Wikipedia:Peer review/Pinky and the Brain/archive1
(Redirected from Wikipedia:Peer review/Pinky and the Brain)
Looking at getting a peer review on this, specifically (but not inclusive to these issues) looking at:
- Article length - it's long, but breaking off subsections to separate pages may hurt the context
- References - I've made sure a lot of this article is sufficiently sourced, want to make sure that what needs referencing is
- General article quality - Particularly in "Pinky" and "Brain" sections are historically a bit more formal in language than other parts, but adequetely do the job of describing the characters.
--Masem 15:17, 2 July 2007 (UTC)
- There are some severe issues on this article with non-free content. Primarily, there are WAY too many non-free images in general, in violation of Wikipedia:Non-free content criteria #3. Specifically, there are some other problems with the images:
- Image:Pinky and the Brain vol1.jpg needs a fair-use rationale.
- Image:Pinky-and-the-brain-acme-labs.png has a fair-use rationale that is simply inaccurate, as there are no characters identified by the image.
- DVD cover art should not be used in the list of DVD releases, per WP:NFCC #8.
- Hope this helps. (ESkog)(Talk) 16:31, 2 July 2007 (UTC)
- I've added fair-use to the cover in the info box, fixed the fair-use on the acme labs bit, and cut out several pictures and the DVD covers. --Masem 16:44, 2 July 2007 (UTC)