Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/BBC News/archive1
I think this is a very good article which should be given a showing as a featured article. Wikiwoohoo 16:29, 26 November 2005 (UTC)
Object. There are lots of problems:
- Missing references.
- Some sections are too short, there is not enough context.
- The BBC News logo image needs a fair use rationale.
- The 'History' section should be the first section.
— Wackymacs 17:08, 26 November 2005 (UTC)
Object - It is extremely short on information, see BBC's own History of BBC News and About BBC News. Some specifics:
- History incomplete. Here it starts in 1993, on BBC News own history timeline: 1922
- Hardly any information on current organization. Number of employees, organizational hierarchy, annual budget, etc, etc
- Arbitrary lists. The "selection of" lists are vague: why these? are these random selections? With no background information.
There are more specific points, but just with the above, clearly the article needs a MAJOR amount of work... --Tsavage 03:34, 27 November 2005 (UTC)
- Thanks to all those who gave comments. Your help is very much appreciated. PLease post any more ideas you have at this peer review of the article. Thanks! Wikiwoohoo 16:26, 28 November 2005 (UTC)