User talk:Dxneo
(Redirected from User talk:Neo the Twin)
| This is Dxneo's talk page, where you can send him messages and comments. |
|
Archives: 1, 2, 3Auto-archiving period: 14 days  |
Hello. Is Euphoria Magazine considered reliable?
[edit]I am asking you as you are a more experienced editor than me and so I am asking since honestly even though Euphoria claims to be a magazine, it's a blog. I've seen it used here multiple times. They have pretty good information on Tyla's Push 2 Start.[[1] Another thing is about "On and On" personally after looking through pageviews I think it should be made back into an article but it's up to you. It received over 20k pageviews during it's time as an article, that's actually really good for a single that was promotional and is more than both Been Thinking and Girl Next Door combined. Let me know what you think. This0k (talk) 19:24, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
References
- ^ Okechukwu, Nmesoma (2024-10-12). "Tyla – Push 2 Start". EUPHORIA. Retrieved 2024-12-09.
- Seems like Euphoria is a blog and blogs are usually considered unreliable. However, if you can find at least two reliable publications referencing Euphoria, we can consider it reliable and even take it to WP:RS/N to assess its reliability. As for "On and On", it's not surprising that it had so much views because it's a "Tyla song" haha. Just that, what were those viewers reading, because the article didn't have much? The label never pushed it, no radio date, minimal stage performance, only appeared on the UK and the US Afrobeats charts, even after I created the user Ss112 told me that it wasn't necessary due to the above reasons. Another thing is the Tyla Tour, it will also be redirected to the album if Tyla doesn't do anything about it. Now she's doing SA Tour which has nothing to do with the Tyla Tour. Hope you understand mate. dxneo (talk) 19:39, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
- Well I personally think On and On is notable since it was included on her album and had a Colors show that received lots of notability. That's how people found it because they were searching for it on Wikipedia because of the Colors show and it being on her album, but it's not anything really but 20k is still a lot because it's actually more than even her song Art which had a whole music video and promotions and radio,which is something to definitely consider. Art has only gained 9k views since and that means On and On is definitely very notable. I will also recreate it if you want but I need to know first and find it kind of strange Ss112 was against it despite the pageviews. Her songs usually peak and then fall as seen with songs like Art but that does not change their notability.This0k (talk) 19:45, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
- I can promote "Art" to GA at any given time, I'm just too lazy. "On and On" Can't even get to C-class, that's why. Of course "On and On" is notable, but not because it's on her album. I have preserved its content here on this redirect history just in case we might wanna bring it back some day. I was surprised when I found out the gap between "Cruel Summer"'s release date and radio date. That's why I preserved the history instead of seeking deletion. Another thing, I'm trying to promote the album to WP:Good topic and since "On and On" cannot be expanded, Good topic cannot happen. Hope you understand. dxneo (talk) 20:33, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
- Also seems I was looking at redirect, Art actually has 26k page views so that's actually not bad at all but I don't think it will get GA either right now, the article does not look as expanded as others like Truth or Dare, an article you brought to GA. Looking at both side by side Art looks like B article not GA, and you know that as well. Unless you mean you can't be bothered to expand it which is clear from looking at the two, Truth or Dare clearly has had significant expansion, I feel as though Art could benefit from a peer review if you are too lazy in my opinion.This0k (talk) 02:34, 12 December 2024 (UTC)
- Peer review won't help. We gonna have to expand it. If I do it alone it will take at least 2–3 days. I'll do it after I get Tyla and "Water" to GA. Around late January I'll get "Push 2 Start to GA, and the album to FA. I'm gonna need your help with sources tho. dxneo (talk) 05:40, 12 December 2024 (UTC)
- Also seems I was looking at redirect, Art actually has 26k page views so that's actually not bad at all but I don't think it will get GA either right now, the article does not look as expanded as others like Truth or Dare, an article you brought to GA. Looking at both side by side Art looks like B article not GA, and you know that as well. Unless you mean you can't be bothered to expand it which is clear from looking at the two, Truth or Dare clearly has had significant expansion, I feel as though Art could benefit from a peer review if you are too lazy in my opinion.This0k (talk) 02:34, 12 December 2024 (UTC)
- I can promote "Art" to GA at any given time, I'm just too lazy. "On and On" Can't even get to C-class, that's why. Of course "On and On" is notable, but not because it's on her album. I have preserved its content here on this redirect history just in case we might wanna bring it back some day. I was surprised when I found out the gap between "Cruel Summer"'s release date and radio date. That's why I preserved the history instead of seeking deletion. Another thing, I'm trying to promote the album to WP:Good topic and since "On and On" cannot be expanded, Good topic cannot happen. Hope you understand. dxneo (talk) 20:33, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
- Well I personally think On and On is notable since it was included on her album and had a Colors show that received lots of notability. That's how people found it because they were searching for it on Wikipedia because of the Colors show and it being on her album, but it's not anything really but 20k is still a lot because it's actually more than even her song Art which had a whole music video and promotions and radio,which is something to definitely consider. Art has only gained 9k views since and that means On and On is definitely very notable. I will also recreate it if you want but I need to know first and find it kind of strange Ss112 was against it despite the pageviews. Her songs usually peak and then fall as seen with songs like Art but that does not change their notability.This0k (talk) 19:45, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
Your Talk page : the Consequences
[edit]
|
The Purple Barnstar | |
| For keeping your temper pretty well and deescalating by yourself a dire situation despite being wrongly accused. Congrats, and keep editing ! Larrayal (talk) 21:53, 25 August 2021 (UTC) |
P.S. : For data protection reasons, still keep lengthy offtopic and personnal discussions off wiki as in the guideline. Not a warning, but a reminder ! Larrayal (talk) 23:59, 11 December 2024 (UTC)
- Thank you mate. Guess I'll be a lot more careful next time. You are appreciated. dxneo (talk) 05:45, 12 December 2024 (UTC)