Wikipedia:Peer review/Minnesota Vikings/archive1
Appearance
I would just like to get some feedback on how to get this article to at least GA status. RyguyMN 23:40, 2 May 2007 (UTC)
- Nice article. Just a quick reading:
- You need to make consistent citation style (see WP:CITE) because I found external links mixed with footnote citation. I suggest you to use the footnote style.
- The "ocean of blue links" somehow confuses readers. There are a lot of links to click, distracting a reader to read the whole article. I suggest editors reduce them, for instances, not to link all the years because they are not related with the subject.
- There are a lot of redundancies in the article with the History of the Minnesota Vikings. Please consider trimming the history section (see WP:SUMMARY).
- The {{see also}} (and similar) templates in the middle of a section also distracts a reader. Consider to put it just below the section heading or make an internal wikilink.
- The subsections of the "Franchise traditions, trends" section are still stubby. Please also remove "To listen to a sample of the Viking horn go to:(Vikings Tailgating) (ext. link)" statement. It is unnecessary and looks like an internal spam link (see WP:SPAM).
- So good luck. — Indon (reply) — 10:45, 3 May 2007 (UTC)
- Thanks for the comments Indon, I will focus in on those. RyguyMN 23:55, 3 May 2007 (UTC)