Jump to content

Wikipedia:Ireland disambiguation task force/cross-usage table

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Main article: Wikipedia:Ireland disambiguation task force

There are currently many anomalies within the Ireland (island) article and its sub-articles. While many of the "Main article:" links point to their respective ROI and NI sub-articles, some of the sub-articles clearly cover the island as a whole, while some are clearly ROI articles entitled "Ireland" - which may or may not have NI's information included. Some NI-only links lead to 'redirect pages' that seamlessly lead onto the equivalent ROI articles.

The meaning of "Ireland" often changes from state to island - often within a single article, and within templates too.

Wikiprojects

[edit]
Wikiproject Republic of Ireland version Northern Ireland version "Ireland" as whole island (inc. NI) "Ireland" meaning ROI only Disam page?
Wikipedia:WikiProject Ireland Wikipedia:WikiProject Republic of Ireland Wikipedia:WikiProject Northern Ireland Wikipedia:WikiProject Ireland. The WP includes pre-1801 history and geographical articles. (many non-geographical articles listed within its scope do also cover Northern Ireland).
Portal:Ireland Portal:Republic of Ireland (covered only in Portal:Ireland) Portal:Northern Ireland Portal:Ireland

"Life in Ireland" infobox

[edit]
Sub article | wikilink Republic of Ireland version Northern Ireland version "Ireland" as whole island (inc. NI) "Ireland" meaning ROI only Disam page?
Life in Ireland infobox | Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) The "Ireland" link redirects to Republic of Ireland
Cuisine | Irish cuisine Cuisine of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Irish cuisine Cuisine of Northern Ireland redirects to Irish cuisine (an ROI-only article!) Irish cuisine
Culture | Culture of Ireland Culture of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Culture of Ireland Culture of Northern Ireland Culture of Ireland
Customs | Etiquette in Europe N/A N/A


Holidays | Public holidays in the Republic of Ireland Public holidays in the Republic of Ireland Public holidays in the United Kingdom (not linked to from infobox) Public holidays in Ireland redirects to Public holidays in the Republic of Ireland
Music | Music of Ireland Music of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Music of Ireland Music of Northern Ireland redirects to Music of Ireland Music of Ireland
Religion | Religion in the Republic of Ireland Religion in the Republic of Ireland Religion in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Religion in Ireland redirects to Republic of Ireland Religion in Ireland (not linked to from infobox)
Sport | Sport in Ireland Sport in the Republic of Ireland redirects to Sport in Ireland Sport in Northern Ireland redirects to Sport in Ireland Sport in Ireland
Comm’s | Communications in the Republic of Ireland Communications in the Republic of Ireland Communications in Northern Ireland redirects to Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Communications in Ireland redirects to Communications in the Republic of Ireland
Economy | Economy of the Republic of Ireland Economy of the Republic of Ireland Economy of Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Economy of Ireland redirects to Economy of the Republic of Ireland
Taxation | Taxation in the Republic of Ireland Taxation in the Republic of Ireland Taxation in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Taxation in Ireland redirects to Taxation in the Republic of Ireland
Transport | Transport in Ireland Transport in the Republic of Ireland redirects to Transport in Ireland Transport in Northern Ireland redirects to Transport in Ireland Transport in Ireland
Architecture | Architecture of Ireland Architecture of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Architecture of Ireland Architecture of Northern Ireland Architecture of Ireland (historical, but only one ref for Northern Ireland)
Geography | Geography of Ireland Geography of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Geography of Ireland Geography of Northern Ireland redirects to Geography of Ireland Geography of Ireland
History | History of Ireland History of the Republic of Ireland History of Northern Ireland History of Ireland
Military | Irish Defence Forces Irish Defence Forces Military in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox)
Recycling | Recycling in the Republic of Ireland Recycling in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Recycling in Ireland
Demographics | Demographics of the Republic of Ireland Demographics of the Republic of Ireland Demographics of Northern Ireland Demographics of Ireland redirects to Demographics of the Republic of Ireland
Education | Education in the Republic of Ireland Education in the Republic of Ireland Education in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Education in Ireland redirects to Education in the Republic of Ireland
Health Care | Health care in the Republic of Ireland Health care in the Republic of Ireland Health care in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Health care in Ireland redirects to Health care in the Republic of Ireland
Languages |Languages of the Republic of Ireland Languages of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Languages of Ireland Languages of Northern Ireland redirects to Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Languages of Ireland
Media | Media of Ireland Media in the Republic of Ireland Media in Northern Ireland Media in Ireland
Government | Government in Ireland Government of the Republic of Ireland redirects to Government in Ireland Government of Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Government of Ireland
Law | Law of the Republic of Ireland Law of the Republic of Ireland Northern Ireland law (not linked to from infobox) Law of Ireland redirects to Law of the Republic of Ireland
Law Enforcement | Law enforcement in Ireland Law enforcement in the Republic of Ireland Police Service of Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Law enforcement in Ireland
Politics | Politics of the Republic of Ireland Politics of the Republic of Ireland Politics of Northern Ireland Politics of Ireland
Foreign Relations | Foreign relations of the Republic of Ireland Foreign relations of the Republic of Ireland Foreign relations of Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox)
Abortion | Abortion in Ireland Abortion in the Republic of Ireland redirects to Abortion in Ireland Abortion in Northern Ireland redirects to Abortion in the United Kingdom#Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Abortion in Ireland
Civil Unions | Recognition of gay unions in Ireland Recognition of same-sex unions in the Republic of Ireland Recognition of same-sex unions in Northern Ireland (not linked to from infobox) Recognition of same-sex unions in Ireland
Prostitution | Prostitution in the Republic of Ireland Prostitution in the Republic of Ireland Prostitution in Northern Ireland (disam page leads to Prostitution in the United Kingdom) Prostitution in Ireland

Other sub-articles

[edit]

Main article: Wikipedia:Ireland disambiguation task force

This is a work in progress:

Sub article Republic of Ireland version Northern Ireland version "Ireland" as whole island (inc. NI) "Ireland" meaning ROI only Disam page?
Rail Transport Rail transport in the Republic of Ireland redirects to Rail transport in Ireland Rail transport in Northern Ireland redirects to Rail transport in Ireland Rail transport in Ireland

Footnotes

[edit]