User talk:Vkouakou/sandbox
Vkouakou's peer review
[edit]I think that your explanation of the different types of gerrymandering are interesting and relevant information for the article overall. However, I think it relies too heavily on the ProPublica source. It would help clear any chances of bias by including at least one other source to explain the four types.
-The bullet point "Packing" specifically could use a second source, because it makes two statements that need verification: When the party controlling the districting process has a statewide majority, packing is usually not necessary to attain partisan advantage; the minority party can generally be "cracked" everywhere. Packing is therefore more likely to be used for partisan advantage when the party controlling the districting process has a statewide minority, because by forfeiting a few districts packed with the opposition, cracking can be used in forming the remaining districts.
-It is very helpful that you added information and sources to the table in the article!
Good job! Mikerailey (talk) 04:05, 3 April 2018 (UTC)