the article out. Fg2 06:21, 10 November 2005 (UTC)