Wikipedia:Peer review/Apogee Stadium/archive2
| Toolbox |
|---|
 | This peer review discussion has been closed. |
I've listed this article for peer review because I will be making a third effort to raise this up to FA status, and I want to do this the right (long, arduous) way. I'd be especially interested in any comments on clarity. I'd also like for a bit more focus on the sections after "History", because few have been directed towards those sections in past reviews. I'm also debating on whether or not to keep the top five attendance table, as I think it's a bit superfluous. I know there aren't many sources to add here, as I've covered just about everything out there on this subject, but if you have any thoughts on the veracity of those sources (good or bad) let me know.
Thanks, Runfellow (talk) 16:42, 19 December 2015 (UTC)
Here we go:
- Currently, the article is a part of nine hidden categories, two of which are categories that the article should get out of, Category:Pages containing links to subscription-only content & Category:Pages using duplicate arguments in template calls.
- References are filled out entirely according to Refill.
- I don't understand what the first paragraph in the History section has to do with the stadium. If you could explain that, otherwise delete it.
- "Richard Raefs, then vice chancellor of administrative affairs at UNT, claimed" should be rewritten as "Richard Raefs, then vice chancellor of administrative affairs at UNT, said". It sounds more netural, rather than already seeming to put the blame on someone.
- Estes bill should be possessive.
- While I understand why you did it, putting then in front of everyone's job titles does not seem necessary when you have given the date of that person's quote.
- The section Opening should have a picture of the opening, rather than a graph of attendance. It should also be renamed Opening Season or Inaugural Season, as it covers the whole season rather than just the opening game.
- File:Apogee Stadium back.jpg should not be centered at the top of a section
- Have an Other uses or Other events section, talking about what it is used for besides Football.
- Didn't check the references, but they looked good
- Have a picture of inside the stadium during a game
