Jump to content

Wikipedia:Here (talk)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

It is common for an editor to use the word "here" on a talk page, as if it obviously did not mean

here on the page you're reading

but rather

well, you know, over there, on that page that this page always "Talks" about,

i.e.,

on the non-talk page (the article, WP page, template page, category page, etc.) that shares the SUBJECTPAGENAME of this talk page that you [the user who is reading not the essay, but the talk-page,] are reading.

The first contributor to this essay -- a self-confessed perfectionist, who is aware that this essay probably only represents a minority viewpoint -- has made a practice of writing, instead, either "on the accompanying article page" (or -- when willing to stop and think about whether only one article is under discussion) "in the article". That contributor also sees piping the word "here", on talk pages, to this essay as an alternative (and perhaps less distracting) practice, that still lessens the opportunity for confusion that is at least theoretically invited by the ambiguous use of "here", which use seems to be reflexive for many of our colleagues.

That is, instead of writing on a talk page

It's irrelevant for the accompanying article to say "Kozlowski was later convicted in New York state court and sentenced to prison for his role in various improprieties during his time as Tyco's CEO."

one can write

It's irrelevant here that "Kozlowski was later convicted in New York state court and sentenced to prison for his role in various improprieties during his time as Tyco's CEO."

(in which the bolding reflects the fact that, on this essay page, that link is a self-link, not a live link to this essay).