Wikipedia:Peer review/List of numbered highways in Tennessee
I've been working to improve the article since it was tagged for cleanup and at this point I would like some input to see if I am on the right track or what else I would need to improve the article. --Taliesin duomo (talk) 20:06, 29 December 2007 (UTC)
- Question: Currently this article is broken up into 2 separate articles (US/Interstate routes on one page, state routes on a seperate page). Is the intention to eventually merge the two or keep the two separate? I could see arguments for either case. But as currently written the article you are asking to be reviewed strongly implies they will be merged but the merge hasn't happened yet. If they will be kept separate IMO you need to remove section 3 of the article and work the link to the other article into the main paragraph.
- IMO the "Notes: mantained by TDOT" is redundant with the first statement of the article. But, I'm biased I'm against using the maintained by field in the infobox, as IMO 99.9% of the time it is redundant with something in the article. So you may want to wait for somebody else's opinion on that one.
- The Former U.S. Highways entry in the table, either needs to be removed or tagged with {{Template:Incomplete table}}.
- in the linked article List of state routes in Tennessee many routes are tagged with both a primary and secondary state route shield, what does this mean? I'm completely baffled but there is no explanation on either article.
- When you're finished could you help me clean up the article List of Nevada State Highways. =-) This one is in terrible shape, to the point I'm scared to do it alone.
- Davemeistermoab (talk) 06:06, 7 January 2008 (UTC)