Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/The Adventures of Pete & Pete/archive1
This show is probably one of the most unique and fondly remembered shows of the 1990's. A quick google search of it shows just how large a following it has. There is a lot to be written about it, from its quirky story lines to its awesome music, and I think making it a featured article would be really great. —This unsigned comment was added by Ahummer (talk • contribs) .
- object Evaluating a featured article is about the quality of the actual article, not how much we like or dislike its subject. This article looks okay I guess, but is not FA quality. Among other things, there are no references at all, let alone inline citations. Pretty glaring problem right there. It only has only one image, and that is of unclear copyright status. Certainly could be more for an FA on this topic. There's not much in the way of brilliant prose, or actual prose at all really. The "setting" section is the most fleshed out, mostly this is just a compillation of episodes, characters and guest stars... what does this really tell someone who isn't a fan already? It's probably not particularly interesting or useful. --W.marsh 03:54, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
- Object. (1) No inline citations. (2) Too much lists and not enough prose. (3) A better copyright tag is needed for the image. (4) Some POV problems (e.g., the Content section). (5) Some mention of critical reviews is necessary for comprehensiveness, and would help to foster NPOV. A quick search of Google finds that, for example, there were some problems with the video of the season 1 DVD. [1], [2]. — TKD::Talk 04:01, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
- Object Article is a series of lists with little information besides fancraft (i.e., character descriptions, episode guides, etc.). It's not FA material, and should become more article and less "list". --Ataricodfish 06:04, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
- Object I loved this show growing up, but the information is slim. A bit more about the broad themes of the show would be good.--Evadb 13:05, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
- Comment The nominator has only had 2 posts..
one of themboth of them here.. Highway 18:10, 29 March 2006 (UTC)